Mafia XXXIV Game Thread - Who Framed Roger Rabbit?

[rdrivera2005]

I can't see a reason why Nurse didn't save Maniac and he told he wasn't roleblocked.

[DemonRHK]

I can't see a reason why Nurse didn't save Maniac and he told he wasn't roleblocked.

Exactly why I am confused.

[Tom Bombadil]

I also don’t buy RHKs claim for a second. Watcher is the most important town role - you claimed quite hastily.

Real watcher should not cc

[thamrick]

What's the case on RHK Maniac?

I REALLY don't like the claim. Like REALLY, REALLY don't like it. But I had been pretty firmly townreading RHK before that.

The claim makes me fine with shooting RHK though. If he actually is PR, it's piss poor town play to give it up so easily without attempting to mount a defense for himself.

[DemonRHK]

I also don’t buy RHKs claim for a second. Watcher is the most important town role - you claimed quite hastily.

Real watcher should not cc

Better out than dead. Thanks for that fake claim, btw. You have no idea how pissed off your retraction made me.

[rdrivera2005]

I also don't believe the claim but I think we can easily sort this out with the Cop, so shooting a claimant is unnecessary right now.

[Tom Bombadil]

Your welcome. Convince me you are the Watcher and we can talk

[Tom Bombadil]

##vote MeanLaQueefa

[rdrivera2005]

What's the case on RHK Maniac?

I REALLY don't like the claim. Like REALLY, REALLY don't like it. But I had been pretty firmly townreading RHK before that.

The claim makes me fine with shooting RHK though. If he actually is PR, it's piss poor town play to give it up so easily without attempting to mount a defense for himself.

This is one of the scumiest post I have seen this game. Basically you said it's fine to shoot the Watcher because he is playing badly.

[Maniac]

I also don't believe the claim but I think we can easily sort this out with the Cop, so shooting a claimant is unnecessary right now.

Yep, it was obvious scum DemonRHK would fakeclaim, so we'll let him get scanned. DemonRHK could be genuine of course and if so we need him around.

[Hellenic Riot]

##GM Note: The Nurse RB's at night no matter what, yes.

[rdrivera2005]

I think shooting Mean or Meme isn't a bad idea. Maybe this force them to play for their life.

[DemonRHK]

Your welcome. Convince me you are the Watcher and we can talk

I can never fault someone for going with their gut. But I can fault you for your reasoning. That'd be like me saying you've setup a lurk excuse because you're portraying yourself as a cineophile, and could say 'Oh I was out, sorry'

A cineophile is someone who watches a ton of movies.

brainbomb - Moderate Town - At this point, I don't see brain being scum in nearly any situation. He's bragged about winning flawlessly as scum, Brain is too proud to be bussing that hard. However, he seems lonely lately without Rj to talk with and keep up with his post count. Counterclaimed cop...I dunno anymore. He's playing 50D Chutes and Ladders.

Crumbing the N1 and the result.

[rdrivera2005]

I can't believe Nurse choosed to save Tham out of the blue, so he was probably RBed by scum (or is scum claiming the RB) and Nurse tried to save BB.

[DemonRHK]

What's the case on RHK Maniac?

I REALLY don't like the claim. Like REALLY, REALLY don't like it. But I had been pretty firmly townreading RHK before that.

The claim makes me fine with shooting RHK though. If he actually is PR, it's piss poor town play to give it up so easily without attempting to mount a defense for himself.

And fuck you very much. If I'd only said 'don't shoot me I'm town' or 'don't shoot me I'm a PR', and got shot after trying to reinforce that stance, you'd be trying to replace #BoIsTheWorst with #RHKIsTheWorst.

[Foxcastle]

I wasn't going to hear you out on your claim, DemonRHK, but if you're not even going to try...

[DemonRHK]

I can't believe Nurse choosed to save Tham out of the blue, so he was probably RBed by scum (or is scum claiming the RB) and Nurse tried to save BB.

Wait what? If the Nurse was on BB he'd be spamming up the thread with us.

[thamrick]

What's the case on RHK Maniac?

I REALLY don't like the claim. Like REALLY, REALLY don't like it. But I had been pretty firmly townreading RHK before that.

The claim makes me fine with shooting RHK though. If he actually is PR, it's piss poor town play to give it up so easily without attempting to mount a defense for himself.

This is one of the scumiest post I have seen this game. Basically you said it's fine to shoot the Watcher because he is playing badly.

Do you believe his claim? Like at all? From a town perspective, why give up that you're watcher? That's a powerful role we have. He literally didn't even try to defend himself. It's obviously a fishing claim.

[Tom Bombadil]

Hmmm. That second brain crumb seems legit. What to do..what to do...

[rdrivera2005]

I can't believe Nurse choosed to save Tham out of the blue, so he was probably RBed by scum (or is scum claiming the RB) and Nurse tried to save BB.

Wait what? If the Nurse was on BB he'd be spamming up the thread with us.

True, it was stupid. So, I don't know.