M68: Guns N' Roses GAMETHREAD [hidden]

[brainbomb]

were into the point of the game where people generate lists of where they view every player in the game with zero explanation as to why.

gonna say at least 3 of the ppl who posted forced reads lists are scum here

At least 3?

How many scum do you think are in the game?

I was unable to find in the game thread where it announced how many scum there were. I have reviewed and see there are 3 which seems low. But I suppose that is standard for a game size of 11-14?

[brainbomb]

if its 3 scum then its probably food, eden and emc/macca

[brainbomb]

The act of calling town Bitchmade for mass selecting roses also seems totally disjointed. I don't see how town is bitchmade for playing best play, or why this would be hilarious. So far I haven't been able to find a post by Eden where I see a town thought process.

could you be more obviously butthurt caught mafia

Right, because I would be able to produce game related reads with actual reasoning while being emotionally tilted.

[Jamiet99uk]

were into the point of the game where people generate lists of where they view every player in the game with zero explanation as to why.

gonna say at least 3 of the ppl who posted forced reads lists are scum here

At least 3?

How many scum do you think are in the game?

I was unable to find in the game thread where it announced how many scum there were. I have reviewed and see there are 3 which seems low. But I suppose that is standard for a game size of 11-14?

It's in the first line of the opening post from Vecna:

Mafia 68: Guns N’ Roses
SETUP
• The finalized setup is 11 town players vs 3 mafia players

You usually pay attention to details like that.

Are you attempting to dumb-tell, to pretend you don't know how many people are on the Mafia team so you couldn't possibly be a member of that particular team.....?

[President Eden]

The act of calling town Bitchmade for mass selecting roses also seems totally disjointed. I don't see how town is bitchmade for playing best play, or why this would be hilarious. So far I haven't been able to find a post by Eden where I see a town thought process.

could you be more obviously butthurt caught mafia

Right, because I would be able to produce game related reads with actual reasoning while being emotionally tilted.

Your entire read is OMGUS with a bunch of unimpressive fluff

[Johnny Big Horse]

Brainbomb, you can post thoughtful and perhaps helpful posts, and sometimes you post noise... maybe more often noise. I think that is the best way to play mafia. Give lots of good sound reasoning, and then lead the dupes astray.

You have convinced me that Eden is one of the town's enemies.

But there are two more, and look, I am not as clever as you legacy players, but it seems to me, we should be looking at Brainbomb (because he mixes too much noise with good reasoning), ghug (for soliciting my opinion which nobody should do) and one more, I forget who.

##Vote President Eden

[worcej]

As for why Eden is scum, I think in every single version of my view of gamestate I end up with Eden as scum with foodcoats.

Eden seems like scum because I feel like the only reasoning he has produced so far on how to scum hunt has been to start by paint by numbers. His immediate item claim and activation time seems really weird. The act of calling town Bitchmade for mass selecting roses also seems totally disjointed. I don't see how town is bitchmade for playing best play, or why this would be hilarious. So far I haven't been able to find a post by Eden where I see a town thought process.

Foodcoats does vote jump as town. he does throw pressure around a fair amount as town. But here it seems more like he isn't voting people who could be scum-- it seems like he is voting people he can get away with voting. The whole vote on me, the end hammer, and then asking damo to validate his reasoning. The horribly scummy forced reads list which is totally out of character for what his town game has been in recent examples. All of this leads me to conclude foodcoats is scum, wether with eden or not.

Dude, keep up this posting style. It's way easier to read when you articulate things thoroughly.

[Johnny Big Horse]

I am pretty sure Jamiet is the Mafia as well. Even I knew how many mafia there are. The people who know most are those who have already met as as a scum group to strategize before this thread was opened. Acting like you don't know...I know you are much smarter than that.

I wish I could vote to Jamiet also.

[worcej]

Brainbomb, you can post thoughtful and perhaps helpful posts, and sometimes you post noise... maybe more often noise. I think that is the best way to play mafia. Give lots of good sound reasoning, and then lead the dupes astray.

You have convinced me that Eden is one of the town's enemies.

But there are two more, and look, I am not as clever as you legacy players, but it seems to me, we should be looking at Brainbomb (because he mixes too much noise with good reasoning), ghug (for soliciting my opinion which nobody should do) and one more, I forget who.

##Vote President Eden

I disagree with your opinion on ghug. It makes the most sense to engage with a new player so that we can bring them actively into the game instead of having them sit back and be engulfed in our shitstorm of posting.

I will say your posting has gotten significantly better - your entrance was poor and I am curious, have you played any sort of mafia/werewolf before?

[President Eden]

Brainbomb, you can post thoughtful and perhaps helpful posts, and sometimes you post noise... maybe more often noise. I think that is the best way to play mafia. Give lots of good sound reasoning, and then lead the dupes astray.

You have convinced me that Eden is one of the town's enemies.

