M68: Guns N' Roses GAMETHREAD [hidden]

[ghug]

I guess I didn't actually get to the point there.

Obviously all of that can be true of someone who is still mafia, but those types of wagons tend to be town wagons. Hence why it suggests he's town to me.

Take it a step further and tell me who the scum were that chose to wagon him.

[snowy801]

I suppose I ought to go about doing other things during this down time

Look forward to hearing from you emc, I trust you'll have lots of thoughts to digest for us

[President Eden]

I guess I didn't actually get to the point there.

Obviously all of that can be true of someone who is still mafia, but those types of wagons tend to be town wagons. Hence why it suggests he's town to me.

Take it a step further and tell me who the scum were that chose to wagon him.

I gave you three names already you're such a goofball

[ghug]

I guess I didn't actually get to the point there.

Obviously all of that can be true of someone who is still mafia, but those types of wagons tend to be town wagons. Hence why it suggests he's town to me.

Take it a step further and tell me who the scum were that chose to wagon him.

I gave you three names already you're such a goofball

Chaqa didn't vote him at the end out of nowhere, brain and I didn't vote him at all. Jamie did, but you can't have four scum.

[Jamiet99uk]

Take it a step further and tell me who the scum were that chose to wagon him.

I gave you three names already you're such a goofball

Chaqa didn't vote him at the end out of nowhere, brain and I didn't vote him at all. Jamie did, but you can't have four scum.

And i'm not scum.

[Johnny Big Horse]

Someone (from town) please shoot BB. We would be on page 20 now, rather than 40, if he wasn't here. His stuff is way too tedious. He adds so much complexity. Even if he is a towny, we will have a much better chance of understanding what is going on if he wasn't here, or if he were mostly silent, but I don't think that is in his nature. Even if he is a towny, he hurts the town.

[damo666]

JBH learns fast.

[Hamilton Brian]

So yeah, go read the setup. But do mafia, assuming all 3 have guns, get …no, kind of answered my own question. Guns for different nights. But if they all chose 3 N1 guns, there could be 4 deaths tonight, right, assuming roses not in use N1?

[President Eden]

Take it a step further and tell me who the scum were that chose to wagon him.

I gave you three names already you're such a goofball

Chaqa didn't vote him at the end out of nowhere, brain and I didn't vote him at all. Jamie did, but you can't have four scum.

Chaqa was shading him all day and generally down for it, Jamie voted him, you agreed with Jamie's vote but didn't vote him yourself. My argument doesn't depend on all of you actually voting him, just that you were all interested, none of you had compelling reasons, and the push materialized largely out of the blue. That all suggests town wagon.

And while this is a bit circular for my liking, it doesn't help me personally that I already suspected literally everyone who voted emc at any point on day 1 except snowy (townread) and worcej (null, could easily be mafia, just don't feel as strongly). I think I have independent reasons to be concerned about the emc push and to think it suggests he's town, but for full disclosure I am somewhat reading him off association.

[President Eden]

So yeah, go read the setup. But do mafia, assuming all 3 have guns, get …no, kind of answered my own question. Guns for different nights. But if they all chose 3 N1 guns, there could be 4 deaths tonight, right, assuming roses not in use N1?

In theory, if all three mafia took guns and shot people without n1 roses, then yes, there could be 4 mafia kills tonight.

[TheMadMonarch]

So, Food eh? I don't really see why, but maybe something will have happened closer to EOD. I will keep reading.

[ghug]

So, Food eh? I don't really see why, but maybe something will have happened closer to EOD. I will keep reading.

Macca's scum.

[ghug]

I gave you three names already you're such a goofball

Chaqa didn't vote him at the end out of nowhere, brain and I didn't vote him at all. Jamie did, but you can't have four scum.

Chaqa was shading him all day and generally down for it, Jamie voted him, you agreed with Jamie's vote but didn't vote him yourself. My argument doesn't depend on all of you actually voting him, just that you were all interested, none of you had compelling reasons, and the push materialized largely out of the blue. That all suggests town wagon.

And while this is a bit circular for my liking, it doesn't help me personally that I already suspected literally everyone who voted emc at any point on day 1 except snowy (townread) and worcej (null, could easily be mafia, just don't feel as strongly). I think I have independent reasons to be concerned about the emc push and to think it suggests he's town, but for full disclosure I am somewhat reading him off association.

So I agree that Jamie's vote was weird (hence my calling it out as noteworthy and not joining him), but not Chaqa's, and it feels like a stretch to conclude he's town just because you have some suspicion of the people who voted for him.

What I keep noticing from you is an astonishingly poor ability to think about how scum would think:
We know town mostly picked roses? Scum must be all the people who told us they didn't!
My view of the game is that potentially scum brainbomb and two townies were up for the kill? Scum must have concocted a fourth wagon with shoddy reasoning rather than jumping on either of the town counters!

Does this actually feel like a bona fide effort to look for hiding scum?

[President Eden]

I know the guy who killed a townie for posting reads lists isn't talking shit about my hunting this game

zzz

[TheMadMonarch]

So, Food eh? I don't really see why, but maybe something will have happened closer to EOD. I will keep reading.

Macca's scum.

Incorrect.

[brainbomb]

Someone (from town) please shoot BB. We would be on page 20 now, rather than 40, if he wasn't here. His stuff is way too tedious. He adds so much complexity. Even if he is a towny, we will have a much better chance of understanding what is going on if he wasn't here, or if he were mostly silent, but I don't think that is in his nature. Even if he is a towny, he hurts the town.

Wouldnt it be even better if someone (from mafia) were to shoot me? Or was that not even a possibility in your mind?

Seems like a town bullet being used on me would only be a good shot if you felt I was the only elim option tomorrow. Im sure some do feel that way.

do you feel that if I were town; that it would be better for town to kill me than for scum to kill me?

[Johnny Big Horse]

BB, I think it is in the mafia's favor if you remain. You are a great ally for them if you are a townie. So, no, they should not kill you. They should kill someone else.

[Johnny Big Horse]

BB. Sorry, I suck at answering questions. Yes, I think the town should kill you even if you are one of us.

[TheMadMonarch]

BB. Sorry, I suck at answering questions. Yes, I think the town should kill you even if you are one of us.

Hard disagree here. BB can be quite useful, wait till he clocks the whole team.

Unless he's a scumbo, that's the only reason you should vote someone.

[brainbomb]

Mafia should not waste a kill on me

got it