Mafia XXXIV Game Thread - Who Framed Roger Rabbit?

[brainbomb]

@BB - why did you immediately follow me onto RJ D1 only to spend the rest of the day defending him?

Cuz im totes scum obviously.

[Tom Bombadil]

tham is scum.

Even that question he asked bb tries to paint himself in a good light by reminding everyone he voted RJ D1 - he doesn't even care about brains answer, he just wants to push the narrative that he voted for scum D1.

[thamrick]

Who here has played with thamrick before? Is he a softie like me?

He looks shitty D2, especially since he didn't vote rj - who he scumread all of D1. That being said, if he is a softie like me, he might not be scum. Rj was a brand new player to mafia, so you have to be particularily harsh (and brave consider you don't know how he will react) to bus a brand new player D1. I would be very reluctant to bus someone who is new to mafia and drew scum their first game.

I'm not going to answer your first question as either way, it isn't believable.

This game's players I've played with:
Balki Bartokomous
bo_sox48
brainbomb
DemonRHK
Jamiet99uk
Maniac
ND
reedeer1
VashtaNeurotic

I played M19 and M20. Town in M19, 3rd party in M20.

I don't know if any of them will remember much of me as I wasn't a high volume poster in either of those games.



@Tom -
"I would be very reluctant to bus someone who is new to mafia and drew scum their first game."

- Is that why you only addressed him directly twice this game?

@rj: why would you shoot those people?

rj:

Why did you say that Jamie's flip totally blindsided you? It seems weird to me as I didn't get the impression that you have a townread of him on D1.

Seems weird to me that you have him listed in your acceptable lynches both times you posted them, yet never questioned him and still arrived at:

##vote rjmcf

I can't vote for someone just coming in as a sub - it seems cruel. rj's been on my radar since his reaction to Jamie's lynch. Will try to expand on this this afternoon.

The second of the above direct-address quotes is after the rj vote. Walk me through your vote reasoning for Rj please. What about Rj's reaction to the Jamiet lynch put him on your radar? A lot of things put Rj on my radar that come to mind, without looking back I can't remember anything about his reaction, and I was pretty focused on Rj at the time.

[brainbomb]

I dont find thamrick to be scummy in terms of gamesolving.

Its purely guilt by association/dissociation

[brainbomb]

I wanna lynch yavuz

[Tom Bombadil]

Just because I didn't directly address someone more than twice doesn't mean they shouldn't be an acceptable lynch. I bet the majority of my acceptable lynch pool at that time consisted of people whom I hadn't addressed often.

rj's reaction was fishy because it seemed insincere. He said he was "totally blindsided by Jamie's flip." That came across as forced because D1 he seemed to have a slight scumread of Jamie - suspicion at least - so I'm not sure why he would have been shocked at the flip.

[Tom Bombadil]

I'll post my new lynchpool soon, but yavuz will be in it too brain.

[thamrick]

I dont find thamrick to be scummy in terms of gamesolving.

Its purely guilt by association/dissociation

I get that. I've been on the wrong wagon both times, when I was scumreading the right wagon. I was strangely Jamiet's consistent townread. And Rj had me as a weak hedgy scumread. I get the case against me. And if I need to hang for it, so be it. I just think it shouldn't be a crime to be wrong. You'd think if I had prior knowledge, I would've been right at some point. If I'd been bussing both Jamiet and Rj by scumreading them, wouldn't I know it would look bad when they flipped and I wasn't on their wagon?

[brainbomb]

I dont find thamrick to be scummy in terms of gamesolving.

Its purely guilt by association/dissociation

I get that. I've been on the wrong wagon both times, when I was scumreading the right wagon. I was strangely Jamiet's consistent townread. And Rj had me as a weak hedgy scumread. I get the case against me. And if I need to hang for it, so be it. I just think it shouldn't be a crime to be wrong. You'd think if I had prior knowledge, I would've been right at some point. If I'd been bussing both Jamiet and Rj by scumreading them, wouldn't I know it would look bad when they flipped and I wasn't on their wagon?

Naw. Yer pretty low on my list. No urgency.

You deserve longer life than fuckin worthless reedeer or yavuz. Or even bo

[Tom Bombadil]

Scum say: "@BB - why did you immediately follow me onto RJ D1 only to spend the rest of the day defending him?"

Town concerned with solving the game would ask: "@BB - why did you vote RJ D1 only to spend the rest of the day defending him?"

Only scum would force in a bit about how they voted RJ D1. Its defensive.

[thamrick]

Just because I didn't directly address someone more than twice doesn't mean they shouldn't be an acceptable lynch. I bet the majority of my acceptable lynch pool at that time consisted of people whom I hadn't addressed often.

rj's reaction was fishy because it seemed insincere. He said he was "totally blindsided by Jamie's flip." That came across as forced because D1 he seemed to have a slight scumread of Jamie - suspicion at least - so I'm not sure why he would have been shocked at the flip.

Your first point is fair. Doesn't mean I don't find it odd that you stayed far away from Rj's erratic behavior.

You didn't address my question about how your arrived at your vote.

Can you point me to where you are getting that Rj seemed to have a Jamie scumread?

[brainbomb]

Why is anyone townreading bo

[brainbomb]

Dammit tom stop bussing thamrick and help me fish out what PR bo is gonna pretend to be

[Tom Bombadil]

bo's easy. if he survives a couple more nights we just lynch him (sort of joking). I haven't looked at his D2 much, so I'll reread.

[thamrick]

Dammit tom stop bussing thamrick and help me fish out what PR bo is gonna pretend to be

Why are you defending me? And can you please seriously answer my question about why you followed me onto RJ? Your Rj interactions D1 don't make a lot of sense to me.

[brainbomb]

Bo's ISO consists of like 3 posts day 1 and anchor voting
And 7 posts day 2 and anchor voting

Then after we bagged 2 scum he comes on and whines that his case was ignored. He was upset we lynched scum

[brainbomb]

Dammit tom stop bussing thamrick and help me fish out what PR bo is gonna pretend to be

Why are you defending me? And can you please seriously answer my question about why you followed me onto RJ? Your Rj interactions D1 don't make a lot of sense to me.

I dont even have an answer to this

[thamrick]

I don't think Bo would be that obvious. He's too good for that.

[Tom Bombadil]

"Then after we bagged 2 scum he comes on and whines that his case was ignored. He was upset we lynched scum"

This seems NAI from bo. He gets pissy if we don't listen to him, regardless of the outcome.

[brainbomb]

Bo is horrible af as scum


Dont you understand bo is a meme?

#bo is the worst???

This is not a joke. Its legit. He always gets caught easily as scum