MAFIA 39 - GAME THREAD

[yavuzovic]

Jamie: Also giving durga and flash guns will be great. Towns been misfiring every game so this is fair!

No no no, to be fairer, he would give a cannon to y2k

[y2kjbk]

Yeah if there was any actual picking of people to items, I would have a cannon.

[brainbomb]

Unless some next level scum play- or total fuckery is afoot im gonna go ahead and retire my SR on durga

[rdrivera2005]

Most likely scumpairs in order starting with most likely

DemonRHK Yav
DemonRHK ND
ND Yav
DemonRHK rdrivera
rdrivera Yav
ND rdrivera

Why our clears need to be so bad at this?

You were voting Ghug until some minutes with me and ND and now you put us as a likely scumteam? Can you explain what change other then Ghug being nice to you (which is highly suspect)?

[damo666]

Yeah if there was any actual picking of people to items, I would have a cannon.

and probably shoot yourself

[y2kjbk]

i redeemed myself! bleh.

[brainbomb]

I think I always kinda mistake people playing well for scum. Confident town is a grey area in my brain.

Xorxes doesnt really feel confident hes kinda just holding back the floodwaters.

So im at
Town
Y2k
Damo
Worcej
Durga
Rivera
Tom

Flash-> improving

Yavuz ->improving
Vecna -> deteriorating
Ghug -> limbo
ND-> Canto 9
DRHK -> Sear of Dis

[xorxes]

I am starting to worry about Tom and Yav. Tom is lurking pretty badly and he is dangerous as scum. I would not mind voting him. Yav usually is obvtown (or obvscum) but I don't have this feeling in this game. Giving him some time because he is a sub. ND worries me less as he won't survive as a deep threat.

Yav looks the same clueless town as always to me, I can never tell if it's an act or not. He says some things that are borderline reasonable, but other things that seem completely random. I don't remember seeing him play as scum though.

[damo666]

Most likely scumpairs in order starting with most likely

DemonRHK Yav
DemonRHK ND
ND Yav
DemonRHK rdrivera
rdrivera Yav
ND rdrivera

Why our clears need to be so bad at this?

You were voting Ghug until some minutes with me and ND and now you put us as a likely scumteam? Can you explain what change other then Ghug being nice to you (which is highly suspect)?

I didn't notice ghug being particularly nice to me, just finally answered me after my badgering. I have already said I changed my opinion after a reread and ghug's belated answer reinforced that change of opinion.

I posted my list to see what reaction it got.

[brainbomb]

I take a spock approach to mafia. Or sherlock.

Take unlikeliest- heroic most brazen scum moves and analyze them. Discuss them. Look at the whys and why nots. Eliminate the unlikeliest and move on. In the example of flash being scum my theory all relies on his rookie status being the key.

Would rookie scum just blast their own guy and seek cred?

[brainbomb]

More often than not im.wrong. the reason why is I only care about who is trying to slip thru the cracks by making brave bold moves.

Lurkers are more often scum than my bullshit theories sadly. My imagination does tend to run away with me

[xorxes]

I take a spock approach to mafia. Or sherlock.

Take unlikeliest- heroic most brazen scum moves and analyze them. Discuss them. Look at the whys and why nots. Eliminate the unlikeliest and move on. In the example of flash being scum my theory all relies on his rookie status being the key.

Would rookie scum just blast their own guy and seek cred?

Maybe they would, maybe they wouldn't, it depends on so many things.

But that's something to decide when someone less clear than flash has been NK'd, not when he is one of the top clears based on actions.

[ghug]

Why tf do you townread Rivera and Tom?

[rdrivera2005]

More often than not im.wrong. the reason why is I only care about who is trying to slip thru the cracks by making brave bold moves.

Lurkers are more often scum than my bullshit theories sadly. My imagination does tend to run away with me

That's something I can agree with

[ghug]

Durga, why are you still voting for me?

[rdrivera2005]

Why tf do you townread Rivera and Tom?

Good question. I tried to be as obvtown as I can but I don't think it's working and Tom did nothing to be townread.

[rdrivera2005]

Durga, why are you still voting for me?

Probably because you are a good wagon and did nothing to get a townread?

[Tom Bombadil]

Why tf do you townread Rivera and Tom?

Good question. I tried to be as obvtown as I can but I don't think it's working and Tom did nothing to be townread.

You townread me N1. Now you scumreading me again. What led to the change in view?

[ghug]

Durga, why are you still voting for me?

Probably because you are a good wagon and did nothing to get a townread?

She joke voted me.

You haven't yet explained why I'm a good wagon.

[y2kjbk]

Durga, why are you still voting for me?

Probably because you are a good wagon and did nothing to get a townread?

##VOTE rdrivera

who does this but scum wanting to push a ghug lynch?