Rumi -- Almost conf town. Aside from the fact that she has just acted very towny as many have already said, Rumi has confirmed peeked in a setup that disincentives peeking for mafia with the oracle.
PE -- Very town. Being wrong isn’t scum indicative and while PE was wrong on Snowy, his reasons for being wrong weren’t scummy. And besides that, his progression on people and the concern/paranoia that he is showing feels incredibly towny.
Bona -- Very town. The confidence that he is pushing forward with in this game while continuing to read it and build on his reads are hallmarks of town Bona.
Bo -- Lean town. He hasn't been the most active, but I found his early posts as he was catching up good. I think he’s aptly described rdr’s play in a way that aligns with my own views:
He gets town points for his vote D2 and EoN2 post about Neon. At the same time, I don’t see anything here that tells me he definitely couldn’t have been scum with Snowy in the same way that I feel about Bona.
Worcej -- Null to townlean. His early pressure on Neon looks extra good after HB’s flip. His votes D1 and D2 are both on Snowy/Byz counterwagons with little explanation. His surge in activity this night after learning that he has a vote back feels natural after moping about N3-D4, though I initially found his sadness at the lack of vote oversold. What has me leaning town are that there are a couple of posts that don’t feel like how mafia think, though maybe I’m just bad at mafia.
worcej wrote: ↑Tue Aug 23, 2022 5:26 pmIf I was mafia and had this tag, why wouldn’t me and my team have freed me of it on N1?
If I was mafia - I would have peeked on D1 to know what tag I had to plan for the BD movement. I would do it regardless of the concern of accidentally hitting the self oracle. Knowing I have any special tag would be critical for executing the NK and BD actions.
Mechanically, there is no point as mafia to keep the tag on themselves because it effectively neuters the team by taking a vote away.
Otherwise, I am not going to fault you for reading me as defending Byz because that’s exactly what I was doing. I was just doing it as a stupid towny not trusting the origins of the case on Byz.
Chaqa -- Scumlean. Sheeping other people’s views I think Chaqa’s not unlikely to be doctor here; the way he approached the tags felt like he had a lot more info than other people. He should also be getting substantial townpoints for bringing the D1 Byz wagon up to tie with Damo.
That said, the way he moved off Snowy D2 doesn’t feel natural to me. At the start of the day, he end votes Snowy. Then, as it becomes clear that Snowy isn’t going to be immediately hammered, he gets off Snowy, but promises to come back to the wagon later. And then finds his way onto the Sabi wagon who, as of his previous comment, “was never a scumread” as soon as Chaqa becomes the primary Snowy CW.
He also came around on voting out Vecna, his strongest townread for most of the game, for some weak semi-mechanical info with no other defense of him. He didn’t seemed troubled to let his strongest townread go.
Rdr -- I think it’s likely he’s either VT or scum here and I’m leaning the latter, though it could be a smart play as either. I’m not a fan of the way that he’s been pushing on me.