MAFIA 79: The Price is Right! [GAME THREAD]

[sweetandcool]

Very disappointed in Koala. I was starting to consider that they had poor reading comprehension, rather than actually being Mafia. Though in the end I'm not sure if I would have changed my vote if I were available.

[Chaqa]

It feels incredibly obvious to me that snowy is town, at least.

Damo, Snowy, Bozo towncore.

[snowy801]

It feels incredibly obvious to me that snowy is town, at least.

Damo, Snowy, Bozo towncore.

Dousing don't make your cut?

Thoughts on Jamiet, s&c?

[Chaqa]

It feels incredibly obvious to me that snowy is town, at least.

Damo, Snowy, Bozo towncore.

Dousing don't make your cut?

Thoughts on Jamiet, s&c?

I had Dousing as town earlier but I wasn't as impressed today.

Jamie hasn't impressed me in the slightest.

[sweetandcool]

Technically this is addressed to anybody, but it's probably only relevant to Dousing.

Don't forget powers! I've been operating under the assumption that a mafia traitor would most likely try to signal their teammates (assuming they didn't recruit the traitor), but what I've lost sight of is that a role townie might try to do something similarly. A role townie might also behave a bit strangely or be a bit reticent.

So I recommend when someone makes a statement, try examining it under the lense of them having a role. There might be clues we are missing!

And no, this is not my way of implying that I have (or don't have) a role. Just something that came to mind.

On a more selfish note, several people seem to have Dousing and I townlocked (I have more detractors, but luckily they keep dying (; ). Maybe those people have extra role-related information we haven't been picking up on.

Something to consider.

[snowy801]

Help I'm being pocketed

bozo was right

[sweetandcool]

Very disappointed in Koala. I was starting to consider that they had poor reading comprehension, rather than actually being Mafia. Though in the end I'm not sure if I would have changed my vote if I were available.

One thing I learned about Koala is they're really good at getting reactions, and I appreciate that. But they need to work on not acting like Mafia.

[Chaqa]

Technically this is addressed to anybody, but it's probably only relevant to Dousing.

Don't forget powers! I've been operating under the assumption that a mafia traitor would most likely try to signal their teammates (assuming they didn't recruit the traitor), but what I've lost sight of is that a role townie might try to do something similarly. A role townie might also behave a bit strangely or be a bit reticent.

So I recommend when someone makes a statement, try examining it under the lense of them having a role. There might be clues we are missing!

And no, this is not my way of implying that I have (or don't have) a role. Just something that came to mind.

On a more selfish note, several people seem to have Dousing and I townlocked (I have more detractors, but luckily they keep dying (; ). Maybe those people have extra role-related information we haven't been picking up on.

Something to consider.

Now I kinda think you're the traitor

[sweetandcool]

Technically this is addressed to anybody, but it's probably only relevant to Dousing.

Don't forget powers! I've been operating under the assumption that a mafia traitor would most likely try to signal their teammates (assuming they didn't recruit the traitor), but what I've lost sight of is that a role townie might try to do something similarly. A role townie might also behave a bit strangely or be a bit reticent.

So I recommend when someone makes a statement, try examining it under the lense of them having a role. There might be clues we are missing!

And no, this is not my way of implying that I have (or don't have) a role. Just something that came to mind.

On a more selfish note, several people seem to have Dousing and I townlocked (I have more detractors, but luckily they keep dying (; ). Maybe those people have extra role-related information we haven't been picking up on.

Something to consider.

Now I kinda think you're the traitor

Oh well. I'm just trying to build some trust with Dousing. If they want to crusade against me, that's fine. But I hope I can demonstrate to them that I'm a reasonable player.

[sweetandcool]

Well at least Jamie and Chaqa come out with some credit.

I just don't get Koala.

Why? I'm only looking at the final count, but considering the landslide it seems likely that at least one mafia would have been clever enough to vote away from Koala.

I will look closer at the lead up to EoD to get a better understanding of what happened, but that's my preliminary conclusion.

[damo666]

Well at least Jamie and Chaqa come out with some credit.

I just don't get Koala.

Why? I'm only looking at the final count, but considering the landslide it seems likely that at least one mafia would have been clever enough to vote away from Koala.

I will look closer at the lead up to EoD to get a better understanding of what happened, but that's my preliminary conclusion.

You may have a point.

[damo666]

I got no townreads left!

[snowy801]

I got no townreads left!

none?

[bozotheclown]

I am going to be unavailable for the duration of N2, I will look at D2 again when I get back, assuming I am still in the game.

[Chaqa]

I wish I was the vig

[sweetandcool]

Wait, I see something.

I think it's unfair to say I've been pushing for a damo and/or President Eden misskill.

@Sweetandcool:

Who accused you of "pushing for a damo and/or President Eden misskill" ? Which player said this, and in which post(s)?

I get the impression that Dousing has been implying this. You can dredge up the posts yourself, but back when they were claiming that my arguments were weak they were saying that I seemed to be making suggestions about other players, and then waiting to see if anybody bites. Then if somebody bites I hop onto the wagon they form.

So they probably didn't directly accuse me of pushing a damo and/or President Eden misskill, but the implication was there, since other than Koala (and previously Fox), I had only made small suggestions of suspicion about damo and President Eden.

[sweetandcool]

Don't worry guys I'll be here for EoD

damo without the scumslip TM what else leads you to see s&c scum?

It's a bit weak but ...

The vote and push on TownFox

The overdoing the "I'm a naive new town" persona [I'll find and post a few examples]

When acknowledging the scumslip he didn't actually acknowledge the right bit and hasn't answered Jamie's question.

Oooo, I like this. All valid points, not very different than what Koala was trying to say. You are incorrect but I'm happy to acknowledge a real argument being made.

Actually, this has me tipping to the point of view of a damo townlock. I swear I'm not sucking up to you damo, go ahead and crusade if you like, but you've proven yourself.

[President Eden]

Haven’t caught up yet, wrapped stream not too long ago.

In hindsight I kind of hate the Koala kill, but I get the feeling it was going to happen eventually.

I’m not really sure what made Koala a more compelling choice than Chaqa though

[President Eden]

I guess I need to read more but I am completely mystified as to how everyone suddenly treated the day as a Koala/Eden inevitability.

Makes me think snowy and Chaqa are partners here

[sweetandcool]

I guess I need to read more but I am completely mystified as to how everyone suddenly treated the day as a Koala/Eden inevitability.

Makes me think snowy and Chaqa are partners here

I agree that snowy and chaqa were prime candidates, so it's surprising that it all fell apart. I strongly suspect that at least one Mafia is located in the President Eden wagon.