M1036 Flipless Coven Hunt I Game Thread

[Bonatogether]

if roles aren't alignment indicative we should massclaim for kicks

Sniper may not be town....

OH! There's also a role "the Judge", if the day ends in a tie, they get to decide who dies. Can be anyone, not just the wagons involved.

ok but then we can find the sniper

[Bonatogether]

Yes, you're right. Poor arithmetic => damo is scum!

is it pronounced air-eth-meh-tic or arith-muh-tic

the latter

whenever i write arthmetic i'm using the other pronunciation btw

[damo666]

is it pronounced air-eth-meh-tic or arith-muh-tic

the latter

whenever i write arthmetic i'm using the other pronunciation btw

that's scummy

[damo666]

Bunny and mimi town

only reads so far

[Bonatogether]

the latter

whenever i write arthmetic i'm using the other pronunciation btw

that's scummy

sorry we can't all speak the king's english

[Bonatogether]

Bunny and mimi town

only reads so far

why is mimir town for you? they've felt sleepy to me

[Chomps]

@Chomps are you new to mafia or did you come from MU?

4 years of playing mafia! Still bad at it though, spent most of my time playing high-power button pressing social ignoring setups and town of salem, but the latest year or two I've been picking up on low power and social ones

[damo666]

Bunny and mimi town

only reads so far

why is mimir town for you? they've felt sleepy to me

vibes really, nothing more specific I'm afraid.

[Bonatogether]

@Chomps are you new to mafia or did you come from MU?

4 years of playing mafia! Still bad at it though, spent most of my time playing high-power button pressing social ignoring setups and town of salem, but the latest year or two I've been picking up on low power and social ones

what in tarnation

[Bonatogether]

Bunny and mimi town

only reads so far

why is mimir town for you? they've felt sleepy to me

vibes really, nothing more specific I'm afraid.

do vibes come from a post or from an aesthetic

[Jamiet99uk]

Okay I'm back ##Unvote

I did some analysis between games and it turns out announcing that you're "back" is statistically scummy
##vote jamie

Show your working.

[Jamiet99uk]

I agree on the first two but got 53.3 for the last one

Yes, you're right. Poor arithmetic => damo is scum!

is it pronounced air-eth-meh-tic or arith-muh-tic

"Maths"

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

Okay I'm back ##Unvote

I did some analysis between games and it turns out announcing that you're "back" is statistically scummy
##vote jamie

Show your working.

my "working" is a reaction test, and you appear to be calm and rational
so, not town jamie
the vote stays

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

@Chomps are you new to mafia or did you come from MU?

4 years of playing mafia! Still bad at it though, spent most of my time playing high-power button pressing social ignoring setups and town of salem, but the latest year or two I've been picking up on low power and social ones

what in tarnation

@chomps
you're a speed mafia player?

[Jamiet99uk]

I did some analysis between games and it turns out announcing that you're "back" is statistically scummy
##vote jamie

Show your working.

my "working" is a reaction test, and you appear to be calm and rational
so, not town jamie
the vote stays

so tired of this
gfy

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

OK, so my thoughts on mechs and knowledge, because there are some people who know things the rest of us do not.

Knowledge
Who knows stuff beyond their own role and/or alignment?

Scum know everyone's alignment (this is fairly normal with only 2 teams)
Apprentice knows someone else's role (either Inquisitor, Gravedigger, or Watchman).

3 Mice know each other's roles. And the odds at least one mouse is a scum is pretty decent (@damo, would you enjoy calculating this?)

If scum are Apprentice or mice then the OTHER scum also know that information too because of N0.

Inquisitor will eventually learn yes/no about people's roles into two different groups. Inquisitor can choose to publicly signal that information to apprentice if apprentice chose watchman and knows to look for it. If inquisitor pings same person and the answer changes, then that person was apprentice and now has upgraded to information role (I checked with GM). Risk is that Apprentice may be scum so might not want to help the coven.

Gravedigger will learn the role AND alignment of people dying on odd days. Can also signal this information to apprentice if apprentice knows who they are. If Gravedigger doesn't want to pass role info, but should almost certainly pass alignment info.

Watchman will learn one of a mouse, apprentice, savior, sniper. Can pass on to apprentice if apprentice knows who they are, but may worry about scum!apprentice.

Action:

Sniper: Can kill if they know a role. If there's a scum!sniper, they can almost certainly kill a mouse or someone else they'll learn about via powers. This has made Bona's "say your role" particularly weird...but I assume he didn't read the rules and/or assumed I'd just lie.

So in addition to scum knowing alignment information, other people will also be hiding information as a group.

I'm not sure if the mice should be trying to off each other or not.

I'm not sure if the Inquisitor or Watchman should be signalling the apprentice, but the Gravedigger should probably be signalling at least Coven/Town somehow. Just because it can't help scum!Apprentice, and might help Town!Apprentice.

mech wall of information I already know and bad opinions
NAI

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

Show your working.

my "working" is a reaction test, and you appear to be calm and rational
so, not town jamie
the vote stays

so tired of this
gfy

is "this" reaction testing, or the expectation that town jamie is calmer than scum jamie?

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

Hello everyone,
2eefb7a1221d57943bfa3fcec3980adf
:)

I won't be able to play tonight but I will be here tomorrow

imagine only having one line of cipher to soft lol
DPIVEJSTM
GMK NKB RES
FMTSJCNSOEPDS
QFFHUDJYSV
YMLY (SOENVT)
VJPZOD (OSPTMS)
SILLY FUNNY RATHER SCUMMY PROBABLY LYING
POTENTIALLY NOT
TPECIVJSYV
PLEASE NOTE THAT THIS IS ALL MISDIRECTION FOR THE MAFIA TO TRY TO SOLVE, ALL TOWN PLAYERS PLEASE IGNORE
TSIOS-ROAB-SOFS-WMBY
FJVTPXW
SODFMST
NSCGTVOHCJSIRSEVTJTEUBBO
IG-DPSSGHM
NBWCWEHAOYYRTSP
GART (SJSVT)
CJSVCEK
SVAPUBLEUCJOMUWTJE
JIONUDJOMBVTSPPDVTUYSIOVUSJTVADUVEUSKEURDLIEIDVISE
THSBBIRR
HYS VIRISKVUSOR VIDJS WSLSKVRAV JTSSGTEUC EOSCSNVJD SHSJDO
BYRARCDJURBC (WRWO)
LTOBHKBLKXTEERPXTD

There is absolutely no shot anyone is going to try and decode this

One day Dip will appear out of the shadows and decode and magically guess every single role or something

I'm currently having problems determining who the spiritualist is. Any thoughts?

[ButterscotchReader]

Bunny and mimi town

only reads so far

I'm on board about mimi, but now that Bunny has backed off his "I'm a lying liar who lies" opening, he's squarely null for me again. Would you share your thoughts on Bunny?

[damo666]

Bunny and mimi town

only reads so far

I'm on board about mimi, but now that Bunny has backed off his "I'm a lying liar who lies" opening, he's squarely null for me again. Would you share your thoughts on Bunny?

Bunny's work on roles suggests town [prima facie]