M68: Guns N' Roses GAMETHREAD [hidden]

[brainbomb]

optimal town play was to take a rose the only reason anyone wouldve taken a gun as town was to give town a 1 shot vig

were all on the same page on that right?

On the face of that statement, sounds ok to me, but I need more info from the setup.

What info you want to get from the setup? What's the use of a gun to town other then randomly shooting someone? Scum probably have 3 guns. Assuming worst scenario where they all kill a target, it will be down to 8 -3, which means only two miskills for town. A wrong town shot that kill another town just count as a misskill too, so why a non megalomaniac town would want to play vig and choose a gun?

rivera what did you think of this post by hamilton?

[brainbomb]

D1ing Chaqa would actually be pretty funny since this is ostensibly his last game on WebDip Mafia because he’s been D1d too many times.

Egregious trolling.

##Vote Foodcoats

it actually isnt egregious at all. Its ironic but hardly rude or trolling. This is not a reason to vote food here

[Chaqa]

But yeah I endorse shooting Macca here. I'll be shooting Eden if I have an N1 gun.

Oh, I'll change mine then so we don't double tap.

[brainbomb]

Yeah, I am not sure how mafia with a rose is bad for town. Unless I am misreading or misunderstanding, the rose just protects from a vigshot on that particular day.

Hamilton has way more posts about setup and best play than usual. and alot less posts about views of rolling gamestate

[President Eden]

I think Eden; regardless of alignment would say he desired a bb flip more than ghug or foodcoats. And if he survives the night it would be relatively achievable to flip me.

doing this day 2 is probably optimal whether I will go quietly is the question. Perhaps another reads list will save me again.

For most of the day yes, and for the entire time I would desire your flip above foodcoats, but I am pretty locked in on ghug being mafia and truly did prefer to get him over either by EOD. I couldn't marshal the votes by the time it became apparent to me that he, not you, needed to be the flip.

[dargorygel]

##GM NOTE
The bot repairs are going to take longer than initially forecast. You might have to run part of Day 2 botless. (Which word looks a lot like 'bottles,' which would be ANOTHER way to play part of Day 2...)

Yellow Legal Pads and pens on the way to those who asked for them.

Hourly manual vote counts, please.

##VOTE COUNT
it is night. There are no votes.

[President Eden]

bb, ghug, and Chaqa are all good guys, but only bb is a good guy in this game.

[brainbomb]

I'm worried that all this attention to the pre-game talk has clouded the game.

I don't think anyone would be justifed in claiming an item, although there have been some claims. Why? If it's a clever "fool mafia" ruse, then awesome.

Really interesting to say since 99% of your posts are talking about the setup, the items (Not who is scum).

scale of 1-10 (10 being VERY ALARMED), how concerned are you that the game was lacking substance day 1?

[brainbomb]

So anyone NOT using a placeholder vote want to explain, or are they all temporary?

Snowy, what do you dislike about foodcoats?

Who WAS using a placeholder vote at the time you wrote this? and why do you identify certain votes as placeholders in this moment?

[brainbomb]

Hamilton is scum

[Chaqa]

bb, ghug, and Chaqa are all good guys, but only bb is a good guy in this game.

Weren't you certain BB was scum like, less than 24 hours ago? What changed?

[brainbomb]

Hamilton scum
emc scum

——

and then perhaps by end of night I can reread rivera, macca, and worcej. Final scum is likely in that group.

——
town
——
ghug
chaqa
damo
johnny
jamie


Eden is quite vocal and still is not free from the shackles of possibly being scums powerwolf. he was saved day 1 but used a number of audience appeals to generate counterwagons which he doesnt need to do with two townies late up for elim. he seems to genuinely be hungry to get the ghuggle, even if it costs him his own life.

rivera fades from my list until I see how he plays tomorrow

[brainbomb]

im just gonna say its worcej before even rereading

emc
hamilton
worcej

[snowy801]

What about damo says town to you?

[Hamilton Brian]

Wrote a lovely post that got evaporated by serverensuction.

The gist:

I am uncomfortable with:
a) the amount of oxygen people dedicated to your pre-game claim but then also your not effectively shutting it down.
b) the amount of energy PE spent trying energize your DK ONLY to flip to ghug on the basis of your reads list which they found convincing.

[Hamilton Brian]

And the D1 vote was either TvT or TvS. And I am leaning more toward it was T v S with Eden playing a candid role in shifting votes off of you.

Are you scum? Possibly?
If you are, is Eden? Hmm...
And if Eden is, does that make snowy who followed PE to ghug?

[Hamilton Brian]

But then looking that the voting list that snowy posted, that's not going to fly.

@PE, without benefit of the bot, why'd you jump to ghug then return to brain?

[Vecna]

The speakers turn on again.

"Be prepared detectives. My favorite psychopaths have instructions to unleash murder upon you all...very soon. Will you defend yourself with brute force and be faster on the trigger?

Oh the excitement!"



##GM Note:
4 Hours remaining in N1

[ghug]

And the D1 vote was either TvT or TvS. And I am leaning more toward it was T v S with Eden playing a candid role in shifting votes off of you.

Are you scum? Possibly?
If you are, is Eden? Hmm...
And if Eden is, does that make snowy who followed PE to ghug?

Yeah, it's not gonna be that easy.

[Hamilton Brian]

And the D1 vote was either TvT or TvS. And I am leaning more toward it was T v S with Eden playing a candid role in shifting votes off of you.

Are you scum? Possibly?
If you are, is Eden? Hmm...
And if Eden is, does that make snowy who followed PE to ghug?

Yeah, it's not gonna be that easy.

Not that easy why?
Are you convinced those two top wagons were T v T?