M69: Trapped in the Chipotle R&D Lab [HIDDEN]

[Hamilton Brian]

Since we're on the topic of items, would anyone argue that it is strictly detrimental to individually choose to reveal their item, if they wanted to?

I go back and forth on it but I think it is detrimental since it makes 3P job a lot easier...unless those people holding those 5 items don't claim anything. But then it gives the 3P the opportunity to just search within that 5 person pool. Yeah, I don't think it's a good idea.

[snowy801]

Code: Select all

Name		Alternative Name	Town	Mafia	3P
Black Beans	Commute (2)		x		
Guac		Cop (2)			x		
White Rice	Doctor (2)		x		
Pinto Beans	Roleblocker (2)		x		x
Sofritas	Friendly Neighbor (2)	x		x
Steak		Day Kill (1)		x		x
Brown Rice	Faith Healer (3)	x	x	
Cheese		Fruit Vendor		x	x	
Chips		Replenisher (2)		x	x	
Pico de Gallo	Watcher (2)		x	x	
Chicken		Double Vote (2)		x	x	x
Corn Salsa	Tracker (2)		x	x	x
Hot Salsa	Hot Potato (2)		x	x	x
Lettuce		Jack-of-All-Trades	x	x	x
Napkins		Mailman			x	x	x
Queso		Day Hammer		x	x	x
Tortilla	Bulletproof (2)		x	x	x

Well the preview looks good, hope it stays that way in reality.
Here's a list of all the items and their possible spawn factions.

I mainly ask the item thing so I can throw my item around. It doesn't seem overtly harmful if I'm the only one doing it, but I guess I'll take some time to think about it before doing anything I can't take back.

[Hamilton Brian]

Again, I don't want to get us distracted from the bigger threat which is the 5 mafia. Sometimes it's easier to get sucked into the rabbit hole of "who's the 3P" when we're still flailing around about who is most likely mafia.

[Hamilton Brian]

Snowy, where do you sit with Damo after D1? Jamie? Both came up for you on D1, especially around the idea of the flash wagon.

[snowy801]

Both scummy

My current suspects are damo, jamiet, kakarroto, and (incidentally) you HB

But I haven't really sat down and thought about it since EoD too much so I'm trying not to draw conclusions

[Jamiet99uk]

Again, I don't want to get us distracted from the bigger threat which is the 5 mafia. Sometimes it's easier to get sucked into the rabbit hole of "who's the 3P" when we're still flailing around about who is most likely mafia.

There are four Mafia.
Not five.

[damo666]

Code: Select all

Name		Alternative Name	Town	Mafia	3P
Black Beans	Commute (2)		x		
Guac		Cop (2)			x		
White Rice	Doctor (2)		x		
Pinto Beans	Roleblocker (2)		x		x
Sofritas	Friendly Neighbor (2)	x		x
Steak		Day Kill (1)		x		x
Brown Rice	Faith Healer (3)	x	x	
Cheese		Fruit Vendor		x	x	
Chips		Replenisher (2)		x	x	
Pico de Gallo	Watcher (2)		x	x	
Chicken		Double Vote (2)		x	x	x
Corn Salsa	Tracker (2)		x	x	x
Hot Salsa	Hot Potato (2)		x	x	x
Lettuce		Jack-of-All-Trades	x	x	x
Napkins		Mailman			x	x	x
Queso		Day Hammer		x	x	x
Tortilla	Bulletproof (2)		x	x	x

Well the preview looks good, hope it stays that way in reality.
Here's a list of all the items and their possible spawn factions.

I mainly ask the item thing so I can throw my item around. It doesn't seem overtly harmful if I'm the only one doing it, but I guess I'll take some time to think about it before doing anything I can't take back.

1. Useful chart. Thanks.
2. Are you melting due to the Hot Potato?

[damo666]

Again, I don't want to get us distracted from the bigger threat which is the 5 mafia. Sometimes it's easier to get sucked into the rabbit hole of "who's the 3P" when we're still flailing around about who is most likely mafia.

There are four Mafia.
Not five.

Fake townslip from HamB? Or genuine?

Genuine is my guess.

[snowy801]

1. Useful chart. Thanks.
2. Are you melting due to the Hot Potato?

What makes you ask #2?

[damo666]

1. Useful chart. Thanks.
2. Are you melting due to the Hot Potato?

What makes you ask #2?

Because you said you wanted to throw your item around.

