Mafia 88: Murder at the Meadery - GAME THREAD

[Bonatogether]

Bonatogether was apparently scum reading Just after his first post, and was confident Just was mafia at EOD. That is not very consistent with not voting for Just for 47 hours of D1. I don't think everyone should assume Bonatogether is town.

The GF is only useful if he gets cop scanned, Bonatogether could have been trying to make that happen.

the first post was a joke, the second post is not a scumread (and is from SoD1??), and the third post is deep-seated eod conviction

When did you start sum reading him then?

when i started arguing with him in the thread because he was taking shots without reason

[Jamiet99uk]

I'd like the vote reconsidered, so I'm happy to answer questions about my reads list and myself to that end.

Question 1: Why did you think Dr.Fidelis was still in the game?

Question 2: Why did you think Foodcoats was still in the game?

If you actually "read the thread three times" and you are an experienced player of this kind of game, I find it very hard to understand how you would completely fail to notice people dying. Player deaths, and the accompanying role flips, are pretty much the most important pieces of information revealed during the game.

Your reads list appears to be what it would have been after 24 hours of Day One. It is currently the latter part of Day Two.

This is all highly suspect.

[damo666]

If Ham and LoW are both town we are in trouble.

[Bonatogether]

That reads list is so fake. ##vote lordofwords

I would expect nothing less from someone I am accusing, but reads were asked for.

And we appreciate that you made the attempt.

I am not swayed, however. And I am disturbed that you seriously included two dead people in them.

what's the scum explanation for that, though? beyond just being disturbing

[Jamiet99uk]

I'm going to reread it the bot this time, but I'm going to ask either making a mistake or this being ploy puts me as scum in any world, especially it has put a wagon on me. I'm stating this generally for everyone.

I'm prioritizing this morning's posts, however.

Your wagon was due to lack of activity. The mistake is bizarre. It can be read as a ploy - "I don't know what's going on, I can't possibly therefore be scum."

You have about 8 hours to redeem yourself.

I have the same viewpoint as Damo, with regard to Lord of Words's bizarre play today. My vote is staying where it is.

[Jamiet99uk]

I would expect nothing less from someone I am accusing, but reads were asked for.

And we appreciate that you made the attempt.

I am not swayed, however. And I am disturbed that you seriously included two dead people in them.

what's the scum explanation for that, though? beyond just being disturbing

The scum explanation is that the list was fake and he sloppily failed to check if it was still up to date.

[Hamilton Brian]

I provided a detailed explanation.

You give the impression you are not reading the game.

I kind of wasn't; had about an hour spent on D1 and this D up to this point. Today should be a bit better.

Read list when you've caught up please.

Ain't gonna happen, at least not what I think you're looking for. From the hip and from the collection of posts I recall:
Damo: you look shitty for the vig shot
Vecna: you look lazy for the the easy scumread of me; it's like you're mafia latching on to the easy miskill.
Bunny: you look pretty good to me
Sweet: you also look pretty good, although someone said something about you openwolfing. I don't think I've seen that yet so I disagree
Rivera: haven't seen a lot but the post on bozo rings with me, but that's not enough to put him in the good camp
Bozo: Rivera has a point
Jamie: I have a pretty hard time getting his vibes, but probably in the could be town/could be mafia list
Sparta: I liked the bussing post; that's a lot of writing and comes off as genuine town
Lord: pressured into committing to the game; wall posts which I don't think mafia would publish. Not solid town but not the miskill that Jamie wanted earlier in the day

forgetting some, I know, which suggests they haven't made an impression on me as of yet

oh, ghug. I think ghug is ok

[damo666]

I would expect nothing less from someone I am accusing, but reads were asked for.

And we appreciate that you made the attempt.

I am not swayed, however. And I am disturbed that you seriously included two dead people in them.

what's the scum explanation for that, though? beyond just being disturbing

He could playing an "I don't know what's going on" card. Implication being if he were scum he'd be aware ergo not scum. I really don't know what to think. Certainly not convinced of his innocence.

