M70 - THE BASKIN-ROBBINS CONSPIRACY [HIDDEN]

[ghug]

Anyways to get the chat back to something productive, where are we consensus wise on how to proceed? I think we seemed to be in favor of a day kill for reasons I and others expounded on and while I'm in favor of the miller claiming early for reasons I went over earlier I,recognize there is a lack of consensus there? What are people thinking on both of those matters? Is there anything else we want to discuss.now that people have had a chance to look at the setup?

##VOTE TheFlyingBoat

Gotta love a good hypocrite in mafia

I want to say "hypocrisy is townie", but instead I'll say "says the person who just seriously responded to my question."

He was also re-asking an already asked question to seem helpful, whereas I provided my opinion when prompted.

[kgray]

##vote vecna

For real though, I have no idea what TFB said in regard to my read to you. Which is extra funny in light of Durga's post, and you then making that wall thinking its a thing.

I mean I literally asked you about what he said, and the post that I'm referring to was a quick question about a read, not one of his more rambling posts about mechs. So it was one of the least eyes-glazing-over post he's had so far.

[President Eden]

Anyways to get the chat back to something productive, where are we consensus wise on how to proceed? I think we seemed to be in favor of a day kill for reasons I and others expounded on and while I'm in favor of the miller claiming early for reasons I went over earlier I,recognize there is a lack of consensus there? What are people thinking on both of those matters? Is there anything else we want to discuss.now that people have had a chance to look at the setup?

Miller should probably claim day 1 since it's no-flip, because if we're unlucky and the miller is shot n1, then the mafia have a free fakeclaim. Unlike other power roles, there's very marginal benefit to the miller staying quiet.

The threat of a kill should be looming for most of the day.

[Chaqa]

Anyways to get the chat back to something productive, where are we consensus wise on how to proceed? I think we seemed to be in favor of a day kill for reasons I and others expounded on and while I'm in favor of the miller claiming early for reasons I went over earlier I,recognize there is a lack of consensus there? What are people thinking on both of those matters? Is there anything else we want to discuss.now that people have had a chance to look at the setup?

Miller should probably claim day 1 since it's no-flip, because if we're unlucky and the miller is shot n1, then the mafia have a free fakeclaim. Unlike other power roles, there's very marginal benefit to the miller staying quiet.

The threat of a kill should be looming for most of the day.

Eden probably town

[kgray]

##VOTE TheFlyingBoat

Gotta love a good hypocrite in mafia

I want to say "hypocrisy is townie", but instead I'll say "says the person who just seriously responded to my question."

He was also re-asking an already asked question to seem helpful, whereas I provided my opinion when prompted.

I don't think you're usually serious early in the game. I think I am. So it's not really hypocrisy on my part?

[Bonatogether]

Anyways to get the chat back to something productive, where are we consensus wise on how to proceed? I think we seemed to be in favor of a day kill for reasons I and others expounded on and while I'm in favor of the miller claiming early for reasons I went over earlier I,recognize there is a lack of consensus there? What are people thinking on both of those matters? Is there anything else we want to discuss.now that people have had a chance to look at the setup?

Miller should probably claim day 1 since it's no-flip, because if we're unlucky and the miller is shot n1, then the mafia have a free fakeclaim. Unlike other power roles, there's very marginal benefit to the miller staying quiet.

The threat of a kill should be looming for most of the day.

Eden probably town

tryhard eden is town in my experience but i've never played with scum!eden so I don't know

[TheFlyingBoat]

Can you give me a tl;Dr

Do we day kill d1? Do we ask the miller to roleclaim? When should we ask the miller to roleclaim? Does anyone have any useful thoughts on the setup and how to play it?

Thank you, I appreciate this

And what do you think? My point was to get people to talk about ideas early so they can't get away with claiming they were just going with the crowd later which is an easy way for scum to blend in.

Given that some active commenters haven't actually said anything of substance, wanted to get people to say things.

[ghug]

Gotta love a good hypocrite in mafia

I want to say "hypocrisy is townie", but instead I'll say "says the person who just seriously responded to my question."

He was also re-asking an already asked question to seem helpful, whereas I provided my opinion when prompted.

I don't think you're usually serious early in the game. I think I am. So it's not really hypocrisy on my part?

But you're me

[Vecna]

Anyways to get the chat back to something productive, where are we consensus wise on how to proceed? I think we seemed to be in favor of a day kill for reasons I and others expounded on and while I'm in favor of the miller claiming early for reasons I went over earlier I,recognize there is a lack of consensus there? What are people thinking on both of those matters? Is there anything else we want to discuss.now that people have had a chance to look at the setup?