[BobMcBob]

i like hb as town here
which, given how often i scumread town!hb, may not be a good sign, but im happy with that for now

[Jamiet99uk]

I find it implausible that 11 hours into the game, Bozo had good reason to believe that Bona was townier than Vecna, that Damo was scummier than Lfischl, or that Rdrivera was townier than Macca (etcetera).

His Page 14 "town to scum" ranking was as fake as a £9 note. The way Foodcoats just became one of Bozo's biggest scumreads on the basis of one or two short posts is deeply sus. His reasoning for making Worcej his top scumread over Snowy and Foodcoats, whilst still voting for Snowy, seemed almost non-existent.

Fake fake fake fake fake.

[Hamilton Brian]

Again, I don't want to get us distracted from the bigger threat which is the 5 mafia. Sometimes it's easier to get sucked into the rabbit hole of "who's the 3P" when we're still flailing around about who is most likely mafia.

There are four Mafia.
Not five.

Fake townslip from HamB? Or genuine?

Genuine is my guess.

I misinterpreted this post from Bozo which is where I was grabbing the number 5 from. And now I lost the post off the bot. Anyway Bozo said "5 including the 3P." So a genuine error.

[worcej]

You quit the last game and the council because you were a thin-skinned crybaby, made a big show of promising to be better, and then came in insulting someone. The fact that that someone is me is only slightly relevant.

I would like to note, for the record, that just a page or two before this statement, Ghug had been insulting Worcej and calling him stupid.

Ghug is a hypocrite and his crying at me was fake.

Worcej and I were engaging in banter. I thought it was remarkably cordial and hope he agrees.

You coming in grumpily legitimately annoyed me I'm happy to drop it all and be pleasant moving forward if you are, but it was what it was.

I'm too stupid to know what cordial means.

[Jamiet99uk]

I would like to note, for the record, that just a page or two before this statement, Ghug had been insulting Worcej and calling him stupid.

Ghug is a hypocrite and his crying at me was fake.

Worcej and I were engaging in banter. I thought it was remarkably cordial and hope he agrees.

You coming in grumpily legitimately annoyed me I'm happy to drop it all and be pleasant moving forward if you are, but it was what it was.

I'm too stupid to know what cordial means.

"Cordial"
NOUN
a sweet fruit-flavoured drink.
"wine cups and fruit cordials"

[worcej]

also i have a question for ghug which i will not be awake to hear the answer to
how serious would you say your arguing with jamie was
jamie you can answer this one too

Fairly? I got pretty publicly annoyed at Jamie last game, and it was irritating to me how quickly he flopped on trying to be better, which was compounded by the fact that I had been enjoying the shitppsting up until that point.

interesting...
noting this one down for later

What is interesting here?

[Maniac]

Again, I don't want to get us distracted from the bigger threat which is the 5 mafia. Sometimes it's easier to get sucked into the rabbit hole of "who's the 3P" when we're still flailing around about who is most likely mafia.

Town slip/fake town slip - you decide

My money is on genuine town slip here. Scum HB does have any reason to fake slip, he isn’t under much pressure.

[worcej]

day 1 scumteam guess for bonus points
snowy, bona, bozo, worcej

Why?

snowy, i explained
bona, i explained
bozo, i think i may have explained, it was pretty similar to vecnas thoughts
you were tacked on mainly for bona interactions although thats moot now obviously
food can take the next slot now

What bona interactions are you referencing?

[worcej]

There was not much participation in my survey request. The mafia have a good reason to avoid going on record with a full reads ranking, but too many town ignored my request and let the mafia off the hook.

Here was my list:

1. bozo
2. Kakarroto
3. BobMcBob
4. cel​aph
5. Bonatogether
6. Vecna
7. ghug
8. HB
9. lfischl
10. damo
11. rdrivera
12. Macca
13. snowy
​14. Maniac
15. Jamie
16. foodcoats
17. worcej

Numbers 14, 15, and 17 all started scum reading me after I posted this list, I don't think that was a coincidence.

You assume too much.

You were already scumming 15 and 17 due to a shitpost. You're also explicitly getting my reasons for scumming you incorrect by saying it started after this list was made.

[BobMcBob]

Fairly? I got pretty publicly annoyed at Jamie last game, and it was irritating to me how quickly he flopped on trying to be better, which was compounded by the fact that I had been enjoying the shitppsting up until that point.

interesting...
noting this one down for later

What is interesting here?

i still find it very hard to believe that ghug was legitimately angry at jamie there
jamie did quite literally next to nothing before ghug went off
unless theres some sort of insane levels of cynicism and dislike that i havent caught onto yet, it seems way off from what is reasonable