M1036 Flipless Coven Hunt I Game Thread

[damo666]

[]10a8d6671173c12fdef673bf2f913a01[]

Sigh. Was I this obnoxious @damo?

Eh?

[BunnyGo]

I learned Butter has played more no flip mafia than I have; quite a bit it sounds like. And that one game she played two town decided to use up their powers and commit suicide to prove they’re town…so she plays with a group I can’t quite fathom but seems to go for peer pressure a lot.

I learned Butter is more focused on mechs (at least publicly) than learning facts about us players. She was disinterested in learning about our pronouns, and while she volunteered facts about her parents, didn’t pull any from us and ignored Bona’s attempt to offer some.

Interestingly, Chomps also refused ny offer early game to learn about me.

Why is that interesting?

When you play this game with strangers, do you find it easier or harder to hunt if you don’t know anything about them?

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

@yavuzovic
e57ba573883d943cfa4dfaf328a

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

I don't ENTIRELY agree with that as a blanket statement, but yes, in a game where roles give zero alignment information, hiding your role from the wolfpack (t least at the BEGINNING) is more important than usual. Witches will know which roles are village aligned and it allows them to plan optimally, but doesn't clear you to fellow villagers. We can't even accept what you said as factual when you die unless you die at night--which PROBABLY but not DEFINITELY means you a villager or unless a village aligned Gravedigger gets your reveal.

It's a great game build for finding witches by trying to manipulate vs "solve by power and follow the information roles" but the rate at which information gets out is important. There is no angel, for example, until a village player dies. Once we know definitively that has happened, we can play a bit more openly.

Would you support a massclaim? Then everyone’s roles are out in the open and we can just play mafia and the sniper becomes a vig (which is good if they’re town).

The mice already know each other. And odds are at least one is scum so the whole scum team knows.

If scum is apprentice, they know another that way and can even try to get their choice killed quickly to take the power from town.

If they have a different investigative role, they’ll learn more roles that way.

Bunny advocating for a massclaim on D1?

Eep.

personally I read it as bunny either being the sniper or having a scummate who is the sniper
bona-bunny-???

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

If we don't vote together today, I suggest town!sniper to kill miminena

you're taking the path of least resistance: speedrunnning to get poison
a town mouse would actually have reads. You have shitpushes and red herring ciphers, therefore you are not town
##vote yavuzovic

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

i hate mechs talk

this is lame

why are you trying to discourage mech talk?
perhaps you realize you might be outted as the third mouse soon?
or perhaps you simply don't want mech ideas to be shared?

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

##vote Diploma Cyan Dwarf Are

dw's brazenness here feels a bit like he's trying to emulate his town play. like he does have the whole reaction test thing but it doesn't really feel like he's going anywhere with it; in his town games that i've experienced he has an obvious direction to his tunnels and sticks with them, but in his scum game he kind of just moved around before settling on someone to go after. overall i just don't think he's being genuine in his posts abt jamie but idk

So your argument is that since I'm not aggressively tunnneling, I must be scum?
this is like that one game I don't have time to find right now
eh
ill find it later if I don't get shitpushed to death

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

I gtg and I will probably not make EoD
apologies for low participation today
see you on the other side

[BunnyGo]

i hate mechs talk

this is lame

why are you trying to discourage mech talk?
perhaps you realize you might be outted as the third mouse soon?
or perhaps you simply don't want mech ideas to be shared?

Why are you posting this wall of responses out of order to the posts you're responding to?

[BunnyGo]

I gtg and I will probably not make EoD
apologies for low participation today
see you on the other side

A wild Diplomacy&Warfare appeared and disappeared!

[damo666]

is Dip mouse #3?

[BunnyGo]

is Dip mouse #3?

I doubt it...I don't think either yavu would have chosen Mimi...

[yavuzovic]

@yavuzovic
e57ba573883d943cfa4dfaf328a

I'm not using hashes to communicate with you. I'm using them for leaving notes for tomorrow.

[Bonatogether]

Everyone, ##vote mimi with me. I can explain my reasoning but the less information we distribute the better

thumbs down

[Bonatogether]

I'm the daughter of a teacher and a librarian. Punctuation is in my blood.

i'm educated too (nominally) but punctuation is short for punctu-lame-ation

You thought that was a brag on my supposed education? O-kay. Bragging about my parent's education would be almost as lame as being proud of posting without commas.

i convey everything i want to without use of punctuation

[Bonatogether]

I am posting from North America in Central Daylight Time.

if you're not british you don't have an excuse for using periods or commas

Are you actually Linda McMahon?

vince

[Bonatogether]

Tell us what you learned from the response(s)?

I learned Butter has played more no flip mafia than I have; quite a bit it sounds like. And that one game she played two town decided to use up their powers and commit suicide to prove they’re town…so she plays with a group I can’t quite fathom but seems to go for peer pressure a lot.

I learned Butter is more focused on mechs (at least publicly) than learning facts about us players. She was disinterested in learning about our pronouns, and while she volunteered facts about her parents, didn’t pull any from us and ignored Bona’s attempt to offer some.

Okay, thank you.

I do not think a lack of interest in Bona's parents is automatically alignment indicative. A lot of people outside this community have never heard of President Eden. We tend to forget that.

where is eden these days

[Bonatogether]

guys there are too many mechs things happening and this stinks

who here watches baseball?

[brainbomb]

Yes I know. Why does that negate anything I said?

The sniper will never shoot because they think someone is lying about a role

##CALL GM: If the sniper guesses wrong, is their shot still used up?

Yes

[Bonatogether]

i hate mechs talk

this is lame

why are you trying to discourage mech talk?
perhaps you realize you might be outted as the third mouse soon?
or perhaps you simply don't want mech ideas to be shared?

mechs talk in this game inherently will not lead to finding scum, and lets scum hide behind an appearance of doing something.