I can think of a scenario where scum just had strong reasons to want to get rid of Ghug (and those reasons probably have to do with him so strongly scumreading Jamiet, even after we flipped kakka).snowy801 wrote: ↑Fri Aug 13, 2021 2:18 pmsnowy801 wrote: ↑Fri Aug 13, 2021 1:38 pm1) In order for this to have happened the scum team would have to have confidence that ghug was in fact commuting, not BP or 3P, as the BP is not an auto-town clear and not as priority for day vig, and 3P is best kept alive to cause fear in town until later in the game.
The only way for this to have happened is that the item investigator N1 checked ghug and discovered it. In which case, why try to shoot the guy who can 100% save himself?
No, ghug was either watcher or napkin. I want to believe napkin, but reality says watcher.
Im guessing they either failed the NK and gunned down Ghug after to get rid of him still, with potentially the 3p sending a random msg at the same time (or them just being truely weird and random, who knows)
Or they didnt try to NK ghug but had the napkins and the gun and were doing something weird.
Me talking about this is mostly just to offer a different scenario to the one where I magically ended up with the commuting item. Me doing a towny thing does not suddenly mean it wasnt towny if an alternative becomes possible. I probably overestimated how likely it truely is, but I dont think we should discount it at all.
Regardless, at this point it doesnt really matter what scenario ultimately happened. Either we kill the 3P today, or I have to clear myself, or im going up on the block tomorrow most likely. Which would be bad.