Mafia 88: Murder at the Meadery - GAME THREAD

[BunnyGo]

Is nobody reading what Dip is writing? I don't think it could look much worse.

##VOTE Dip

That is another possible busing slot, but kingofthepirates looks more likely to be bussing, although it could be both.

You think that kingofpirates, in his second game, drew mafia for the first time, and on the first day, he bussed his godfather (a more experienced player) to death?

Yes. He’s a clever high school student.

Tell me, did he waffle this much game 1?

[sweetandcool]

I think I've just solved the game.

The reason everything has become so difficult and several good arguments have arisen is that scum is lurking and/or voting low impact content.

The scum team is Dip, Vecna, and Ham.

Small chance I am wrong about Ham. But he looks partnered with Dip.

Explain killing damo and RBing Sparta with that team.

Well maybe not Ham, I kind of waffling big-time on that.

I don't understand Vecna nor rdr, so it's hard for me to speculate their motivations for those actions.

I suppose under the theory that Ham is Town that they thought damo was Cop.

Under the theory that Ham is Mafia they didn't think damo was Cop, but they wanted it to look that way in order to absolve Ham.

Their real Cop hunt was the RB on Sparta.


Hmmm, actually that second theory sounds more plausible. They don't need Cop dead, just RB. I'll have to look into how likely Sparta is Cop.

[sweetandcool]

Problem now is we can't go back and get posts. We can't really even VCA our way through this unless someone has screenshots or something.

In that case, I think the hypoclaim is something that needs to happen. At some point mafia hit cop; I am not sure how much longer cop evades mafia.

http://mafia.peterlund.se/e/web/front_page

Using global game statistics and day 1 and day 2 work.

You can get day 3 as well, except for the last hour.

[kingofthepirates]

Have you? I saw nothing there that addressed a single thing in my long post nor bozos.

Tell you what, I’ll stop voting you if you quote my post and refute my points clearly and logically line by line.

So a number of things. Firstly: I'm not sure which post you are refering to. I responded to what I saw as the original reasons (response on pg 126), and bozo's page 127 post. I'm not sure if I missed something? If so, my bad, I'll go back and check.

[sweetandcool]

That is another possible busing slot, but kingofthepirates looks more likely to be bussing, although it could be both.

You think that kingofpirates, in his second game, drew mafia for the first time, and on the first day, he bussed his godfather (a more experienced player) to death?

Yes. He’s a clever high school student.

Tell me, did he waffle this much game 1?

No, he just sheeped like a madman last game. This game he kind of has, kind of hasn't.

[Bonatogether]

My scum-pool is currently:

Bozotheclown
Sweetandcool
BunnyGo
Worcej
Vecna

My towncore is:

Balki
Bonatogether
Spartaculous

Haven't got a clue on Hamilton, there are arguments in both directions.

Null on KingofthePirates although I don't like the extremely lazy push on him by Bunny / Bozo / Sweet.

Null on D&W so far. Need to see more.

Did I forget anyone?

We only agree on BofA.

And you’ve made NO CASES AT ALL FOR ANY OF YOUR READS!!

LAZY LIAR!! I dub thee!

what's bofa?

[BunnyGo]

and if ur reasoning was the previous things you typed up, what do you think now that I've responded?

I see nothing I typed addresses so far

[BunnyGo]

My case against worcej is twofold:

1. He has seemed pretty tuned out, and hasn't contributed much of use.

2. The timing of his vote on JustWill seemed just about perfect for a wolfie trying to jump on a doomed partner's wagon.

Neither of those is how scum!worcej plays

[Balki Bartokomous]

That is another possible busing slot, but kingofthepirates looks more likely to be bussing, although it could be both.

You think that kingofpirates, in his second game, drew mafia for the first time, and on the first day, he bussed his godfather (a more experienced player) to death?

Yes. He’s a clever high school student.

Tell me, did he waffle this much game 1?

I can only really say that I have not noticed an obvious, alignment-indicative difference between last game and this game for Johnny Depp. Did he "waffle this much"? I don't know. I haven't really identified him as a waffler this game, but that may be because I've sort of sorted him Town in my mind since the JustWill flip and I just didn't focus on him Day 1.

[Balki Bartokomous]

My case against worcej is twofold:

1. He has seemed pretty tuned out, and hasn't contributed much of use.

2. The timing of his vote on JustWill seemed just about perfect for a wolfie trying to jump on a doomed partner's wagon.

Neither of those is how scum!worcej plays

Well, you make this sound really easy. How does scum!worcej play?

