M72 - “Echoes of Evelyn” - Game Thread [HIDDEN]

[damo666]

I think Maniac should be tomorrow's kill assuming he survives the night.

[Jamiet99uk]

I think Maniac should be tomorrow's kill assuming he survives the night.

Finally.

[Chaqa]

Oh well this is starting to go horribly wrong.

I think either Maniac or Chaqa is the GF.

I don't think scum would engineer a fake role block for a goon so I have down to the following:

Maniac ghug
Maniac Bob
Chaqa Maniac
Chaqa ghug
Chaqa Bob
Ghug Maniac
Ghug Bob

With the bottom 2 a bit less likely.

You having a laugh?

[Maniac]

RIP HR

[damo666]

Oh well this is starting to go horribly wrong.

I think either Maniac or Chaqa is the GF.

I don't think scum would engineer a fake role block for a goon so I have down to the following:

Maniac ghug
Maniac Bob
Chaqa Maniac
Chaqa ghug
Chaqa Bob
Ghug Maniac
Ghug Bob

With the bottom 2 a bit less likely.

You having a laugh?

No. I'm extremely serious.

[Chaqa]

Oh well this is starting to go horribly wrong.

I think either Maniac or Chaqa is the GF.

I don't think scum would engineer a fake role block for a goon so I have down to the following:

Maniac ghug
Maniac Bob
Chaqa Maniac
Chaqa ghug
Chaqa Bob
Ghug Maniac
Ghug Bob

With the bottom 2 a bit less likely.

You having a laugh?

No. I'm extremely serious.

Explain why as scum I would agree to the N1 roleblock claim, make a critical vote on celaph, push Durga all game, voraciously defend Bona, ghug, HR, etc., keep pushing people that the “consensus” says I shouldn’t, or any other thing?

I was actually expecting a nightkill to hit me tonight because I’m so town

[Chaqa]

And you have a team of me and Maniac listed but think I’m specifically GF. I can’t be Gf and be maniac’s teammate

[damo666]

And you have a team of me and Maniac listed but think I’m specifically GF. I can’t be Gf and be maniac’s teammate

The pairings are in the order GF goon

[Chaqa]

And you have a team of me and Maniac listed but think I’m specifically GF. I can’t be Gf and be maniac’s teammate

The pairings are in the order GF goon

You have it listed “Chaqa Maniac”

Maniac cannot be the goon.

Also - on day 4 I had basically the deciding vote between Vecna and HR. If I were scum with Vecna, while the cop was alive, and Vecna being the roleblocker, why would I bus him and save HR, and defend HR today, when I could just have gotten the HR miskill then and there?

[damo666]

What can we glean from voting?

Day 1 durga and celaph both voting Bob implies Bob almost certainly not GF

Day 2 similarly due to durga/celaph votes TFB almost certainly not GF

Jamie/Donny/rdr virtually simultaneously voting celaph when TFB 8-6 looks very good especially considering TFB unlikely GF. I consider it enough to lock town these 3.

Ghug's vote also looks ghug but not enough to lock town him.

HR looks bad if TFB is town.

Day 3

Chaqa self vote bizarre.

The people with best credit from durga votes are gold and TFB

Day 4

Chaqa looks good unless HR is GF

Kgr best looking Vecna vote and considering roleblocks I put her lockdown.

Vecna's gold vote implies gold not GF and as gold cannot be goon gold is locktown.

Day 5

A mess.

Conclusions:

GF pool: Maniac HR ghug
Goon pool: Chaqa HR ghug Bob

Possible pairs GF goon in order of likelihood

HR Chaqa
Maniac HR
Maniac ghug
Maniac Bob
Maniac Chaqa
HR ghug
HR Bob
ghug HR
ghug Bob
ghug Chaqa

Looking back to this HRs flip improves Chaqa's look and I don't know why I didn't give him credit for his D2 celaph vote (going from TFB 6 cel 4 to 5-5). Given this and the N1 roleblock claim I now give Chaqa the benefit of the doubt and assume he is town.

So now I am down to:

Maniac ghug
Maniac Bob
Ghug Maniac
Ghug Bob

I still think Maniac is the way to go 2m.

[damo666]

Oh I'm having a mare.

Delete ghug Maniac!

[damo666]

So

MG
MB
GB

[Chaqa]

Does scum!Maniac fake claim Cop when under little pressure and his teammate Vecna is softing Cop and is on the block?

At the point it happened, even if mafia had seen RHK’s crumbs, they didn’t know there was an inno on Maniac, so it doesn’t make much sense unless he was trying to protect Vecna… which seems like something Maniac wouldn’t do?

I think Maniac is probably just town

[Jamiet99uk]

And you have a team of me and Maniac listed but think I’m specifically GF. I can’t be Gf and be maniac’s teammate

The pairings are in the order GF goon

But it is not possible for Maniac to be the Goon.

[damo666]

And you have a team of me and Maniac listed but think I’m specifically GF. I can’t be Gf and be maniac’s teammate

The pairings are in the order GF goon

But it is not possible for Maniac to be the Goon.

Yeah I know. Read on. Was a mistake.

[ghug]

Oh well this is starting to go horribly wrong.

I think either Maniac or Chaqa is the GF.

I don't think scum would engineer a fake role block for a goon so I have down to the following:

Maniac ghug
Maniac Bob
Chaqa Maniac
Chaqa ghug
Chaqa Bob
Ghug Maniac
Ghug Bob

With the bottom 2 a bit less likely.

This is a ridiculous assumption.

[ghug]

What can we glean from voting?

Day 1 durga and celaph both voting Bob implies Bob almost certainly not GF

Day 2 similarly due to durga/celaph votes TFB almost certainly not GF

Jamie/Donny/rdr virtually simultaneously voting celaph when TFB 8-6 looks very good especially considering TFB unlikely GF. I consider it enough to lock town these 3.

Ghug's vote also looks ghug but not enough to lock town him.

HR looks bad if TFB is town.

Day 3

Chaqa self vote bizarre.

The people with best credit from durga votes are gold and TFB

Day 4

Chaqa looks good unless HR is GF

Kgr best looking Vecna vote and considering roleblocks I put her lockdown.

Vecna's gold vote implies gold not GF and as gold cannot be goon gold is locktown.

Day 5

A mess.

Conclusions:

GF pool: Maniac HR ghug
Goon pool: Chaqa HR ghug Bob

Possible pairs GF goon in order of likelihood

HR Chaqa
Maniac HR
Maniac ghug
Maniac Bob
Maniac Chaqa
HR ghug
HR Bob
ghug HR
ghug Bob
ghug Chaqa

Looking back to this HRs flip improves Chaqa's look and I don't know why I didn't give him credit for his D2 celaph vote (going from TFB 6 cel 4 to 5-5). Given this and the N1 roleblock claim I now give Chaqa the benefit of the doubt and assume he is town.

So now I am down to:

Maniac ghug
Maniac Bob
Ghug Maniac
Ghug Bob

I still think Maniac is the way to go 2m.

Why aren't you giving me credit for my celaph vote?

[Jamiet99uk]

Let's all just agree it's Maniac.

[damo666]

Why aren't you giving me credit for my celaph vote?

Ghug's vote also looks good but not enough to lock town him.

I did [see correction] but it was not a critical vote when you made it, it could easily be a risky bus which you let ride since it looked like TFB was for the chop and you got caught out with the 5 late switches to celaph.

[damo666]

Let's all just agree it's Maniac.

Yep. Maniac 2m. Those alive on d8 can worry about the goon.