M1019 – Once Upon A Time… [GAME THREAD] [HIDDEN]

[Durga]

@Durga when you wake up what was your question for me? I literally Ctrl+Fed for TFB and TheFlyingBoat and I didn't find any unanswered questions using the bot. It's possible I am missing something still, but I just don't know what question you're talking about. And I know you're trying to make this out to be scummy behavior but missing a question, asking for it to be re-asked, and then answering it to satisfaction happened every now and then. I am being genuine in asking for whatever questions you have for me.

I did NOT make it out to be scum behaviour. You're the one who is saying that me apparently not asking anyone any questions is scum behavior. Don't twist it.

[BunnyGo]

I have the utmost respect for Jamiet99uk

##vote Jamie

This is a typical example of english oppression against the scottish nature, I will not let that happen

##vote damo666

Kaka and damo go back and forth a bit here. He also posts that Jamie is "heart symbol" and that he said stuff in pregame about Jamie. Did he? I don't have pre-game thread here.

[BunnyGo]

Good morning, Durga.

[Durga]

Also Durga, ghug and I talked before in the chat and we would like to have another one voted out today. So would you please comply and vote either uber or snowy? (They couldn't come to a common ground so please choose one of them).

This is where kaka "claims" his whole team. Not sure what to make of it, as I don't know kaka, but most scum players have trouble choosing all town or all scum as their claimed teammates.

Where do you get that last idea from? I can assure you this time he chose two town

[Durga]

Good morning, Durga.

Good morning, I found your self defeating post about not being able to read people kinda sad but mostly a bit out of character - what was up with that

[BunnyGo]

Also Durga, ghug and I talked before in the chat and we would like to have another one voted out today. So would you please comply and vote either uber or snowy? (They couldn't come to a common ground so please choose one of them).

This is where kaka "claims" his whole team. Not sure what to make of it, as I don't know kaka, but most scum players have trouble choosing all town or all scum as their claimed teammates.

Where do you get that last idea from? I can assure you this time he chose two town

People are bad at randomly choosing and faking things.

[Durga]

This is where kaka "claims" his whole team. Not sure what to make of it, as I don't know kaka, but most scum players have trouble choosing all town or all scum as their claimed teammates.

Where do you get that last idea from? I can assure you this time he chose two town

People are bad at randomly choosing and faking things.

Okay so you're shading me or implying I'm scum because kaka randomly picked me and ghug and ghug turned out to be town? That's really your take here?

[BunnyGo]

Good morning, Durga.

Good morning, I found your self defeating post about not being able to read people kinda sad but mostly a bit out of character - what was up with that

It’s all true, I often find I get worse at games as I start learning new techniques and trying to consciously incorporate them. I usually sit down and reflect on what I’m getting out of games after I play and before I sign up. I completely missed on Sabi (both on who I thought they was as a game player and in game reading) last game. And I realized I wanted a game to sit back and recalibrate.

[BunnyGo]

Where do you get that last idea from? I can assure you this time he chose two town

People are bad at randomly choosing and faking things.

Okay so you're shading me or implying I'm scum because kaka randomly picked me and ghug and ghug turned out to be town? That's really your take here?

I’m saying it’s a data point in favor of that. Yes. Do you think that we should ignore everything kaka did?

[BunnyGo]

People are bad at randomly choosing and faking things.

Okay so you're shading me or implying I'm scum because kaka randomly picked me and ghug and ghug turned out to be town? That's really your take here?

I’m saying it’s a data point in favor of that. Yes. Do you think that we should ignore everything kaka did?

I realize this specific take is one that you know the answer to, but if he’d named someone else, what would be your thought?

[Durga]

People are bad at randomly choosing and faking things.

Okay so you're shading me or implying I'm scum because kaka randomly picked me and ghug and ghug turned out to be town? That's really your take here?

I’m saying it’s a data point in favor of that. Yes. Do you think that we should ignore everything kaka did?

Uh no, but something like that is so calculated that you couldn't possibly just assume he would have picked a team member. Obviously I have the benefit of knowing he didn't, but why don't you go back and read what that convo was like and see whether you think that was a scum and scum interaction.

Or is this the line of questioning because now that ghug is dead you need a reason to scum read someone else? Feels kinda lazy tbh.

I think it's okay to speculate but to say he wouldn't have picked two town is silly.

