Mafia XXXIV Game Thread - Who Framed Roger Rabbit?

[Rjmcf]

What makes you think this? Who do you think he said he'd give a gun to?

The lack of his death and the rb claim by Balki.

As much as I hate to devil's advocate for brain when he wants my head, there are 2 rbs.

Are you claiming rb Demon?

[VashtaNeurotic]

Brainbomb. If you are going to claim gunsmith....then tell us who you gunned, simply.

[brainbomb]

What did the RB message say Balki? You were roleblocked last night? or was there flavor. It could help us figure out if you were town RB'd or mafia RB'd.

This would not be different mechanically.

[bo_sox48]

Also of note is that the witch missed last night.

It is also perfectly plausible that the witch didn't make any attempts last night.

Why, they only lose their ability when it actually kills twice?

Given that I once had this argument with a GM and was told that my two successful actions was actually two attempts at my action, I assume that that means attempts. It really screwed town over that game and made my role totally useless because of the ambiguity. You can ask the GMs to clarify if you like.

[brainbomb]

Brainbomb. If you are going to claim gunsmith....then tell us who you gunned, simply.

I was not roleblocked

[DemonRHK]

The lack of his death and the rb claim by Balki.

As much as I hate to devil's advocate for brain when he wants my head, there are 2 rbs.

Are you claiming rb Demon?

no, I already said I wasn't.

Im not sure what you are asking me? I wasnt roleblocked

Who did you gun?

[brainbomb]

It is also perfectly plausible that the witch didn't make any attempts last night.

Why, they only lose their ability when it actually kills twice?

Given that I once had this argument with a GM and was told that my two successful actions was actually two attempts at my action, I assume that that means attempts. It really screwed town over that game and made my role totally useless because of the ambiguity. You can ask the GMs to clarify if you like.

Still mad about that eh?

[brainbomb]

Oh I wasnt roleblocked yall

[VashtaNeurotic]

WITCH
You are the WITCH. Each day you must vote for a suspect. Each night, you may visit another player by PM'ing both GMs with the order ##CURSE <NAME>. If that player is visited by a TOWN-SIDED player that night, they will be killed by the curse. If they survive, the target will not learn that they were cursed. After killing two people via curse, you will be too exhausted from your efforts to cast any further curses. At night you can talk to the other Mafia in the Mafia QT at <LINK>. Your teammates are <NAME>, the Hooker, <NAME>, the Stalker, <NAME>, the Godfather, and <NAME>, the Thief. You win when all of the Town have been eliminated, or nothing can stop this from happening.

Kind of clear here....no?

[Rjmcf]

Oh I wasnt roleblocked yall

Ok so he's claiming a different PR. Neat.

[bo_sox48]

Why, they only lose their ability when it actually kills twice?

Given that I once had this argument with a GM and was told that my two successful actions was actually two attempts at my action, I assume that that means attempts. It really screwed town over that game and made my role totally useless because of the ambiguity. You can ask the GMs to clarify if you like.

Still mad about that eh?

I do my best not to hold grudges, but I also don't forget.

[brainbomb]

It is currently 41° C in Brazil

[thamrick]

##CALL GM

Does the witch get 2 attempts at kills with the curse or 2 actual kills?

[brainbomb]

Given that I once had this argument with a GM and was told that my two successful actions was actually two attempts at my action, I assume that that means attempts. It really screwed town over that game and made my role totally useless because of the ambiguity. You can ask the GMs to clarify if you like.

Still mad about that eh?

I do my best not to hold grudges, but I also don't forget.

Bo. You actually were right that game and I apologize. I fucked up in my proofreading

[bo_sox48]

WITCH
You are the WITCH. Each day you must vote for a suspect. Each night, you may visit another player by PM'ing both GMs with the order ##CURSE <NAME>. If that player is visited by a TOWN-SIDED player that night, they will be killed by the curse. If they survive, the target will not learn that they were cursed. After killing two people via curse, you will be too exhausted from your efforts to cast any further curses. At night you can talk to the other Mafia in the Mafia QT at <LINK>. Your teammates are <NAME>, the Hooker, <NAME>, the Stalker, <NAME>, the Godfather, and <NAME>, the Thief. You win when all of the Town have been eliminated, or nothing can stop this from happening.

Kind of clear here....no?

If you think it's clear, great. I'm telling you straight up from experience with that exact same scenario that that is a dangerous assumption.

I was going to type a call GM but thamrick just did. Thanks, thamrick.

[VashtaNeurotic]

So bb refuses to either:
1. Tell us who he gunned.
3. Flat out say we won't tell us who he gunned and explain why
3. Rescind his PR claim

So uh, until he does either ##votebrainbomb. I'm sure this vote won't last long, though.

[Rjmcf]

It is currently 41° C in Brazil

It's actually 22, I just looked it up.

[bo_sox48]

Aw, thanks brain. I wish you had come to that realization back then.

/grudge

[Rjmcf]

Aw, thanks brain. I wish you had come to that realization back then.

/grudge

This is nice and all, but you still haven't responded to me. I think we all need an answer right now, you're deflecting.

[brainbomb]

Aw, thanks brain. I wish you had come to that realization back then.

/grudge

I could go into why I ruled the way I did. Just wanted to stand with my co gm.

But thats pretty unimportant here.