MAFIA 71: "PAPERS PLEASE" - GAME THREAD [Hidden]

[snowy801]

Mafia team predictions:

bozo: lfischl/ghug/snowy, Foxcastle/Fluminator
Squigs: damo/captainmeme/TFB, Fluminator/lfischl
TheFlyingBoat: Fluminator/lfischl/captainmeme, ghug/Macca
ghug: bozo/Tom/Fluminator, captainmeme/Macca
rdrivera: Fluminator/Foxcastle/Squigs, captainmeme/bozo
Foxcastle: Tom/bozo/brainbomb, lfischl/TFB
brainbomb: Fluminator/lfischl/Macca, BesharamSabi/Squigs

You could make a spreadsheet out of this

[snowy801]

I think it's pretty interesting how much response bozo's survey has gotten given that it usually doesn't and it doesn't strike me as being particularly useful

[Foxcastle]

oh kgray was town tho. k hold on
so what you mean is that im teammates with durga who wants kgray dead

Obviously Durga's team killed kgray. So if my team predictions are correct, your team killed kgray, and I think that's an entirely reasonable supposition.

[snowy801]

so heres a weird tinfoil for ya

lfischl and bona are scum on the same team and lfischl is just voting bona because its easy and its what he usually does so he can pass by today

Which came first? The brainchicken or the bozoegg?

[Foxcastle]

I think it's pretty interesting how much response bozo's survey has gotten given that it usually doesn't and it doesn't strike me as being particularly useful

I don't think this is out of line with the response rate to Bozo's various schemes.

[bozotheclown]

Since the mafia have the advantage of being able to legitimately look for scum, I think it would be a good idea to force the scum to go on record with their reads for the remaining 5 scum slots. I would like everyone to state their best guess, and you can update it whenever you want. Please participate, maximum participation will force the scum to fabricate some reads.

I am going to go with my lfischl/ghug/snowy theory for team 1. The reasons for my lfischl/ghug suspicion should be clear, and snowy did not follow through on voting ghug D1 and defended lfischl. Also, ghug and snowy are good candidates for the Durga NK. For Durga's teammates I will go with Foxcastle and Fluminator. Fluminator for the kgray NK and the reasons kgray had for suspecting him, and Foxcastle because I do not like how he completely reversed his read on me when his read got challenged. Foxcastle also started criticizing my suspicion of lfischl despite voting for lfischl D1 and helped save Fluminator D1. Also, I am not convinced Foxcastle did not scum slip when he mentioned a second mafia PM.

Please add your best guess to the list:

bozo: lfischl/ghug/snowy, Foxcastle/Fluminator

The second PM is directly stated in several role descriptions in the set up post. Don't you usually read the setup closer?

I read the setup, but I did not pay much attention to the "provided separately" part of the mafia role PMs, so that when you first mentioned a second mafia PM, I did not know what you were referring to. I do not doubt that you are interpreting that correctly, but of course if you were mafia it would be obvious to you. When you responded to my initial question, it was clear how you would know that from the setup, so I am not saying it is an obvious scum slip, but it is something town could easily miss.

[Foxcastle]

Since the mafia have the advantage of being able to legitimately look for scum, I think it would be a good idea to force the scum to go on record with their reads for the remaining 5 scum slots. I would like everyone to state their best guess, and you can update it whenever you want. Please participate, maximum participation will force the scum to fabricate some reads.

I am going to go with my lfischl/ghug/snowy theory for team 1. The reasons for my lfischl/ghug suspicion should be clear, and snowy did not follow through on voting ghug D1 and defended lfischl. Also, ghug and snowy are good candidates for the Durga NK. For Durga's teammates I will go with Foxcastle and Fluminator. Fluminator for the kgray NK and the reasons kgray had for suspecting him, and Foxcastle because I do not like how he completely reversed his read on me when his read got challenged. Foxcastle also started criticizing my suspicion of lfischl despite voting for lfischl D1 and helped save Fluminator D1. Also, I am not convinced Foxcastle did not scum slip when he mentioned a second mafia PM.

Please add your best guess to the list:

bozo: lfischl/ghug/snowy, Foxcastle/Fluminator

The second PM is directly stated in several role descriptions in the set up post. Don't you usually read the setup closer?

