M69: Trapped in the Chipotle R&D Lab [HIDDEN]

[snowy801]

I didn't want to interrupt the flow but I had a question for you earlier celaph.

[celaph]

If I had to vote right now I would vote Snowy, but with 8 players in the single digit posts I'll hold off and wait for more content.

So far I like Bob a lot and Vecna a fair amount. Bozo, Macca, and food all get mild endorsements. Null on all the rest.

Elaborate more on why snowy over anything else please

I think Bob had phrased it well if harped on it a little much. It felt like a lot of questions with little content as I called out

You indicated that you've had enough of the wooshtej chatter. Do you suspect any of the three major participants hide malicious intent?

This feels like asking a question for the purpose of asking a question.

At this time I note Jamiet has left without stating his reason for scum reading ghug. A convenient timing? Time will tell.

i disagree

Bona! On what grounds would you state that worcej's few initial posting does not already feel scummy? Does any of his comments stand out as towny to you?

Snowy! Why did you question Bona's disagreement, but not Vecna's original comment? Does anything in worcej's comments seem scummy to you?

are there things in there that you want me to elaborate on?



FWIW, my suspicion of snowy decreased somewhat after his response to me:

[ghug]

Really? You don't buy me calling your usual 'hey, let's mass claim X' bullshit?

It doesn't take much effort to go through the bot and look back at your games and find these pushes from you.

And the out of order thing I'm struggling with - I usually try to be 'in order' but will jump to direct responses as I see things come up.

How has bozo's decision to stop pushing the mass claim (before you ever questioned it) affected your read of him?

He is OMGUS'ing and is tunneling, which I believe when I see him tunnel he usually is scum.

How has bozo's decision to stop pushing the mass claim (before you ever questioned it) affected your read of him?

[ghug]

##VOTE Bona

Let's put some money where mouths are.

[worcej]

How has bozo's decision to stop pushing the mass claim (before you ever questioned it) affected your read of him?

He is OMGUS'ing and is tunneling, which I believe when I see him tunnel he usually is scum.

How has bozo's decision to stop pushing the mass claim (before you ever questioned it) affected your read of him?

He is OMGUS'ing and is tunneling, which I believe when I see him tunnel he usually is scum.

[ghug]

He is OMGUS'ing and is tunneling, which I believe when I see him tunnel he usually is scum.

How has bozo's decision to stop pushing the mass claim (before you ever questioned it) affected your read of him?

He is OMGUS'ing and is tunneling, which I believe when I see him tunnel he usually is scum.

How has bozo's decision to stop pushing the mass claim (before you ever questioned it) affected your read of him?

[bozotheclown]

He is OMGUS'ing and is tunneling, which I believe when I see him tunnel he usually is scum.

I had listed you as my top scum read before you voted for me, which is why I suspect your vote may have been preemptive so you could make this claim.

Your scum claim on me was rather weak (because it was established from a shitpost aimed at Jamie) and you've continued to pile on supplemental material to justify your read more than actually investigating much of anything else.

I ranked my initial reads on all players, why are you ignoring my request to do the same? What are your reads?

[snowy801]

Had a small aneurysm trying to parse celaph's post. No idea if you were addressing my previous post so again:

@celaph I noted this earlier, but on p13 you have 4 consecutive posts (in my opinion) strongly defending Bob from... not much aggression, honestly.

What would you say made you feel you needed to go out of your way to bat for Bob here, if you did?

[celaph]

I largely mislike Celaph because he has four posts in a row buddying up to Bob. One or two I can handle, but this seems excessive. Why go so far out of your way?

I've been harping on town Bob because I feel like his reads have been really well aligned with my own and I tend to assume that someone coming to the same conclusion as me is coming from a similar position as me.

[worcej]

How has bozo's decision to stop pushing the mass claim (before you ever questioned it) affected your read of him?

He is OMGUS'ing and is tunneling, which I believe when I see him tunnel he usually is scum.

How has bozo's decision to stop pushing the mass claim (before you ever questioned it) affected your read of him?

Now you’re just being annoying.

[celaph]

Also, snowy, Bob is actually quite a convincing scum player I think. One of the better ones around here.

Does that pique your interest?

since when did i gain that reputation?
i couldve sworn i was still looked down upon only a few games ago

You're certainly better than me, though I set a very low bar.

[snowy801]

Now you’re just being annoying.
[/quote]

If you don't mind, I would like to hear an answer on this one. You've addressed the periphery, but not the actual question.

Annoying ghug aside.

[ghug]

He is OMGUS'ing and is tunneling, which I believe when I see him tunnel he usually is scum.

How has bozo's decision to stop pushing the mass claim (before you ever questioned it) affected your read of him?

Now you’re just being annoying.

Maybe if you'd answer my question...

[bozotheclown]

oh, I was unaware of that little bit of pre-game banter. Not sure if it changes too much since he was all justifying it n stuff.

I was not aware of that either, but I still question foodcoats claiming he was "lost".

[worcej]

[quote=worcej post_id=248433 time=<a href="tel:1628015521">1628015521</a> user_id=857]
[quote=ghug post_id=248429 time=<a href="tel:1628015128">1628015128</a> user_id=51]
[quote=worcej post_id=248428 time=<a href="tel:1628015101">1628015101</a> user_id=857]
He is OMGUS'ing and is tunneling, which I believe when I see him tunnel he usually is scum.

How has bozo's decision to stop pushing the mass claim (before you ever questioned it) affected your read of him?
[/quote]Now you’re just being annoying.
[/quote]

Maybe if you'd answer my question...
[/quote]I kinda am - it has changed from policy kill to actually seeing him as potential scum because of his development of a case on me. It’s opportunistic and lacking merit.

[worcej]

Wow… that quote is disgusting

[snowy801]

Has anyone considered that it might be Jamiet?

[ghug]

Has anyone considered that it might be Jamiet?

Yes

[celaph]

On foodcoats, I want to comment that

1) He said he would sheep Bona or I before the game started
2) If he rolled scum, following that procedure thoughtlessly may well be exactly what he would do anyway

Still chewing on that myself

Oh, thanks for the context. Dropping food back to null for now.

[rdrivera2005]

ooh, a ranking list gambit?
sign me up!

1. bob
2. kak
3. macca
4. celaph
5. bozo
6. vecna
7. hb
8. worcej
9. damo
10. jamie
11. ghug
12. maniac
13. food
14. lfischl
15. maniac
16. bona
17. snowy

its something like that at least

Why there is two Maniacs and no rivera on this list. Have I been subbed out for inactivity?