Mafia XXXIV Game Thread - Who Framed Roger Rabbit?

[DemonRHK]

30 to EoD. Steve looks like a modkill. I'm going to consolidate onto Jamie, regardless that brain bailed it.

##Vote Jamie

[MeanLaQueefa]

Balki, I took great care to explain my entire argument against you in a page long post, and then you respond "point by point" by quoting one section of it, and asking me questions that are clearly answered in another section of it.

Questions aren't the end all be all of mafia, you can come up with any borkdilly response if you're mafia, you're capable of that. Questions do help town, but accusatory questions over things that don't warrant it confuse people into thinking there is really something to warrant the accusation. These are the types of questions you've been asking all game, even in the post refuting me you do it.

Actions speak louder than words, and I don't see town reasons for you to do what you did. You decided to push a line of questioning with RHK immediately after he got voted for that made him look worse, but then walked away. That is piling on without commitment, that sets you up to start a wagon without taking any responsibility for it. That is very good if you're scum, but worthless and counter productive to your own reads if you're town. You push jamie, when everyone, even you, can agree he isn't a good lynch today. He's done nothing but be an idiot, pushing yav a bit for being confused, and then pushing lurkers. Dumb does not equal scum. He is an easy vote to push, but not a good one in the slightest. Now that you're under pressure, you're doing nothing but trying to undercut the arguments against you, and aren't explaining yourself.

I said in the first post I made voting for you, that is could be the way you play the game, so you need to explain yourself. I'll endulge you with some questions:
Why is questioning demon right after he got voted for out of the blue by tom a good move for town?
Why is jamie the scummiest person here?
Why throw darg down as a possibility with 40mins till we lynch and no votes on him?

I also want to throw out that we don't really have time to debate now, because you've waited this long to respond. I voted for you over a day ago, and there's more I want to talk about here, but we're about to lynch and people keep posting new things as I write this that I'm trying to keep up with, so I'm just posting so people actually have time to read this before the lynch.

I could be wrong about you. You're right, I did make the assumption that you're mafia, but when I do that, everything you've done makes sense, but when I assume you're town, nothing that you've done fits that. You have the most against you of anyone here, so you'll be my vote until that changes.

[Maniac]

Maniac - maybe I just don't like Maniac's style of play, but has seemed very unhelpful. If you're not scum Maniac, start trying to help town - SCUM

That's fair. I haven't got into this game.

I think the most help I can be right now is to ask people to get off the people who only have 1 vote. Make a decision and don't let scum dictate the lynch.

[rdrivera2005]

@Reeder - Could you explain why you are voting me and suggest we lynch Ezio tat I am pushing all day long?

[MeanLaQueefa]

eh maybe everyone can't agree jamie is a bad lynch today lol, things changed as I wrote that. I still think jamie isn't the best lynch here.

[brainbomb]

Vash would always try to lynch me here as town

[MeanLaQueefa]

Also, why does balki being a good player mean it's too risky to kill him? Balki and brain both seem to be saying that? Isn't it a bigger risk to leave him alive if he is so good at being mafia?

[thamrick]

Vash would always try to lynch me here as town

Vash isn't here. I can't get behind a Vash lynch beyond just policy for being unhelpful. If we're wrong, where do we go from there?

[Jamiet99uk]

@Jamiet - who are you leaning at this point?

I read Rdrivera,MeanlaQueeffa,DemobRHK, you and perhaps Brainbomb as Town.

I lean scum on Ezio, Balki, Rjcm, and ND.

I am suspicious of Bozo and SuperSteve.

[brainbomb]

Calling it rn vash is a good scum role. He always does this shit when hes hooker or godfather

[brainbomb]

Lol jamie is voting vash and it isnt even a scumread

[Jamiet99uk]

Where is a vote count?

[ND]

Fuck it.

##VOTE SNOWY

Less convinced on Brain now. So my next read is Snowy primarily for a meta reason (lack of posting and lack of participation and lack of anything really)

Vote Snowy!

[RagingIke297]

Day One Vote Count 4.1

ND (4): snowy801, bozotheclown, Rjmcf, Foxcastle
Balki Bartokomous (3): MeanLaQueefa, yavuzovic, Maniac
DemonRHK (2): Tom Bombadil, Ezio,
VastaNeurotic (2): Jamiet99uk, brainbomb
Jamiet99uk (2): Balki Bartokomous, DemonRHK
brainbomb (1): bo_sox48
yavuzovic (1): dargorygel
Rjmcf (1): thamrick
Ezio (1): rdrivera2005
RDrivera2005 (1): reedeer1
Reedeer1 (1): VashtaNeurotic
snowy801 (1):ND


Not voted (1): SuperSteve

Currently ND is set to be lynched. You have 18 minutes remaining.


All players must vote by the end of the day.

[Jamiet99uk]

##CALL GM - Why are there no vote counts and can we have one please?

[brainbomb]

Ok Jamie. Why are you voting vash if hes not in your scumreads?

[brainbomb]

##Vote Jamiet99uk

[thamrick]

Of the lead wagons, ND is the one I'm most comfortable with.

##Vote ND

@ND - why has your scum hunting been so lazy? Really, the best vote you can come up with for EoD is a vote based on meta?

RIP SuperSteve

[reedeer1]

At - rd. I voted you because of some of the interesting dialogue you had on some of the first pages. I meant to shift my vote on to my second choice Ezio in my last post ##Vote Ezio

The reason for Ezio is similar, but also just a gut feeling like all my reads and votes end up being. I found his posts to be scummy.

At - thamrick, My reads have not changed, and I did supply the list I had before. The only changes have been that I have grown suspicious of Balki, but not enough for a vote, and I think bozo could be town. Also Brainbomb has been jumping from possibly a PR to Possibly town, to possibly a VT.

[brainbomb]

Did you get mad yer teammate vash isnt playing enough Jamie?