M72 - “Echoes of Evelyn” - Game Thread [HIDDEN]

[ghug]

I don't want to kill kgray, Flum, celaph, Durga, Lamp, Maniac, Vecna, Llama, HR, bozo, or boat today. Anyone else is fair game.

Llama and Bozo seem out of place on this list

I don't think Llama carelessly +1s my post if he's scum worried about the consequences of his lurking, which is enough of a push towards town that he's out for the day. I think bozo's list and responses to it were a good way to generate discussion, and he seemed comfortable explaining his thought process.

[celaph]

Well, Jamie is probably town at least. He's never really this passionate about being right over something so insignificant as scum

This is not true. The time he decided to push that I (his scum teammate) had scumslipped is a good counterexample.

I thought of this as well, but rereading Jamie's iso that day it felt more like he was gloating whereas here he has been engaging in the counterarguments more. Perhaps I'm making something out of nothing, but he feels more open to being wrong right now.

[ghug]

I don't want to kill kgray, Flum, celaph, Durga, Lamp, Maniac, Vecna, Llama, HR, bozo, or boat today. Anyone else is fair game.

Is this an unordered or ordered list?

Yes

[Bonatogether]

This seems like a really weird thing to take issue with Bona. Can you explain why you think changing syntax in this particular context is scummy instead of just NAI?

it shows the thought they're putting into the message is at a different level from their other stuff, which immediately begs the question 'why' and 'what were they looking to get out of this'

i scumlean it because new players are usually not changing how much they think about something in the middle like that

Right and what's the answer to those two questions? You clearly have an opinion, why don't you share it?

if i had an answer i wouldn't need to ask it lmao

my best guess is that's indicative of a tense, high-strung dude trying to not get bombed in his first game, but being scum is not far behind

[Durga]

blamp, this is a stupid take

also the sudden jump to talk formally from not even capitalizing makes me kinda scumread you cause i do that sometimes when i'm lying. also you go back to not capitalizing like a nerd next paragraph

Bona, could you try to refrain from repeatedly calling people "stupid".
It isn't very nice.

the post is stupid

blamp might be stupid too, but he hangs out with durga so he can't be that dumb

Thank... You?

[TheFlyingBoat]

blamp, this is a stupid take

also the sudden jump to talk formally from not even capitalizing makes me kinda scumread you cause i do that sometimes when i'm lying. also you go back to not capitalizing like a nerd next paragraph

Bona, could you try to refrain from repeatedly calling people "stupid".
It isn't very nice.

the post is stupid

blamp might be stupid too, but he hangs out with durga so he can't be that dumb

Counterpoint

[Bonatogether]

##vote TheFlyingBoat

Someone being ever-present for the entire shitposting phase only to pretty much disappear into the aether ever since, and only crop up whenever they're the object of discussions; aside from parroting questions at RHK on data, is a pretty disappointing display.

I mean I thought I had some decent questions on bozo's list, which weren't all asked by others and after answer he answered them I personally viewed him as a slight town lean after. But also in my view the most interesting things that happened in the pages between 18 and like 32 were bozo's list, deathllama's return, and bona seizing on blamp with a lot of words but not a lot of actual explanation or backing to the argument, which is why I responded to it.

imagine this being your response to a vote by HR of all people

[Durga]

Feels like bona is being a lot meaner than usual

[Fluminator]

I'm surprised Flum isn't more obsessed with Donny considering he threw that one game to him

I'm a little worried he mentioned he went back to M61 and concluded I was being truthful about the trust tell when I made this post pretty early on in that game. I want to scumread him for that, but he does feel pretty townie at a gut feel.

The pizza tell actually broke a few games imo.

FTR, I'm not actually starting a trust tell. It's to illustrate there's always ways to break games.
In one diplomacy game I was really indignant when I got teamed out for trying to blackmail a rulebreaker into doing what I said or else I'd report him to the mods. But now that I've gotten older and more mature, I can understand the viewpoint that it's not that great or clever to always try to break the game in your advantage even if it's not officially cheating.

"

How do you square that with your play this game?

What's there to square?

[ghug]

I don't want to kill kgray, Flum, celaph, Durga, Lamp, Maniac, Vecna, Llama, HR, bozo, or boat today. Anyone else is fair game.

out of curiosity why is celaph and flum on there and why is jamie not?

Celaph gets a day because he's good as town and not especially dangerous as scum (the latter isn't a requirement (see kgray (nested parentheses are great)), but is nice). I've explained that I think Flum's shenanigans are more likely to be town motivated. I slightly scumread Jamie.

[DeathLlama8]

Feels like bona is being a lot meaner than usual

oh I thought this too last night but I thought I was just stressed

[ghug]

ghug are you going to vote

Yeah yeah I'm getting to it.

[Fluminator]

##Vote Flyingboat
I know I scumread him every day 1, but this time I think it's for real lol.

[celaph]

I don't want to kill kgray, Flum, celaph, Durga, Lamp, Maniac, Vecna, Llama, HR, bozo, or boat today. Anyone else is fair game.

What is your opinion of HR's comments on Boat? I assume he's still on here for y'alls earlier exchange.

[Bonatogether]

If Fox is subbing out, does that make Vecna the sub? I'm for sure not voting Vecna today.

tbh I don't feel like celaph is in his town groove but I want to see if that picks up and certainly don't support him dying D1.

Okay I'll back off your boy for now

##vote tfb

ty

##vote tfb

##vote theflyingboat

choo choo

[ghug]

Donny seems a little bit obsessed with Flum this game

I'm surprised Flum isn't more obsessed with Donny considering he threw that one game to him

Wasn't just to him.

[Donny Dude]

I like DL statement on not acquiescing to my thing on voting but then he went back to just Bob so ehh
I do agree on the point about Damo being super decisive though.

[DeathLlama8]

hm how do people feel about donny

asking because it feels like a lot of people are gut townreading him but I'm not really seeing what he's done to warrant that

I townleaned him for that interaction with celaph but he could also not like being called slow as scum or want to provoke, and otherwise he's been pretty floaty

[kgray]

Donny why are you liking celaph better now?

[Fluminator]

##Vote the flying boat
lmfaoooo, that was genuinely an accident this time