M1027: Community - Game Thread

[Jamiet99uk]

I like how Hamilton Brian and Chaqa were just vanilla Goons but Ghug was Mafia Scum.

[Jamiet99uk]

I think we're finding out that this setup is super swingy. If Mafia had hit the Investigator before last night, the Mafia team would still be in quite a good place. Instead, as it stands, we've actually done a good job of collaborating, and used the Investigator's power to max effect.

It's not quite Game Over but Town is definitely winning.

[Jamiet99uk]

Current reads:

Town

sweetandcool
heartthrob24909
JustAGuyNamedWill
rdrivera2005
Worcej

Scum

Obviously Sweetiepie is mechanically towncleared.

It pretty much has to be Worcej, Rdrivera, or Will, I think.

[Jamiet99uk]

Not much else to say until we get the next flip and scan result.

I have voted to end night early.

[BunnyGo]

Not much else to say until we get the next flip and scan result.

I have voted to end night early.

For those unaware: voting to end night early is via private message to GM (either Discord or webdip) and must be unanimous.

[worcej]

Current reads:

Town

sweetandcool
heartthrob24909
JustAGuyNamedWill
rdrivera2005
Worcej

Scum

Obviously Sweetiepie is mechanically towncleared.

It pretty much has to be Worcej, Rdrivera, or Will, I think.

Willing to put more words behind the scum read of myself and rdr?

[worcej]

I think we're finding out that this setup is super swingy. If Mafia had hit the Investigator before last night, the Mafia team would still be in quite a good place. Instead, as it stands, we've actually done a good job of collaborating, and used the Investigator's power to max effect.

It's not quite Game Over but Town is definitely winning.

Agreed in principle.

It was a nice change of pace, but I have done little actual case building or examination of the gamestate outside of Monarch vs ghug and that makes it hard to “feel good” about winning this one.

[Jamiet99uk]

Current reads:

Town

sweetandcool
heartthrob24909
JustAGuyNamedWill
rdrivera2005
Worcej

Scum

Obviously Sweetiepie is mechanically towncleared.

It pretty much has to be Worcej, Rdrivera, or Will, I think.

Willing to put more words behind the scum read of myself and rdr?

In a four-person scum team, there are generally likely to be one or two members who try to lie low and avoid attention, while other members of the team generate noise and smoke.

Ghug and Hamilton Brian were both quite active and involved in the game. Ghug is still the fourth highest poster, and he died three phases ago.

So, who is the low-posting, coasting, quiet scum? You and Rdr have both been extremely low-energy this game and therefore fit that profile.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

In a similar way,

@sweetandcool
@Jamiet99uk
@heartthrob24909
@worcej
@rdrivera2005

Worcej and rdr are of equal suspicion to me

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

I think we're finding out that this setup is super swingy. If Mafia had hit the Investigator before last night, the Mafia team would still be in quite a good place. Instead, as it stands, we've actually done a good job of collaborating, and used the Investigator's power to max effect.

It's not quite Game Over but Town is definitely winning.

Agreed in principle.

It was a nice change of pace, but I have done little actual case building or examination of the gamestate outside of Monarch vs ghug and that makes it hard to “feel good” about winning this one.

Haven’t won yet.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Current reads:

Town

sweetandcool
heartthrob24909
JustAGuyNamedWill
rdrivera2005
Worcej

Scum

Obviously Sweetiepie is mechanically towncleared.

It pretty much has to be Worcej, Rdrivera, or Will, I think.

Can you tell me why you townread heart?

[Jamiet99uk]

Current reads:

Town

sweetandcool
heartthrob24909
JustAGuyNamedWill
rdrivera2005
Worcej

Scum

Obviously Sweetiepie is mechanically towncleared.

It pretty much has to be Worcej, Rdrivera, or Will, I think.

Can you tell me why you townread heart?

Well, I don't know his meta, but he seems earnest and invested in trying to solve. He is giving me town vibes. I have not noticed him do or say anything that aroused any suspicions.

Do you scumread heart?

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Current reads:

Town

sweetandcool
heartthrob24909
JustAGuyNamedWill
rdrivera2005
Worcej

Scum

Obviously Sweetiepie is mechanically towncleared.

It pretty much has to be Worcej, Rdrivera, or Will, I think.

Can you tell me why you townread heart?

Well, I don't know his meta, but he seems earnest and invested in trying to solve. He is giving me town vibes. I have not noticed him do or say anything that aroused any suspicions.

Do you scumread heart?

I do, but not nearly as much as worc and rdr. Just think heart is a viable candidate

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Personally, Jamie is hard town read for me, but if its final 3 and he’s still around, Im going to start having suspicions…

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Also @Jamie you... don't seem like the kind of guy to misinteperet a joke

Who wants to tell him?

I got this impression from Jamie too.

@Stand I haven't played with you before. Nice to meet ya!

Wait, who is Standstill?!

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

I have some of my own pseudo science here.

I assume 1-3 scum were on the kak train. Let's call it 2

7 people were not on the train. One is kak and one is me, known town to me.

That would mean 2 of 5 of ghug, rdr, sweet, bozo, Hamilton are scum. Could be 1of 6 or 3 of 5 as well. I doubt all 4 scum were on kak, nor that none were. The other townies in my second group should be able to see this the same way as me

Bringing this up again

[Jamiet99uk]

Who wants to tell him?

I got this impression from Jamie too.

@Stand I haven't played with you before. Nice to meet ya!

Wait, who is Standstill?!

Ghug edited your name. It's easy to do.

[Jamiet99uk]

I have some of my own pseudo science here.

I assume 1-3 scum were on the kak train. Let's call it 2

7 people were not on the train. One is kak and one is me, known town to me.

That would mean 2 of 5 of ghug, rdr, sweet, bozo, Hamilton are scum. Could be 1of 6 or 3 of 5 as well. I doubt all 4 scum were on kak, nor that none were. The other townies in my second group should be able to see this the same way as me

Bringing this up again

Rdr is the name that stands out there.

Its funny, if the scum team is Ghug, Hamilton, Chaqa and Rdr, that's a very experienced squad.

And town is kicking their bottoms.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

I got this impression from Jamie too.

@Stand I haven't played with you before. Nice to meet ya!

Wait, who is Standstill?!

Ghug edited your name. It's easy to do.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

I have some of my own pseudo science here.

I assume 1-3 scum were on the kak train. Let's call it 2

7 people were not on the train. One is kak and one is me, known town to me.

That would mean 2 of 5 of ghug, rdr, sweet, bozo, Hamilton are scum. Could be 1of 6 or 3 of 5 as well. I doubt all 4 scum were on kak, nor that none were. The other townies in my second group should be able to see this the same way as me

Bringing this up again

Rdr is the name that stands out there.

Its funny, if the scum team is Ghug, Hamilton, Chaqa and Rdr, that's a very experienced squad.

And town is kicking their bottoms.

That would be funny. It all depends on how long the inv survives