Mafia XL - A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum

[flash2015]

Flash - damo - DRC - ghug(?) worcej(?)

Are you still voting for me today? If yes, why?

[flash2015]

The only valid votes for a towny today are DrCJG or DemonRHK

[peterlund]

The bot not picking up votes after last code update I think is fixed now. Thanks Fox for reporting...

[ghug]

DrC, what did you learn from holding your claim?

[bo_sox48]

Wow that was an incredibly hilarious turn of events

[bo_sox48]

Hypo #2: I am actually the doctor, I may have been pretty sure who the Observer was and thought Demon was lying... but I could only really be sure after he said who he had visited and that he hadn't seen me visit. I have cc'd so that our observer remains hidden. But, I don't really want to give away who I visited because it may lead to who I believe may be the observer and more importantly there is literally nothing I can do to prove it other than have the observer vouch for me... which is obviously not preferred.

Here is what I read this hypothetical as:

I am town. Town is one day away from MYLO. Under these circumstances, I am willing to take a chance on outing myself as a PR and lynching another player that might be a PR because... I think he's lying?

I hope this isn't your strategy and that you just thought of this because you're upset that you made it so obvious what role you're trying to claim. If we lynch you and RHK in the next two days and both of you turn out to be PRs because this was your plan, please go play mafia elsewhere.

[Foxcastle]

The bot not picking up votes after last code update I think is fixed now. Thanks Fox for reporting...

Thank you, Peter! Players are encouraged to +1 Peter's post above.

[Foxcastle]

VOTE COUNT

DrCJG (4) — Squigs44, damo666, ND, DemonRHK
flash2015 (2) — ghug, Durga
damo666 (2) — bozotheclown, worcej
DemonRHK (2) — DrCJG, flash2015
ghug (1) — bo_sox48
Unvote (1) — rdrivera2005

DRCJG is on the chopping block!

3 hours and 15 minutes remain in Day 5.

[DemonRHK]

Waiting 42 hours to counterclaim, and being overly secretive and vague is just trying to incite confusion and try to obscure DrC’s teammates.

This is a sac play to save the driver to make sure I die tonight, I’m sure of it.

[Squigs44]

Oh...

##Vote DemonRHK

Everyone sheep me now.

[Squigs44]

Things make so much more sense now.

[Squigs44]

This is one of those moments that Squigs has solved something and you all sheep me. Dr is town, Demon is scum. No further questions.

[DemonRHK]

You need to put thoughts down. You’re buying the vaguest counterclaim I’ve ever seen, why?

[Squigs44]

You need to put thoughts down. You’re buying the vaguest counterclaim I’ve ever seen, why?

I said no further questions. Who are your scummates though?

[flash2015]

This is one of those moments that Squigs has solved something and you all sheep me. Dr is town, Demon is scum. No further questions.

I think you are sheeping me!

[Squigs44]

This is one of those moments that Squigs has solved something and you all sheep me. Dr is town, Demon is scum. No further questions.

I think you are sheeping me!

Lol

[DrCJG]

Why did you not at least start a Demon wagon earlier in the day? Or have you not been around until now?

1) Voting him certainly would put a spotlight on me... when I think a reread of me makes it clear I was trying to avoid that.

2) No one who questioned Demon's claim voted him... though that could be because they knew he was scum...

Waiting 42 hours to counterclaim, and being overly secretive and vague is just trying to incite confusion and try to obscure DrC’s teammates.

This is a sac play to save the driver to make sure I die tonight, I’m sure of it.

Respect for the play. You have done an excellent job of repeating what my "confused teammates" are yelling.

Would you care to provide further evidence of your supposed claim?

Hypo #2: I am actually the doctor, I may have been pretty sure who the Observer was and thought Demon was lying... but I could only really be sure after he said who he had visited and that he hadn't seen me visit. I have cc'd so that our observer remains hidden. But, I don't really want to give away who I visited because it may lead to who I believe may be the observer and more importantly there is literally nothing I can do to prove it other than have the observer vouch for me... which is obviously not preferred.

Here is what I read this hypothetical as:

I am town. Town is one day away from MYLO. Under these circumstances, I am willing to take a chance on outing myself as a PR and lynching another player that might be a PR because... I think he's lying?

I hope this isn't your strategy and that you just thought of this because you're upset that you made it so obvious what role you're trying to claim. If we lynch you and RHK in the next two days and both of you turn out to be PRs because this was your plan, please go play mafia elsewhere.

Well I am not sure why you chose to read it that way... I am confident he is lying... and I assure you, that under hypo #2 I am certain of that.

[rdrivera2005]

Things make so much more sense now.

Can you share what you discovered?

I am completely torn on this claim thing, Demon was scummy and a fake claim to save himself make more sense then Dr claiming to save driver. But the timing and lack of specifics make it less credible.

I will sheep you know (and Flash will jump in my throat....).

##vote Demon

[ghug]

This is one of those moments that Squigs has solved something and you all sheep me. Dr is town, Demon is scum. No further questions.

Nah


DrC, you ignored my question: What did you learn by waiting? Why did you choose to claim when you did and not, say, last night, or an hour before the deadline?

[DemonRHK]

You need to put thoughts down. You’re buying the vaguest counterclaim I’ve ever seen, why?

I said no further questions. Who are your scummates though?

Ok, congratulations on pushing the largest gamethrow since me about 20 games ago.