M69: Trapped in the Chipotle R&D Lab [HIDDEN]

[worcej]

At this time I note Jamiet has left without stating his reason for scum reading ghug. A convenient timing? Time will tell.



Bona! On what grounds would you state that worcej's few initial posting does not already feel scummy? Does any of his comments stand out as towny to you?

no

it feels like normal worcej!posting

if you can read this i lost the game

How would you characterize "normal worcej" based on your history with him, and how do you think his overall posting fits this model?

What is my normal to you snowy?

I want you to respond to me with each question you're asking Bona.

[snowy801]

@Chaqa this was the specific post with the GM CALL, but there is a brief discussion from p6 - 7

I did think the hidden text was a signature.

I think, perhaps, such text ought not be allowed, even if yours is clearly just a joke such potential for hidden signalling is why signatures are banned, after all.

it's not that hidden? you saw it on the bot

Not particularly keen on debating this point, seems like a derail.

##GM CALL ruling please.

[worcej]

WHERE ARE YOU HIDING JAMIE?!?!?!

WHO IS THIS IMPOSTER?!?!?!

Worcej already feeling pretty scummy with just his few initial posting.

Possible, and Jamie could be his teammate.

I think worcej and Jamie are my top scum suspects after snowy.

Are we grasping at straws this quickly?

I'm actually confused now.

[snowy801]

no

it feels like normal worcej!posting

if you can read this i lost the game

How would you characterize "normal worcej" based on your history with him, and how do you think his overall posting fits this model?

What is my normal to you snowy?

I want you to respond to me with each question you're asking Bona.

I don't meta read people, so it isn't particularly relevant to me, but normal worcej to me is a fairly obvious lurking scum.

As to your previous question, it was already addressed but no.

[damo666]

Rough 1 to 17 for Bozo's survey

1. Damo
2. Bob
3. Bozo
4. Kak
4. Vecna
4 Ham B
7. Food
7. Ghug
7. rdr
7. worcej
7. Jamie
7. Celaph
7. Snowy
14. Lfischl
14. Macca
14. Maniac
17. Bona

[Chaqa]

@Chaqa this was the specific post with the GM CALL, but there is a brief discussion from p6 - 7

it's not that hidden? you saw it on the bot

Not particularly keen on debating this point, seems like a derail.

##GM CALL ruling please.

##GM Note: I didn't quite understand the this when I read it. All players should ensure all text is readable within the game thread. Keep the sizes legible, people.

[Vecna]

WHERE ARE YOU HIDING JAMIE?!?!?!

WHO IS THIS IMPOSTER?!?!?!

Worcej already feeling pretty scummy with just his few initial posting.

What gave you that vibe?

Historically I haven't been great at reading worcej, but he's struck me as jovial so far, not something that I find sus at this stage.

He just feels like he's actively attempting to play in a way that he thinks we expect of him.

Jovial really isnt town indicative for Worcej. Its his content and thoughts. Early and day1 n all, so its not a strong read, but definately a good first impression that leaves me suspicious.

[snowy801]

When did Ghug become such a thin skinned crybaby?

You quit the last game and the council because you were a thin-skinned crybaby, made a big show of promising to be better, and then came in insulting someone. The fact that that someone is me is only slightly relevant.

Can I be honest that you both seem to be over-reacting and I am leaning more towards theater than actual honest intent?

I half agree, because I do think Jamiet is being disingenuous here (and one of my lower scum reads). But ghug's reaction is exactly what I was thinking so it was either organic or very well mirrored.

[Vecna]

Worcej already feeling pretty scummy with just his few initial posting.

Possible, and Jamie could be his teammate.

I think worcej and Jamie are my top scum suspects after snowy.

Do you think that Worcej and Jamie are scum together or that you think that they are both independently scummy? The former seems weak at best given how little interaction they've had.

Do you have reasons to suspect snowy besides his early posting?

Celaph quite a bit more active early on than im used to. Nothing that gives me a foul smell though, quite logical and investigative mindset.

