MAFIA 75: TROUBLE AT THE PRECINCT [HIDDEN]

[Jamiet99uk]

Frankly Chaqa it's about time you dropped your "I'm a blundering simpleton who can read or understand game mechanics" schtick. It's not very convincing and it's getting old.

I don't see this post like that. I think he's being chaqa sittingvaround the campfire talking about fishing lures. Or an old timer sitting at the coffeeshop talking about the ins and outs of checker strategy (drafts, i believe, for you...)

Draughts

Well from my perspective it's like an old timer sitting at the coffee shop talking about the ins and outs of checker strategy, but occasionally exclaiming "I haven't read the rules of checkers!".

It's f-ing tiresome and dates back to Chaqa's old "I haven't read my Role PM" nonsense from a few years back.

[Jamiet99uk]

@snowy
Thanks for subbing. May your enjoyment be proportional to how much the room ends up enjoying you.

If you could stretch your awareness and your brain, would yiu have voted for byz yesterday?

You're asking him if he would have voted for... himself?

I'm asking him as snowy, if he'd been reading the game but not in it... if he sees scumminess.

Why would scum!Snowy answer that question honestly?

[Jamiet99uk]

Bo_Sox is town and his contributions on the last page are among the most useful analysis anyone has posted so far tonight.

[Jamiet99uk]

I could totally see scum!Sabi fake-claiming Deathbomb nametag to avoid being voted tomorrow.

[BesharamSabi]

Lol love this.

[dargorygel]

You're asking him if he would have voted for... himself?

I'm asking him as snowy, if he'd been reading the game but not in it... if he sees scumminess.

Why would scum!Snowy answer that question honestly?

No... but i might have learned something about his approach in this game.

But now we get to learn his response to your take on my question.

Maybe we should never ask questions of our scum candidates, since they might lie. Think how easy it would be to keep up wth the thread!

[dargorygel]

I don't believe, while i was reactively suspicious at first, that there was skullduggery at eod. None of the participants are imbeciles. The risk of suspicion would make a decision to tie or not impractical. Yes, pyx coukd hsve been trying atcthe end, but it would have required the tags to fall in pleasant places for him. Wouldn't have risked for such low odds.

Do you think pyxxy actually thinks that hard

The same thing could be said about whether he'd pull the trigger on a tie-causing thing... few of y'all put that much thought into sudden gambits. That's why I'm saying i don't see mischief. It might have ended in mischief, and of course scum always intend mischief. I just don't see it purposeful here.

[worcej]

Guess I kinda respect the limb but this doesn't compel me.

Have you seen scum Jamie or are you just guessing at how he'd behave?

I've seen town Jamie and I've seen get kicked from the game Jamie.

Look at the bot for prior scum games as Jamie.

In general, he is always helpful to new players regardless of alignment so that’s NAI to me.

[worcej]

The FLORIST is a potentially useful Investigative PR in this set-up. I wonder if that occurred to anyone.

I have an idea which I'll elucidate later.

It honestly is more harmful in my eyes, assuming I interpreted the mechanics correctly.

[worcej]

Damn. It has occurred to me that the Bus Driver probably negates most of the Florist's investigative power.

It really doesn’t - I actually thought the bus driver is nerfed in this setup.

[worcej]

Jamie and Chaqa need to get a room. Pyxxy and Besharam are both awful and Besharam is my top scumread right now. Vecna is really good at saying things that make sense and doing absolutely nothing with those things and it drives me insane. PE and Rumi have spent so much time obvtowning that I don’t think I need to read their posts as anything but well intentioned anymore. That EOD sucked which probably means that much of the mafia team sat out. To me that points toward it being town v town.

This has been a breaking news update from me, your host, bo_sox48.

I am actually please to not make this list.

The Sabi scum take is interesting and I want to know more.

[worcej]

I could totally see scum!Sabi fake-claiming Deathbomb nametag to avoid being voted tomorrow.

What is your opinion, in the scale of bad to good, of Sabi as a player?

[snowy801]

I could totally see scum!Sabi fake-claiming Deathbomb nametag to avoid being voted tomorrow.

What is your opinion, in the scale of bad to good, of Sabi as a player?

Toxic bait post

[rdrivera2005]

Oh, and rdr is doing that thing he did the last time I saw him as scum where he mentions that everything and everyone sucks and then gives himself an alibi until everyone forgets it happened so he doesn’t have to go into detail.

I really don't get where I said anyone sucks in this game. In fact I have a lot of town reads and don't have any strong scum read so either you are confusing me with other player or just plain inventing things which is weird.

[rdrivera2005]

I could totally see scum!Sabi fake-claiming Deathbomb nametag to avoid being voted tomorrow.

What is your opinion, in the scale of bad to good, of Sabi as a player?

Toxic bait post

Agree, this could be a valid question in some context, but this way it have a huge chance to end in some form of conflict.

[pyxxy]

GM NOTE

If a powered tag is on someone when they die, it's gone with them. There is no reshuffing of powers back into the pool.

Follow up ##CALL GM

The Mafia NK is usually regarded as a "visit".

When the Mafia NK someone, does the Maf Team member carrying out the kill swap tags with their victim?

GM NOTE

Yes, the NK is a visit, and the performing member will trade nametags with the intended victim at that stage of the execution of night orders.

Follow up ##CALL GM

"the performing member"
Does the mafia get to pick which member performs the kill? And can any of the mafia perform the kill, or only certain roles?

[Jamiet99uk]

I could totally see scum!Sabi fake-claiming Deathbomb nametag to avoid being voted tomorrow.

What is your opinion, in the scale of bad to good, of Sabi as a player?

Somewhere in the middle of the scale.

Sabi is intelligent and articulate, and very keen to participate, but also sometimes makes impulsive decisions which may have benefited from more careful consideration, and is not immune from making mechanics related errors.

[Jamiet99uk]

Damn. It has occurred to me that the Bus Driver probably negates most of the Florist's investigative power.

It really doesn’t - I actually thought the bus driver is nerfed in this setup.

Well my thinking, since you wish to discuss it, was that the Florist had a one-shot ability to check another player's PEEK claim, by visiting them and then peeking in the morning.

But the Bus Driver interferes with that, you see?

[pyxxy]

Damn. It has occurred to me that the Bus Driver probably negates most of the Florist's investigative power.

It really doesn’t - I actually thought the bus driver is nerfed in this setup.

Well my thinking, since you wish to discuss it, was that the Florist had a one-shot ability to check another player's PEEK claim, by visiting them and then peeking in the morning.

But the Bus Driver interferes with that, you see?

We're on the same page. I have a wallpost for you soon.

[Jamiet99uk]

No.

Why are you so happy to swallow this inaccurate depiction of me? If you think it is accurate, read the whole thing again.

@WORCEJ:

Can I press you for a proper answer, please?

Did you ever answer this, Worcej?

I do not think that you did.