Miller should probably claim day 1 since it's no-flip, because if we're unlucky and the miller is shot n1, then the mafia have a free fakeclaim. Unlike other power roles, there's very marginal benefit to the miller staying quiet.

The threat of a kill should be looming for most of the day.

Eden probably town

Hey Chaqa, can you explain this read?

[Chaqa]

I want to say "hypocrisy is townie", but instead I'll say "says the person who just seriously responded to my question."

He was also re-asking an already asked question to seem helpful, whereas I provided my opinion when prompted.

I don't think you're usually serious early in the game. I think I am. So it's not really hypocrisy on my part?

But you're me

ghug = kgray
Eden = Chaqa

[Chaqa]

Miller should probably claim day 1 since it's no-flip, because if we're unlucky and the miller is shot n1, then the mafia have a free fakeclaim. Unlike other power roles, there's very marginal benefit to the miller staying quiet.

The threat of a kill should be looming for most of the day.

Eden probably town

Hey Chaqa, can you explain this read?

Eden agrees with me about the Miller.

[ghug]

I don't think you're usually serious early in the game. I think I am. So it's not really hypocrisy on my part?

But you're me

ghug = kgray
Eden = Chaqa

I feel like this is offensive to both you and Eden.

[TheFlyingBoat]

##VOTE TheFlyingBoat

Gotta love a good hypocrite in mafia

I want to say "hypocrisy is townie", but instead I'll say "says the person who just seriously responded to my question."

He was also re-asking an already asked question to seem helpful, whereas I provided my opinion when prompted.

I wasn't asking you directly. I was asking the group since we had almost an entire page dedicated to Stellaris and cats smh.

[ghug]

Gotta love a good hypocrite in mafia

I want to say "hypocrisy is townie", but instead I'll say "says the person who just seriously responded to my question."

He was also re-asking an already asked question to seem helpful, whereas I provided my opinion when prompted.

I wasn't asking you directly. I was asking the group since we had almost an entire page dedicated to Stellaris and cats smh.

Why do you think I thought you were asking me specifically?

Why do you think that's what offended me about your post?

[Bonatogether]

Gotta love a good hypocrite in mafia

I want to say "hypocrisy is townie", but instead I'll say "says the person who just seriously responded to my question."

He was also re-asking an already asked question to seem helpful, whereas I provided my opinion when prompted.

I wasn't asking you directly. I was asking the group since we had almost an entire page dedicated to Stellaris and cats smh.

Why so serious? It's not even 3 hours in.

[BesharamSabi]

Do we day kill d1? Do we ask the miller to roleclaim? When should we ask the miller to roleclaim? Does anyone have any useful thoughts on the setup and how to play it?

Thank you, I appreciate this

And what do you think? My point was to get people to talk about ideas early so they can't get away with claiming they were just going with the crowd later which is an easy way for scum to blend in.

Given that some active commenters haven't actually said anything of substance, wanted to get people to say things.

Has there been games where there were no kill in d1 and what happened as a result?

[ghug]

Thank you, I appreciate this

And what do you think? My point was to get people to talk about ideas early so they can't get away with claiming they were just going with the crowd later which is an easy way for scum to blend in.

Given that some active commenters haven't actually said anything of substance, wanted to get people to say things.

Has there been games where there were no kill in d1 and what happened as a result?

We've literally never actually done it because it's always a bad idea.

[BesharamSabi]

Gotta love a good hypocrite in mafia

I want to say "hypocrisy is townie", but instead I'll say "says the person who just seriously responded to my question."

He was also re-asking an already asked question to seem helpful, whereas I provided my opinion when prompted.

I wasn't asking you directly. I was asking the group since we had almost an entire page dedicated to Stellaris and cats smh.

You love the cat tho.

[Chaqa]

Thank you, I appreciate this

And what do you think? My point was to get people to talk about ideas early so they can't get away with claiming they were just going with the crowd later which is an easy way for scum to blend in.

Given that some active commenters haven't actually said anything of substance, wanted to get people to say things.

Has there been games where there were no kill in d1 and what happened as a result?

I think there was an accidental D1 tie awhile back.

[Vecna]

Eden probably town

Hey Chaqa, can you explain this read?

Eden agrees with me about the Miller.

Hmmm, it was really hard to get you to explain anything last game when you were town.

Such a sneaky trap. I totally caught you.

bam