I read the setup, but I did not pay much attention to the "provided separately" part of the mafia role PMs, so that when you first mentioned a second mafia PM, I did not know what you were referring to. I do not doubt that you are interpreting that correctly, but of course if you were mafia it would be obvious to you. When you responded to my initial question, it was clear how you would know that from the setup, so I am not saying it is an obvious scum slip, but it is something town could easily miss.

Literacy is a scumtell now, apparently.

[bozotheclown]

I think it's pretty interesting how much response bozo's survey has gotten given that it usually doesn't and it doesn't strike me as being particularly useful

If we get 100% participation, or close to it, I think it could be very useful late in the game.

[snowy801]

The second PM is directly stated in several role descriptions in the set up post. Don't you usually read the setup closer?

I read the setup, but I did not pay much attention to the "provided separately" part of the mafia role PMs, so that when you first mentioned a second mafia PM, I did not know what you were referring to. I do not doubt that you are interpreting that correctly, but of course if you were mafia it would be obvious to you. When you responded to my initial question, it was clear how you would know that from the setup, so I am not saying it is an obvious scum slip, but it is something town could easily miss.

Literacy is a scumtell now, apparently.

Sure is

[Fluminator]

I guess I can't be upset almost no one answered my question since I never answer questions either

[bozotheclown]

The second PM is directly stated in several role descriptions in the set up post. Don't you usually read the setup closer?

I read the setup, but I did not pay much attention to the "provided separately" part of the mafia role PMs, so that when you first mentioned a second mafia PM, I did not know what you were referring to. I do not doubt that you are interpreting that correctly, but of course if you were mafia it would be obvious to you. When you responded to my initial question, it was clear how you would know that from the setup, so I am not saying it is an obvious scum slip, but it is something town could easily miss.

Literacy is a scumtell now, apparently.

Sometimes it is.

[snowy801]

I think it's pretty interesting how much response bozo's survey has gotten given that it usually doesn't and it doesn't strike me as being particularly useful

If we get 100% participation, or close to it, I think it could be very useful late in the game.

Unsure, but I suppose each has their own way of playing

I've got no team associations for you but I'll manufacture some generic scum reads a bit later for the purpose for your survey

[Fluminator]

##vote No Kill

this is officially the best strategy don't @ me

see you in three days

i hate this but also it checks out as typical meme, which i also hate

This feels like genuine annoyance.

[Tom Bombadil]

##vote No Kill

this is officially the best strategy don't @ me

see you in three days

i hate this but also it checks out as typical meme, which i also hate

This feels like genuine annoyance.

Meaning what? You think they are teammates?

[snowy801]

lmfao
##unvote Bona
I can't

why was this hilarious?

It was. You had to be there.

Are we allowed to +1 again? Did my warnings reset over the night?

I'd like an answer to this too incidentally

[Fluminator]

I wouldn't know because I don't read posts more than 3 sentences long

Liar. You read Eden's goodbye.

Oh yeah I read that one for the drama.

Anyway foxy doing role pm analysis irked me and then I reminded myself that irking me is probably a good thing but also teammates should always be listed in the role pm so idk why you'd even consider they aren't but I also just don't want to go into this because we have no way of knowing

Lol, this is funnier in hindsight.

[Fluminator]

i hate this but also it checks out as typical meme, which i also hate

This feels like genuine annoyance.

Meaning what? You think they are teammates?

Yes, I could definitely see Meme wanting to kill Kgray for the memes too.

[brainbomb]

so I killed my own teammate kgray?

you arent thinking this whole team composition through very well

... I have never even scumread kgray, let alone put her on a team with you.

kgray was town so it made no sense. lol

[Fluminator]

why was this hilarious?

It was. You had to be there.

Are we allowed to +1 again? Did my warnings reset over the night?

I'd like an answer to this too incidentally

I said everyone only had one +1 to use because everyone gets a free warning. He +1ed that post.

But then Jamiet missed him doing it and it was sad.

[Fluminator]

Macca idgaf attitude is good vibes

Interesting interactions with Macca if you search their name in Durga's iso. She does a complete 180 on townreading Macca to scumreading them.

That's actually quite scummy. I could see Macca noticing that and wanting to nightkill her for that.
It could also be she forgot her read on teammate Macca but I think that's less likely.