[BunnyGo]

If anyone wants to bet me that the mafia killed Damo because of what he was saying in the thread that others might agree with, versus they killed Damo because they thought he might be Cop, I'll take that bet.

We can check in the mafia server after the game.

They were almost certainly shooting for Cop last night.

This is absolutely what I think to have been happening, which continues to harden my stance that Hamilton needs to die.

How can you possibly still consider Hamilton is a VT who specifically setup possible crumbs on D1 to rely on in an effort to defend a cop claim?

He isn’t being RB’ed based off of claims - so do you really think scum 100% buy the fact he’s not the cop and is just a VT?

Please respond to the stage 2 yomi thinking I posted about this.

[kingofthepirates]

I see nothing I typed addresses so far

I confused you with bozo, my bad. I addressed bozo's reasons, please let me know where yours are.

[BunnyGo]

I think I've just solved the game.

The reason everything has become so difficult and several good arguments have arisen is that scum is lurking and/or voting low impact content.

The scum team is Dip, Vecna, and Ham.

Small chance I am wrong about Ham. But he looks partnered with Dip.

Explain killing damo and RBing Sparta with that team.

Well maybe not Ham, I kind of waffling big-time on that.

I don't understand Vecna nor rdr, so it's hard for me to speculate their motivations for those actions.

I suppose under the theory that Ham is Town that they thought damo was Cop.

Under the theory that Ham is Mafia they didn't think damo was Cop, but they wanted it to look that way in order to absolve Ham.

Their real Cop hunt was the RB on Sparta.


Hmmm, actually that second theory sounds more plausible. They don't need Cop dead, just RB. I'll have to look into how likely Sparta is Cop.

Now you’re thinking! Go get em!


You’re doing more and better work than Lazy Liar!

[sweetandcool]

My scum-pool is currently:

Bozotheclown
Sweetandcool
BunnyGo
Worcej
Vecna

My towncore is:

Balki
Bonatogether
Spartaculous

Haven't got a clue on Hamilton, there are arguments in both directions.

Null on KingofthePirates although I don't like the extremely lazy push on him by Bunny / Bozo / Sweet.

Null on D&W so far. Need to see more.

Did I forget anyone?

We only agree on BofA.

And you’ve made NO CASES AT ALL FOR ANY OF YOUR READS!!

LAZY LIAR!! I dub thee!

what's bofa?

Napoleon bofa Deez nuts

I heard he screamed it at the battle of Austerlitz.

[BunnyGo]

My case against worcej is twofold:

1. He has seemed pretty tuned out, and hasn't contributed much of use.

2. The timing of his vote on JustWill seemed just about perfect for a wolfie trying to jump on a doomed partner's wagon.

Neither of those is how scum!worcej plays

Well, you make this sound really easy. How does scum!worcej play?

Usually open wolfing and hyper active. Often sounds closer to town Bunny, but with less mania.

[BunnyGo]

<snip> because it’s soooooo long.

It’s long @kOp but you and @LazyLiar should go read.

[BunnyGo]

And I found it….USING THE BOT!!

[Balki Bartokomous]

I see nothing I typed addresses so far

I confused you with bozo, my bad. I addressed bozo's reasons, please let me know where yours are.

I first read this as "I confused you with bozo, my dad."

Just to be absolutely clear, Sparrow, is Bozo your dad?

[BunnyGo]

You think that kingofpirates, in his second game, drew mafia for the first time, and on the first day, he bussed his godfather (a more experienced player) to death?

Yes. He’s a clever high school student.

Tell me, did he waffle this much game 1?

I can only really say that I have not noticed an obvious, alignment-indicative difference between last game and this game for Johnny Depp. Did he "waffle this much"? I don't know. I haven't really identified him as a waffler this game, but that may be because I've sort of sorted him Town in my mind since the JustWill flip and I just didn't focus on him Day 1.

Cool. Tell us why.

no visual task completion, and no one has so far vouched for you doing your tasks like a good crew mate. kinda sus ngl...

I am going to stick with this bit for a while.

He did waffle quite a bit that game. Unvoted and whatnot. But look at the oozing confidence in that post early D1.

Compare it to the posts I quoted in my long case I just made.

[Balki Bartokomous]

I'm not sold on that BunnyGo. I think I'd feel less confident in this read if JustWill were a goon. Losing Godfather on Day 1 is just a big loss for the bad guys. I feel like the "Pirate might have bussed godfather" to be the sort of tinfoil we should not be entertaining for a while. Maybe until we only have one mischop left.