M70 - THE BASKIN-ROBBINS CONSPIRACY [HIDDEN]

[snowy801]

No, I think Eden is town. I just don't like his assumption that we were actually going to catch Chaqa and that kind of 'you ruined an opportunity' thing rings pretty hollow. It's one more scumpoint to Eden I guess, but still a townread.

I think it just shows how dumb he is, if you ask me
Or he's sad he missed an opportunity to further romance Chaqa, but

Y'all are silly if you think Chaqa couldn't have slipped there and had it teased out. I cannot tell you how many times an analogous thing has happened in regular conversation. He's NOT dumb but he really is that distractable and absentminded. In the middle of work with his dog barking to be let out or eat or whatever with a hectic EOD looming he 100% could have fucked that up

Regardless it is strictly optimal to approach it the way I did and not blurt out the obvious like y'all did

Shrug
I didn't need to be convinced further. Perhaps I should've considered that others did, but I don't think the Chaqa question needs further settling. I just thought it was funny

[Durga]

I'll turn my brain back on before EOD and think about it more, but I would rather lose by voting them both off as town than lose because I ignored Chaqa saying that

##VOTE Chaqa

Tell him, Durga

He's worthless

[Vecna]

Anyway... that might have genuinely been a slip but it's impossible to tell now. THANKS GUYS

What reaction was he gonna give that wouldve actually resulted in you thinking that though?

You really think he was going to repeat and actually type out he wanted to kill flum?

[Jamiet99uk]

I'll turn my brain back on before EOD and think about it more, but I would rather lose by voting them both off as town than lose because I ignored Chaqa saying that

##VOTE Chaqa

Tell him, Durga

He's worthless

Ooooft

[Vecna]

Anyway... that might have genuinely been a slip but it's impossible to tell now. THANKS GUYS

This reaction I don't like, though.

good

[President Eden]

Anyway... that might have genuinely been a slip but it's impossible to tell now. THANKS GUYS

What reaction was he gonna give that wouldve actually resulted in you thinking that though?

You really think he was going to repeat and actually type out he wanted to kill flum?

I'm more flabbergasted that y'all think this is impossible. Do y'all even know Chaqa? He most definitely could have, and it was literally free to attempt.

[TheFlyingBoat]

I'll turn my brain back on before EOD and think about it more, but I would rather lose by voting them both off as town than lose because I ignored Chaqa saying that

##VOTE Chaqa

Tell him, Durga

He's worthless

Damn, Durga, tell us how you really feel lol

[Tom Bombadil]

I think this analisys so weak and forced in so many points. Scum could know Chaqa is town (and even believe Chaqa is Cop) but decide to not risk a kill because there is a Doctor. If the Doc saves Chaqa scum loses a kill and town got 2 insta-clear. Better RB him and kill another possible Cop and still have the chance to push for his DK. Chaqa could still be scum, but this simplistic analisys is so off for Tom.

Also, a lot of experienced people like Eden thought Damo was Cop, so why only an less experienced team will kill Damo?

Also, point 2 is just bizarre, when did you see scum kill over town reads? Damos town reads on D1? And when did scum didn´t want to hit PRs, specially in a no flip game?

Wellcome to my probably scum list Tom.

Interesting points. Quick question about the end: why is tom on your scum list? Because he sucks?

Because it looks like low effort, like you need to post something to look like you are trying. And it´s usually Mafia that do such a thing.

I do not think it is simplistic analysis. I think your retort is simplistic. I understand if Chaqa is town, scum not wanting to kill him because of doctor. My point is that is Chaqa is town, and they thought him doctor, they would likely hunt for another PR - and damo would presumably be the least likely choice since he clearly softer cop. Why as another PR would you try to draw a NK by faking cop? So your hypothesis of scum could think Chaqa cop and try to hit another cop(if they are wrong or another PR) makes no sense since damo would be unlikely to be a PR.

