MAFIA XXXVIII: INFINITY WAR

[brainbomb]

The likliest explanation for your inabiloty to find any scum so far is that you are first time scum without guidance

[flash2015]

The likliest explanation for your inabiloty to find any scum so far is that you are first time scum without guidance

I think I am supposed to be slightly offended by this.

[rdrivera2005]

The likliest explanation for your inabiloty to find any scum so far is that you are first time scum without guidance

I think I am supposed to be slightly offended by this.

@Flash - Last game you were open and direct at D1, and it was a pretty towny approach. This game you are hedging a lot. Could you give some explanation why you changed your play or you don't think you changed?

[Squigs44]

Everyone is pushing on Flash, but no one is voting him. I'll start:

##vote flash

[flash2015]

The likliest explanation for your inabiloty to find any scum so far is that you are first time scum without guidance

I think I am supposed to be slightly offended by this.

@Flash - Last game you were open and direct at D1, and it was a pretty towny approach. This game you are hedging a lot. Could you give some explanation why you changed your play or you don't think you changed?

I guess my question to you is - Did you think it was an effective strategy in finding scum? If not, why should I keep following the same strategy? Especially since the noise to signal ratio on D1 is very high.

[yavuzovic]

I hate D1s



I see 83727261848 pages of posts every open.
People love writing when they don't have information but when they get valuable information, they start to think before writing and they write less. Whatever.

##vote Foxcastle
Because q qqqq qqqq QQQQQ.

[dargorygel]

@flash... so you are choosing hedgy because you don't feel that open was effective?

[flash2015]

I hate D1s



I see 83727261848 pages of posts every open.
People love writing when they don't have information but when they get valuable information, they start to think before writing and they write less. Whatever.

##vote Foxcastle
Because q qqqq qqqq QQQQQ.

##CALL GM - Rule violation! Rule violation!

[flash2015]

@flash... so you are choosing hedgy because you don't feel that open was effective?

There really isn't much information to go on. Why show false confidence in my reads?

[yavuzovic]

Rules are not deterrent unless you punish people.

[RagingIke297]

##CALL GM

When sent their role PM, does Gamora know they have a stone, or not?

VT's with stones know they have stones if they have stones

I hate D1s



I see 83727261848 pages of posts every open.
People love writing when they don't have information but when they get valuable information, they start to think before writing and they write less. Whatever.

##vote Foxcastle
Because q qqqq qqqq QQQQQ.

##CALL GM - Rule violation! Rule violation!

You should read rule 11 more carefully

[rdrivera2005]

I think I am supposed to be slightly offended by this.

@Flash - Last game you were open and direct at D1, and it was a pretty towny approach. This game you are hedging a lot. Could you give some explanation why you changed your play or you don't think you changed?

I guess my question to you is - Did you think it was an effective strategy in finding scum? If not, why should I keep following the same strategy? Especially since the noise to signal ratio on D1 is very high.

You didn't answer my question, at least not directly.

Answering yours, I think it was a really effective strategy. You were pretty obvious town at the end and you blocked my attempt to win the game. This game is not only about finding scum, being townread when you're town is also important.

[yavuzovic]

"Message - Squigs44
Squigs44
Day-1 55:27
page 14
↑xorxes: "Now SK should claim, since they can't win anyway unless Mafia wants to let them win."

Why would SK claim? He would just get NKd and the scum team gets the power stone. The only thing SK claiming does is help scum."
Or I turn back
##vote Squigs44
This is definitely fake townslip since this happened so early and it's like considered before he said that.

[ChippeRock]

Everyone is pushing on Flash, but no one is voting him. I'll start:

##vote flash

Are you saying your only voting flash because you think he's got thr biggest wagon? No explanation at all is scum behavior.

[Jamiet99uk]

##CALL GM

When sent their role PM, does Gamora know they have a stone, or not?

VT's with stones know they have stones if they have stones

Okay, so Brainbomb's claim, which has not been CC'ed, is entirely plausible.

[Jamiet99uk]

I wasn't sure that he was scum. His slip was a mistake that implied he wasn't a VT, not that implied he was scum, so I knew there was a good chance he was town. And then we never really got to probe the scum angle because he claimed doctor pretty quickly.

You felt there was a good chance he was town, but you went ahead and pressured him into claiming his role?

*slow clapping*

[ghug]

I don't get this Flash thing. Darg is still scum.

[Jamiet99uk]

I don't get this Flash thing. Darg is still scum.

What's your case? Your vote for him seemed like a page 3 joke vote.

[Squigs44]

Everyone is pushing on Flash, but no one is voting him. I'll start:

##vote flash

Are you saying your only voting flash because you think he's got thr biggest wagon? No explanation at all is scum behavior.

I had a few posts earlier saying why I think Flash might be scum. After saying those things, others have pointed out scummy things he has done since then.

[flash2015]

@Flash - Last game you were open and direct at D1, and it was a pretty towny approach. This game you are hedging a lot. Could you give some explanation why you changed your play or you don't think you changed?

I guess my question to you is - Did you think it was an effective strategy in finding scum? If not, why should I keep following the same strategy? Especially since the noise to signal ratio on D1 is very high.

You didn't answer my question, at least not directly.

Answering yours, I think it was a really effective strategy. You were pretty obvious town at the end and you blocked my attempt to win the game. This game is not only about finding scum, being townread when you're town is also important.

I **thought** I was obviously town (I don't know how I could have been more obvious)...but if I understand correctly even at the very end the other remaining players were still not confident in it. I am not going to play the same way each time to establish "meta".