MAfIA 84 - A VERY TENDER THANKSGIVING GAME THREAD

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Well done!

And @spirit: you can use he/him for me.

I survived!

[heartthrob24909]

Those are literally NOT the same thing.

Forming an ALLIANCE where only one will end up winning (Catan) or where you will play kingmaker is a FUNDAMENTALLY different style of game.

I'm talking about a TEAM. Like fu**ing baseball, or bridge, or MAFIA where you win or lose with THE WHOLE TEAM regardless of your actual actions.

Your answer suggests you do not understand that fundamental thing.

So to answer your original question: I do think there's a chance you're mafia. But I don't actually care. Town's chances of winning will be increased if we eliminate you day 1 regardless. I care about that statement (usually that statement requires me to believe a player is mafia)

Ok, so you say joking about being mafia is detrimental. That’s why I only really did it in the beginning, where we all kind of joke around and have fun with it

This is valid. I think pushing buttons is good. Intentional or not I like the argument that has developed bc of them. Bunny being literally so mad feels townly

[Jamiet99uk]

Whoop!

Person obviously buddying me is obvious!

[Bonatogether]

voting for self-pres as i stated i would

##vote sweetandcool

Ach, bad timing, I just changed my vote.

haha

[ghug]

Hype

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Hey, at least we got one mafia

[heartthrob24909]

Go see how often you KEPT GOING BACK TO IT UNPROMPTED. It was excessive and out of nowhere repeatedly.

I’m walking away and going to dinner. But if you survive today, shape the f*** up.

I feel like this argument is based upon me liking non team games. I don’t really have an argument against that, so I won’t really.

I think this point doesn’t work because convincing someone to do something against their best interest in solo games is hard, which would make me, someone who likes doing that, good at making town do something within their best interest.

Next time you have a criticism, tell me in mafia chat so I don’t have to type in the forum as much

I gotta say the idgaf attitude kinda makes me lean town on you (and this joke did amuse me). Not experienced enough to rly comment on whether the jokes make you particular helpful/unhelpful as a teammate... its whatever imo

[heartthrob24909]

##VOTE Macca

Self preservation vote. I am town, and if I can’t joke around then that’s fine, I won’t. Just trying to lighten the mood.

Oh well I never rly like to see self pres reasoning

[Bonatogether]

Oh boy, if sweet turns out to be mafia I am in a shit ton of trouble lol

what a goofy man

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

##VOTE Macca

Self preservation vote. I am town, and if I can’t joke around then that’s fine, I won’t. Just trying to lighten the mood.

Oh well I never rly like to see self pres reasoning

Wait til this guy hears about bona

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Oh boy, if sweet turns out to be mafia I am in a shit ton of trouble lol

what a goofy man

I’m psychic

[SpiritoftheRadio]

Fuck yeah we got em! Also sad mafia sweet dies day 1 two games in a row, but boy gotta stop being sniffable that early

[Bonatogether]

this is incoherent. from the top: you said you weren't voting me. i demonstrated that you were. you flipped your vote to the player i subbed in for, which is not a valid vote and so you are still voting me. i point out the inconsistency, and now you continue to insist that you're voting for and scumread the player i subbed in for, but not me, when in fact we are the same slot.

I'm done with this. At this point if it doesn't make sense to you that's your problem.

This is like the arguments my dad and brother have at the dinner table. Getting into the early Thanksgiving spirit I see

but i was right

[bozotheclown]

Also, ##VOTE Bona

I've decided that ND (Bona) could be scum.

ND's strategy actually halfway worked last time as Mafia. Several people townread him for his antics. So I'm thinking this game he decided to resurrect that strategy, banking on the fact that people would assume he wouldn't be so obvious about using his previous scum-strategy, and therefore would townread him.

This feels like some very forced reasoning. ##vote Sweet just to get out of the no kill vote for now

I suspect this vote could have been Temasek bussing/distancing sweetandcool.

[damo666]

I have to admit I don't really know what the case on sweet was. Came back on virtually at EOD saw Macca wasn't gonna fly so switched to sweet to ensure no last second shenanigans (and I didn't want Will to go).

What was the case on sweet?

[SpiritoftheRadio]

Well done!

And @spirit: you can use he/him for me.

my bad, I realized I effed up as soon as I posted, but I get in trouble when I edit posts (which is my nature). I will get it right from now on.

[Bonatogether]

##VOTE sweetandcool

If sweet flips mafia, we get closer to winning but I get voted out. If sweet flips town we get further but my original assumption Macca is suspicious proves more towny

Sigh, this game is complicated

self analysis is dumb

[SpiritoftheRadio]

I have to admit I don't really know what the case on sweet was. Came back on virtually at EOD saw Macca wasn't gonna fly so switched to sweet to ensure no last second shenanigans (and I didn't want Will to go).

What was the case on sweet?

My case was that sweet looked like he was bussing Will and Will not going onto his wagon instead of maccas was really strange. Other people had other cases earlier, but I have forgotten.

[bozotheclown]

I am not sure how you can "read" someone when you know the answer.

This is the primary reason I voted for sweetandcool among the current wagons.

It's a poor reason. I didn't read who my teammate were until halfway through the phase last game. I townread ND.

But late to talk about it though.

Based on your comment I suspect I was right for the wrong reason, but if you are reading this, I did also consider what your other voters were saying in my decision.

[ghug]

I have to admit I don't really know what the case on sweet was. Came back on virtually at EOD saw Macca wasn't gonna fly so switched to sweet to ensure no last second shenanigans (and I didn't want Will to go).

What was the case on sweet?

This sounds like town damo.

I thought sweet sounded fake in a couple of posts last night. Haven't read the last several hours yet, so I don't know what everyone else thought.