[Hamilton Brian]

If Ham and LoW are both town we are in trouble.

Is this a fauxtown post?
I assure you I am town and I am INSISTING that you look elsewhere.

[damo666]

I kind of wasn't; had about an hour spent on D1 and this D up to this point. Today should be a bit better.

Read list when you've caught up please.

Ain't gonna happen, at least not what I think you're looking for. From the hip and from the collection of posts I recall:
Damo: you look shitty for the vig shot
Vecna: you look lazy for the the easy scumread of me; it's like you're mafia latching on to the easy miskill.
Bunny: you look pretty good to me
Sweet: you also look pretty good, although someone said something about you openwolfing. I don't think I've seen that yet so I disagree
Rivera: haven't seen a lot but the post on bozo rings with me, but that's not enough to put him in the good camp
Bozo: Rivera has a point
Jamie: I have a pretty hard time getting his vibes, but probably in the could be town/could be mafia list
Sparta: I liked the bussing post; that's a lot of writing and comes off as genuine town
Lord: pressured into committing to the game; wall posts which I don't think mafia would publish. Not solid town but not the miskill that Jamie wanted earlier in the day

forgetting some, I know, which suggests they haven't made an impression on me as of yet

oh, ghug. I think ghug is ok

So, Vecna Bozo and who?

[damo666]

If Ham and LoW are both town we are in trouble.

Is this a fauxtown post?
I assure you I am town and I am INSISTING that you look elsewhere.

Ooooooo

[Hamilton Brian]

I still think we've got to read Will for D1 and hold on to that reads list.

And identifying the bussers on Will.

There was a post I wrote for when D2 started. I want to go back to that with the VCA, despite ghug saying VCA on D1 isn't that critical, or whatever was said.

[Hamilton Brian]

So, Vecna Bozo and who?

You?

[damo666]

So, Vecna Bozo and who?

You?

I INSIST you think again.

[Bonatogether]

##vote sweetandcool

dude is openly powerwolfing.

I have not been wrong on this slots alignment in a single game.

so real

[Vecna]

I find it interesting that HB is feigning to not have a clue about what is going on this game, yet he feels he can make a judgement call on whether SweetNcool is powerwolfing.

[Bonatogether]

This game just got made a lot easier by the newer players putting in a few killer posts that pretty much absolves them.

The irritation with certain players is palpable.

Balki Bartokomous
kingofthepirates
Rdrivera2005
Bonatogether
Bozotheclown
Spartaculous
BunnyGo
Jamiet99uk
damo666
Lord of Words
ghug
Vecna
The above group is probably all town, in no particular order

Leaving a very easy poe:
Hamilton Brian
Sweetandcool
worcej

Maybe im wrong about 1, which is likely either Rdrivera, Kotp or Bona if some weird bussing occured.

But for now, fuck whether any of these slots bussed or not, thats a crapshoot anyway. Reads reign supreme.

lmao??

[Bonatogether]

And we appreciate that you made the attempt.

I am not swayed, however. And I am disturbed that you seriously included two dead people in them.

what's the scum explanation for that, though? beyond just being disturbing

The scum explanation is that the list was fake and he sloppily failed to check if it was still up to date.

if it's fake, why wasn't it dropped at EoN?

[Bonatogether]

And we appreciate that you made the attempt.

I am not swayed, however. And I am disturbed that you seriously included two dead people in them.

what's the scum explanation for that, though? beyond just being disturbing

He could playing an "I don't know what's going on" card. Implication being if he were scum he'd be aware ergo not scum. I really don't know what to think. Certainly not convinced of his innocence.

this is really a file for later situation, but that really doesn't make sense as an argument for now

[Bonatogether]

guys the obvious busser on will is sweet. will and i had been going at it for hours, and he's been given way too much credit for being the first vote. i registered in the thread at the time that i thought i was getting onto a wagon with a scum member on it bussing, and i just don't see how it doesn't work out to be either me or sweet as the earliest bus, from an outside pov