Slightly good initial feelings.

[snowy801]

Vecna, what about Bona says scum to you, if I understood you right?

It seems you're drawing from experience here, in which case, what experience and what does that say about Bona here now?

[worcej]

I changed my mind, I think it would be advantageous for town to mass claim items, because I think we would have a high probability of catching the 3P before he gets his required items. However, I am confident that it would be impossible to get a consensus on this.

Ah. Here it is.

##vote bozo

[Vecna]

If I had to vote right now I would vote Snowy, but with 8 players in the single digit posts I'll hold off and wait for more content.

So far I like Bob a lot and Vecna a fair amount. Bozo, Macca, and food all get mild endorsements. Null on all the rest.

Why mild endorsements on Macca and Food?

[damo666]

Post requirement fulfilled.

Where is rdr?

Why is nobody else voting Bona?

How do you pronounce ghug and lfischl and xorxes?

[damo666]

I changed my mind, I think it would be advantageous for town to mass claim items, because I think we would have a high probability of catching the 3P before he gets his required items. However, I am confident that it would be impossible to get a consensus on this.

Ah. Here it is.

##vote bozo

scummy

[worcej]

That wasn't the only running I did!


Ba dum dum!

Poop jokes - You go from to

[Vecna]

Vecna, what about Bona says scum to you, if I understood you right?

It seems you're drawing from experience here, in which case, what experience and what does that say about Bona here now?

Still catching up, but just responding to this quickly in between.

A jovial not so serious Bona gives me flashbacks to his scumgame. Im not entirely sure if my meta-analysis is accurate here, but he usually is a bit more matter of factly with his opinion.

The way he defended Worcej there also seemed -very- uncharacteristic to me. There is no way I believe he couldve had good reasons to pick out that one read of the sea of reads out there to comment on, and to disagree with that strongly.

Im suspecting either a team relation, or a serious white knighting/TMI type of thing going on there.

[Chaqa]

Mafia 69 Day 1 Vote Count 2: In Between Meetings Edition

snowy801 (4): bozotheclown, lfischl, Macca573, BobMcBob
ghug (3): Bonatogether, Maniac, Jamiet99uk
Maniac (2): Kakarroto, foodcoats
Vecna (1): snowy801
Jamiet99uk (1): ghug
worcej (1): Vecna
Bonatogether (1): damo666
bozotheclown (1): worcej

The following players must cast a vote: celaph, Hamilton Brian, rdrivera2005

The following players have not met the minimum vote count: lfischl, Maniac, rdrivera2005

[snowy801]

Post requirement fulfilled.

Where is rdr?

Why is nobody else voting Bona?

How do you pronounce ghug and lfischl and xorxes?

Why did you say "Post requirement fulfilled."? Briefly walk me through your thoughts.

Bona is my strongest town read. I've come to discover that rdrivera comes and goes as he pleases.

[Vecna]

Oof, at least I've read up to here now, who makes 24 hour starting days? Can't make even a good joke phase with work and stuff happening.

Anyway, I clearly don't want to leave with my introduction joke vote (well at least halfly, ghug might be still e~vi~l but I don't see anything out of the ordinary), I like the posts of bozo and bob; celaph and bona look good too. Maybe Vecna is up there too ... not too sure about that though.

Jamie is ... hmm ... there's something rubbing me the wrong way, but there was the thing where I misread jamie on early days when he was pr, so I'll come back later. I'm also getting something from maniac, his comment about my post (at least I think that was it? prove me wrong if I am) I didn't like, he should be better than this.

##vote maniac

and I have to go or I'm late to work

I think youre just jealous I didnt give you any attention yet

[Chaqa]

##GM Note:

I would just like to give a gentle reminder to the game that this setup is complex. Please read through all of your item information, role information, game information, etc. so that you don't miss out on any options or actions.

I'm planning to put together a document later today with all of the GM calls and answers clarifications and add it to the top of the Items sheet for easy access.