M68: Guns N' Roses GAMETHREAD [hidden]

[damo666]

If I ignore the fact that scum {Chaqa, JBH, x} is gonna say this who do you have in mind to kill then?

This post implies Chaqa is scum, now he's on your Do Not Vote list, like 3 posts later.

I read that post as "Ignoring the fact that IF these two are scum..."

Yes.

[ghug]

Ghug's gun claim

Possibilities

1. He is lying and has a rose and is

a) scum - so unlikely can be ignored

b) town - very possible

2. He has a gun and is

a) scum who has already shot - possible but why claim
b) scum with n3 gun - again why claim?
c) town who has already shot - then why not tell us? Can be ignored.
d) town with n3 gun - let's hope, please shoot a survivor from HB, worcej, rdr

If ghug is town there is a good chance he will draw a kill (due to possibilty of 2d) thus giving at least 2 of town Jamie town Chaqa and town JBH survival.

Hopefully scum NK ghug and he has a N2 rose.

Anyway for today at least ghug is off the table.

You know I claimed rose EoN1, right?

[ghug]

Ghug's gun claim

Possibilities

1. He is lying and has a rose and is

a) scum - so unlikely can be ignored

b) town - very possible

2. He has a gun and is

a) scum who has already shot - possible but why claim
b) scum with n3 gun - again why claim?
c) town who has already shot - then why not tell us? Can be ignored.
d) town with n3 gun - let's hope, please shoot a survivor from HB, worcej, rdr

If ghug is town there is a good chance he will draw a kill (due to possibilty of 2d) thus giving at least 2 of town Jamie town Chaqa and town JBH survival.

Hopefully scum NK ghug and he has a N2* rose.

Anyway for today at least ghug is off the table.

Ghug claimed a rose EON1.

OK thanks. If we take that as the truth he doesn't have a n2 rose. Anyway I don't think he's a sensible kill today.

* N3 obviously.

I didn't claim which night my rose is.

[ghug]

Jamie, why did you join brainbomb in voting for me?

I figured it was a good way to start the day.

Why?

[damo666]

Ghug claimed a rose EON1.

OK thanks. If we take that as the truth he doesn't have a n2 rose. Anyway I don't think he's a sensible kill today.

* N3 obviously.

I didn't claim which night my rose is.

I meant you don't have a n1 rose and that I hope you have a n3 rose.

You saying 'If I am killed tonight know I had a rose' [paraphrasing] implies you don't have a n1 rose. Correct?

[ghug]

Having banged on about JBH being a safe kill his impassioned (though somewhat naive) post sound very town. I am tempted to gamble 'all in' on JBH being town.

In this case who to vote for? I think it has to be from {HB, worcej, rdr}. Thoughts people on kill Johnny v assume Johnny town and if the latter who to kill?

I appeal for a Bozo type survey on the above.

I think it's worth the gamble, especially since we can remove Jamie and Chaqa from consideration for the day, as Johnny's only at risk of winning as scum if they're both town.

[Jamiet99uk]

Jamie, why did you join brainbomb in voting for me?

I figured it was a good way to start the day.

Why?

Either:

A: You are in my scum pool and I wanted to see what would happen.

Or

B: I'm scum and I need you out of the way.

Or

C: We're both scum and I'm bussing you, babes.

I wonder which it could be?

[ghug]

OK thanks. If we take that as the truth he doesn't have a n2 rose. Anyway I don't think he's a sensible kill today.

* N3 obviously.

I didn't claim which night my rose is.

I meant you don't have a n1 rose and that I hope you have a n3 rose.

You saying 'If I am killed tonight know I had a rose' [paraphrasing] implies you don't have a n1 rose. Correct?

Correct.

[ghug]

I figured it was a good way to start the day.

Why?

Either:

A: You are in my scum pool and I wanted to see what would happen.

Or

B: I'm scum and I need you out of the way.

Or

C: We're both scum and I'm bussing you, babes.

I wonder which it could be?

I'm asking why you scumread me.

[Jamiet99uk]

Why?

Either:

A: You are in my scum pool and I wanted to see what would happen.

Or

B: I'm scum and I need you out of the way.

Or

C: We're both scum and I'm bussing you, babes.

I wonder which it could be?

I'm asking why you scumread me.

Fingers on buzzers:

What was the surname of Edgar Allan, the writer of "The Raven" and other tales of mystery?

