M68: Guns N' Roses GAMETHREAD [hidden]

[Johnny Big Horse]

but Jamie is still here? They took a chance on Eden and didn't take the clear shot at Jamie?

I always thought Eden was town.

Probably speaking too soon, but maybe my farfetched idea was right. Jamiet, Chaca and Riviera.

[e.m.c^42]

Rip Eden 'n snowy, but bit surprised Jamie lived, yeah.

[brainbomb]

##vote ghug

[Johnny Big Horse]

wow, and someone shot at me too. I had a N2 rose.

Ok, geniuses what does that mean? Who would shoot at me? Or why?

I was obviously town. You all have admitted it.

So, I assume it would be mafia that shot me, since all of you townies profess there are more suspicious people than me. So, if they shot Eden and Me, could that mean we are on to something? I mean, could it mean that whatever Eden and I agreed on, could be almost true?

I would think if I was the village idiot, which I have assumed I was, the mafia would keep me around as long as possible because I can only confuse you all with rubbish theories.

[Johnny Big Horse]

also what does it mean that there were 3 shots.

Does each mafioso get one shot a night? I thought the mafia group, as a whole, got just one shot a night.

If it is the second, they get one shot collectively, it means that two of us townies shot Snowball, Eden or me.

Hopefully someone will explain it.

[Johnny Big Horse]

##Vote Chaca

[e.m.c^42]

also what does it mean that there were 3 shots.

Does each mafioso get one shot a night? I thought the mafia group, as a whole, got just one shot a night.

If it is the second, they get one shot collectively, it means that two of us townies shot Snowball, Eden or me.

Hopefully someone will explain it.

Since no one claimed anything it's probably NK and two scum guns then, which is good since that only leaves one at most?

[Jamiet99uk]

Yikes.

RIP Eden, RIP Snowy.

[rdrivera2005]

also what does it mean that there were 3 shots.

Does each mafioso get one shot a night? I thought the mafia group, as a whole, got just one shot a night.

If it is the second, they get one shot collectively, it means that two of us townies shot Snowball, Eden or me.

Hopefully someone will explain it.

Each scum can choose a gun or a rose. The NK is a group choice and count as a shot.

If you are telling the truth scum used two guns last night (and the NK).
In fact, this is good news as they have max one remaining gun (0 if Chaqa is scum).
But would they be so obvious to shoot both you and Eden if Chaqa is scum? Anyway, Chaqa isn't a great choice for today as after next night we can be sure about how many scum guns are around.

[rdrivera2005]

Yikes.

RIP Eden, RIP Snowy.

Why are you alive?

[Johnny Big Horse]

also what does it mean that there were 3 shots.

Does each mafioso get one shot a night? I thought the mafia group, as a whole, got just one shot a night.

If it is the second, they get one shot collectively, it means that two of us townies shot Snowball, Eden or me.

Hopefully someone will explain it.

Each scum can choose a gun or a rose. The NK is a group choice and count as a shot.

If you are telling the truth scum used two guns last night (and the NK).
In fact, this is good news as they have max one remaining gun (0 if Chaqa is scum).
But would they be so obvious to shoot both you and Eden if Chaqa is scum? Anyway, Chaqa isn't a great choice for today as after next night we can be sure about how many scum guns are around.

Not sure it would be obvious. Nobody believes the idea that Chaqa is scum. Only me and eden did. And you were the leading dismisser of this stupid idea which may be right.

BB believed for about 5 minutes, I think, but maybe not. I don't understand him. He seems to move from theory to theory, or maybe he just posts things he does not believe. I don't know.

[Jamiet99uk]

Yikes.

RIP Eden, RIP Snowy.

Why are you alive?

Because nobody attempted to kill me last night.

I assume they think I am way off the scent, and thus prioritised Snowy over me in terms of people who were nearly clear - and that President Eden was a fearkill.

[damo666]

JBH could be scum falsely claiming a shot.

[brainbomb]

rivera is suddenly looking very towny.
Okay rd

im town too

what shall we do today. im all in with you. And you are absolutely right about chaqa also probably being town unless and extra shot goes off tomorrow

[damo666]

Three reasons Eden could have been shot rather than Jamie

I) Jamie is scum
2) Scum thought it a decent enough gamble to kill PE with the side effect of throwing shade on Jamie
3) A townie shot PE

I assign rough probabilities as follows:

1) 30
2 ) 67
3) 3

[Jamiet99uk]

I am town.
I continue to assume Chaqa is town.
I think that Brainbomb is town.

That leaves 3 scum in this pool:

1. Damo666
2. ghug
4. Worcej
9. Rdrivera2005
10. Hamilton Brian
12. EMC
14. Johnny Big Horse

[Jamiet99uk]

Three reasons Eden could have been shot rather than Jamie

I) Jamie is scum
2) Scum thought it a decent enough gamble to kill PE with the side effect of throwing shade on Jamie
3) A townie shot PE

If it is this reason, then I really think that person should claim, now.

[Jamiet99uk]

It's a small detail but if JBH's claim to have been shot at, and saved by his vest, is true, then it's mathematically impossible for me and JBH to be scum together. We could be town together, and indeed that now seems relatively likely to me.

Unless any townies are holding un-declared guns, I think we can be pretty certain that we are down to just one death per night, for the remainder of the game (not that it will go much longer if we can't find scum today).

[brainbomb]

im operating under the assumption that eden was right about ghug early and was killed by ghug

[Jamiet99uk]

im operating under the assumption that eden was right about ghug early and was killed by ghug

Ok.

##Vote Ghug