But there are two more, and look, I am not as clever as you legacy players, but it seems to me, we should be looking at Brainbomb (because he mixes too much noise with good reasoning), ghug (for soliciting my opinion which nobody should do) and one more, I forget who.

##Vote President Eden

What parts of his posts are noise and what parts are good reasoning in your view?

[ghug]

Brainbomb, you can post thoughtful and perhaps helpful posts, and sometimes you post noise... maybe more often noise. I think that is the best way to play mafia. Give lots of good sound reasoning, and then lead the dupes astray.

You have convinced me that Eden is one of the town's enemies.

But there are two more, and look, I am not as clever as you legacy players, but it seems to me, we should be looking at Brainbomb (because he mixes too much noise with good reasoning), ghug (for soliciting my opinion which nobody should do) and one more, I forget who.

##Vote President Eden

So, for the record, soliciting opinions from people who aren't talking is good for town, and I do it all the time (even when I'm scum, though then it's to appear like I'm town or to make sometime look bad).

[worcej]

##VOTE worcej

Gotta stick with my top townread.

Wait, did I miss when Chaqa became your top town read?

[President Eden]

I am going to revisit an interaction at EON1 that I can't discuss right now.

[damo666]

At least 3?

How many scum do you think are in the game?

I was unable to find in the game thread where it announced how many scum there were. I have reviewed and see there are 3 which seems low. But I suppose that is standard for a game size of 11-14?

It's in the first line of the opening post from Vecna:

Mafia 68: Guns N’ Roses
SETUP
• The finalized setup is 11 town players vs 3 mafia players

You usually pay attention to details like that.

Are you attempting to dumb-tell, to pretend you don't know how many people are on the Mafia team so you couldn't possibly be a member of that particular team.....?

At first I thought brain was joking. Now I'm not so sure.

[Jamiet99uk]

I am pretty sure Jamiet is the Mafia as well. Even I knew how many mafia there are. The people who know most are those who have already met as as a scum group to strategize before this thread was opened. Acting like you don't know...I know you are much smarter than that.

I wish I could vote to Jamiet also.

I have always known perfectly well how many Mafia there are. Three is the Mafia number.

Where did I suggest I was uncertain about this information?

When did I act as if I didn't know?

Please provide evidence for this claim. I purport that you are incorrect.

[Jamiet99uk]

##VOTE EMC

Policy vote.

His lack of participation has now reached the point that it's inexcusable.
He needs to show up and take part.
Plus, his initial posts were very bad.

[TheMadMonarch]

Not read all, but I see food has picked up. Interesting.

[Johnny Big Horse]

Brainbomb, you can post thoughtful and perhaps helpful posts, and sometimes you post noise... maybe more often noise. I think that is the best way to play mafia. Give lots of good sound reasoning, and then lead the dupes astray.

You have convinced me that Eden is one of the town's enemies.

But there are two more, and look, I am not as clever as you legacy players, but it seems to me, we should be looking at Brainbomb (because he mixes too much noise with good reasoning), ghug (for soliciting my opinion which nobody should do) and one more, I forget who.

##Vote President Eden

What parts of his posts are noise and what parts are good reasoning in your view?

uh, all of yesterday was noise. BB seems to have calmed down quite a bit and become thoughtful.

[Johnny Big Horse]

Brainbomb, you can post thoughtful and perhaps helpful posts, and sometimes you post noise... maybe more often noise. I think that is the best way to play mafia. Give lots of good sound reasoning, and then lead the dupes astray.

You have convinced me that Eden is one of the town's enemies.

But there are two more, and look, I am not as clever as you legacy players, but it seems to me, we should be looking at Brainbomb (because he mixes too much noise with good reasoning), ghug (for soliciting my opinion which nobody should do) and one more, I forget who.

##Vote President Eden

I disagree with your opinion on ghug. It makes the most sense to engage with a new player so that we can bring them actively into the game instead of having them sit back and be engulfed in our shitstorm of posting.

I will say your posting has gotten significantly better - your entrance was poor and I am curious, have you played any sort of mafia/werewolf before?

I have never played mafia before. It looked like from from afar, but all of this nastiness, especially yesterday... I might as well read the news.

But I have played Avalon in person several times, and my line of thinking comes straight from that.

[Johnny Big Horse]

I am pretty sure Jamiet is the Mafia as well. Even I knew how many mafia there are. The people who know most are those who have already met as as a scum group to strategize before this thread was opened. Acting like you don't know...I know you are much smarter than that.

I wish I could vote to Jamiet also.

I have always known perfectly well how many Mafia there are. Three is the Mafia number.

Where did I suggest I was uncertain about this information?

When did I act as if I didn't know?

Please provide evidence for this claim. I purport that you are incorrect.

Sorry Jamiet, you are right. I misread this. I apologize for mischaracterizing you. I don't want to vote for you anymore.