[BunnyGo]

Okay so you're shading me or implying I'm scum because kaka randomly picked me and ghug and ghug turned out to be town? That's really your take here?

I’m saying it’s a data point in favor of that. Yes. Do you think that we should ignore everything kaka did?

Uh no, but something like that is so calculated that you couldn't possibly just assume he would have picked a team member. Obviously I have the benefit of knowing he didn't, but why don't you go back and read what that convo was like and see whether you think that was a scum and scum interaction.

Or is this the line of questioning because now that ghug is dead you need a reason to scum read someone else? Feels kinda lazy tbh.

I think it's okay to speculate but to say he wouldn't have picked two town is silly.

I think you're reading too heavily into what I'm saying, and are cherry picking from my reread the one post about you (as there are not many about you). I am reading what the convoy was like; it's a bit weirder the second time needing to use time stamps to differentiate "live" conversation rather than solo posts.

So far the thread is: lots of shitposting noise from ghug, snowy, damo, kaka. Some TFB showing up loudly, and then running away. You showing up and reminding us you never read the set up, but then mostly playing to type, Jamie jumping in with a "time-zoned" wall of posts, and DeathLlama piping in with mostly shitposts.

And everything ghug and snowy and damo thought isn't worth much on reread because they're all town who knew nothing (except that 2 of them were PRs) so the only gleaning is what kaka did, and what the unknown people did.

[Durga]

I just think that "surely he didn't pick two town" isn't a take worth considering

[BunnyGo]

What if we daykill rdr?

If you're up for it, we could.

Though I would prefer other first, but still, I'm not against.

Kak is scum, town Kak would never agree to DK me.

This is a post that has aged really well from rdr.

[BunnyGo]

I just think that "surely he didn't pick two town" isn't a take worth considering

Read my post again without misquoting it and tell me you still aren't misreading what I said.

[Doom427]

If you're up for it, we could.

Though I would prefer other first, but still, I'm not against.

Kak is scum, town Kak would never agree to DK me.

This is a post that has aged really well from rdr.

BunnyGo is scum, Town Bunnygo would never agree with RDR.

(This is me pointing out that post is... a joke? Pretty sure that's an inside joke of some kind)

[BunnyGo]

Kak is scum, town Kak would never agree to DK me.

This is a post that has aged really well from rdr.

BunnyGo is scum, Town Bunnygo would never agree with RDR.

(This is me pointing out that post is... a joke? Pretty sure that's an inside joke of some kind)

I'm very confused, but Ok...good morning, Doom.

Out of curiosity, do you think you're feeling more comfortable here after the gaming chat at the end of last game? Am I off on that guess?

[Doom427]

Ok, I did a quick reread, and...

Town Vecna-
Voted Kak and put him at 2

Scum Vecna-
Only actual comments was a small fight with Snowy over townreading me over an analysis I did.

Town Bunny-
Been doing a lot of readings?

Scum Bunny-
As miller, he didn't get in people's faces this much, like at all? Maybe it comes across differently because it's getting responded to, and there's isn't much else in thread but...It def feels like a different game.
Second point-The killing Ghug thing. I mean, WIFOM and w/e, but pushing Ghug during the night as scummy, and not seeing any traction, so deciding to kill him? Feels v. possible. Esp. cause a big chunk of his argument was Ghug was in charge and not scoring any kills.

All of my scumreads last game were... wrong? So this one probs is too, but

[Doom427]

This is a post that has aged really well from rdr.

BunnyGo is scum, Town Bunnygo would never agree with RDR.

(This is me pointing out that post is... a joke? Pretty sure that's an inside joke of some kind)

I'm very confused, but Ok...good morning, Doom.

Out of curiosity, do you think you're feeling more comfortable here after the gaming chat at the end of last game? Am I off on that guess?

Maybe? But Think the biggest difference between the games so far for me has been work laptop, or no work laptop. I play on my phone when not at work, so can't edit posts as much. Video game chat was fun though... /sigh

Just grabbed a 100 psn card the other day and did a massive vita buying binge before the store dies. That was fun

[Doom427]

it was the best the class had produced thus far

Quoting the actual post, so people can see it in context-

What feels odd is Vecna hadn't... made any actual posts at all at this point?

I get people posting less, but spending time saying "Well, she's been producing the best thing so far, so town read" when you've produced... nothing? Feels like a very reactive play that feels active while not pushing forward your own analysis. Don't know if that's Vecna's style as scum, but it would be one