[snowy801]

This game is too fucking long

[BunnyGo]

##unvote

[kgray]

I remember you trying to start a Jamie wagon with fifteen minutes left.

Nice avoiding the question. And what you did was 7 million times scummier so gtfo on this.

See, I don't think you'd be constantly pretending I'm not answering your questions if you were arguing in good faith. I don't think you actually pushed that hard to kill Chaqa, and I think your original justification for scumreading him was questionable in the same "teammate who knows too much" sort of way.

How do you figure that what I did was scummier?

Well I'm not really arguing with you in good faith anymore tbf.

I think it's garbage that you think I wasn't trying that hard to kill Chaqa when I was going out of my way to ask people if they agreed with my point. I tried a lot harder than you did even though you'd been allegedly scumreading him all day. And it's totally disingenuous to say that interaction was the original justification for me scumreading him, because I'd talked about other things I thought were suspicious earlier.

Encouraging a wagon you don't care enough to actually vote for is scummy.

[TheFlyingBoat]

This game is too fucking long

The issue is we don't get the endorphins from being right and more importantly from being able to tell others just how wrong they were.

[DemonRHK]

Completely Fallible Human Yet GM Vote Count Day Two The Third
(Through post 4829)

bozotheclown(4) - Bonatogether, worcej, kgray, Jamiet99uk
worcej(3) - bozotheclown, BesharamSabi*, Tom Bombadil
kgray(3) - ghug, snowy801, Fluminator
snowy801(2) - Vecna*, Chaqa
Tom Bombadil(2) - rdrivera2005, Doom427
Chaqa(2) - President Eden, TheFlyingBoat
rdrivera2005(1) - Durga
Vecna(1) - lfischl
Bonatogether(1) - BunnyGo

Currently, BOZOTHECLOWN is set to be killed.

2 Hours remain in Day 2.

[snowy801]

This game is too fucking long

The issue is we don't get the endorphins from being right and more importantly from being able to tell others just how wrong they were.

No I don't mean it like that, I mean there's just too much to sift through for in terms of evidence and rereads. I'm having a blast

[Fluminator]

Why don't we organize a time on saturday where we play with endvotes and play it essentially live.

[BunnyGo]

What about daykilling you for placing the apostrophe in "y'all" in the wrong spot like a dirty Yankee?

Ya all -> Ya'll

NJ

That’s spelled yous or youse

[Vecna]

He seems hyper to you?

yes, very much so

Hey! That’s two obv towns who want the Bona train back! ##vote bona!

##vote Bona

[BunnyGo]

Ya all -> Ya'll

NJ

Excuse me sir we from NJ have our faults, but we would never abbreviate y'all so heinously

Exactly!

[snowy801]

Nice avoiding the question. And what you did was 7 million times scummier so gtfo on this.

See, I don't think you'd be constantly pretending I'm not answering your questions if you were arguing in good faith. I don't think you actually pushed that hard to kill Chaqa, and I think your original justification for scumreading him was questionable in the same "teammate who knows too much" sort of way.

How do you figure that what I did was scummier?

Well I'm not really arguing with you in good faith anymore tbf.

I think it's garbage that you think I wasn't trying that hard to kill Chaqa when I was going out of my way to ask people if they agreed with my point. I tried a lot harder than you did even though you'd been allegedly scumreading him all day. And it's totally disingenuous to say that interaction was the original justification for me scumreading him, because I'd talked about other things I thought were suspicious earlier.

Encouraging a wagon you don't care enough to actually vote for is scummy.

To be honest ghug I think it's an extremely weak argument to make that kgray wasn't trying her hardest to get Chaqa killed.

The punches were strong enough that even if she pulled it last moment it would've brought others in (see: Eden, and others maybe I don't remember)

[Jamiet99uk]

Why don't we organize a time on saturday where we play with endvotes and play it essentially live.

I've got better things to be doing on Saturday than coordinating my diary with you scrubs.