**bzzzz**

Yes, Ghug?

[ghug]

Either:

A: You are in my scum pool and I wanted to see what would happen.

Or

B: I'm scum and I need you out of the way.

Or

C: We're both scum and I'm bussing you, babes.

I wonder which it could be?

I'm asking why you scumread me.

Fingers on buzzers:

What was the surname of Edgar Allan, the writer of "The Raven" and other tales of mystery?

**bzzzz**

Yes, Ghug?

Uhh, Baltimore Maryland?

Wait shit

[Jamiet99uk]

@Ghug - lol

But seriously it's simply a process of elimination. I find you hard to read because you have the same attitude as all four alignments, but POE says you're very much in the pool.

I still favour a J.B. Horse elim today though.

[ghug]

@Ghug - lol

But seriously it's simply a process of elimination. I find you hard to read because you have the same attitude as all four alignments, but POE says you're very much in the pool.

I still favour a J.B. Horse elim today though.

S'pose I can't complain about being scumread because I'm so awesome.

[Jamiet99uk]

@Ghug - It's because you're so awesome.

I still favour a J.B. Horse elim today though.

S'pose I can't complain about being scumread because I'm so awesome.

What do you think about J Big Horse, and about Damo's flippety floppery?

[ghug]

@Ghug - It's because you're so awesome.

I still favour a J.B. Horse elim today though.

S'pose I can't complain about being scumread because I'm so awesome.

What do you think about J Big Horse, and about Damo's flippety floppery?

I've townread Bojack for much of the game, and his behavior today hasn't done anything to change that. I can see the argument that it's weird for mafia to shoot him, but it's equally weird to choose to lie about being shot. I can see the argument that killing him is the only way to absolutely ensure the game doesn't end tonight, but we're also pretty likely to lose if we miskill him and go into KILO needing three successful kills, so I'd rather just trust my townread and take that gamble now.

Damo's flip flipping around the situation strikes me as a townie struggling to make sense of the situation.

[ghug]

The fact that damo didn't know I'd claimed a rose also suggests to me he's town. I don't think that gets ignored in the QT.

I think where I'm at is the team is Brian, Rivera, worcej, and that's it.

If I'm wrong, Chaqa's maybe the most likely slipping through of the others, and his quick shooting down of my rd was shot claim could have been protecting celaph from it, which would make the team something like Chaqa, celaph, Brian/worcej (celaph would know rd's deal if they were teammates).

[rdrivera2005]

Having banged on about JBH being a safe kill his impassioned (though somewhat naive) post sound very town. I am tempted to gamble 'all in' on JBH being town.

In this case who to vote for? I think it has to be from {HB, worcej, rdr}. Thoughts people on kill Johnny v assume Johnny town and if the latter who to kill?

I appeal for a Bozo type survey on the above.

I think at this point, we are in such a bad position that a vote to avoid losing or a policy vote aren't a good call. Vote JBH if you think he is scum, otherwise vote someone else.

Right now I will ##vote HB

[ghug]

Having banged on about JBH being a safe kill his impassioned (though somewhat naive) post sound very town. I am tempted to gamble 'all in' on JBH being town.

In this case who to vote for? I think it has to be from {HB, worcej, rdr}. Thoughts people on kill Johnny v assume Johnny town and if the latter who to kill?

I appeal for a Bozo type survey on the above.

I think at this point, we are in such a bad position that a vote to avoid losing or a policy vote aren't a good call. Vote JBH if you think he is scum, otherwise vote someone else.

Right now I will ##vote HB

Why HB? What are your other reads?

[Jamiet99uk]

I notice that EMC has gone back to lurking.

[Jamiet99uk]

Having banged on about JBH being a safe kill his impassioned (though somewhat naive) post sound very town. I am tempted to gamble 'all in' on JBH being town.

In this case who to vote for? I think it has to be from {HB, worcej, rdr}. Thoughts people on kill Johnny v assume Johnny town and if the latter who to kill?

I appeal for a Bozo type survey on the above.

I think at this point, we are in such a bad position that a vote to avoid losing or a policy vote aren't a good call. Vote JBH if you think he is scum, otherwise vote someone else.

Right now I will ##vote HB

Why HB? What are your other reads?

You just said you scumread HB, so why are you pushing back on someone voting him?