M68: Guns N' Roses GAMETHREAD [hidden]

[ghug]

describe my play so far
compare it to my scum meta
talk about how im scum for playing too agitated
talk about how im overreacting to early pressures
talk about how i typically behave when im a runaway wagon as scum
talk about how there are no prs so all are expendable
talk about how I might have lied in pregame
talk about how you feel about me lying in pregame
talk about how turning mafia into a math problem never works
talk about why turning this mafia game into a math problem will work

These are the primary reasons I'm voting for you.

[President Eden]

wouldnt that just allow a false narrative to fester and gain even more traction? How can I dispel a false narrative by walking away and letting it get even worse?

Do you think you're making traction with the way you're handling the situation now? Inertia is a real problem in these situations, but you especially know that this group can be fickle when the rubber hits the road at EOD. I would bet that if you're hunting for most of the day that some people besides just me will be interested in taking out a different, lower-effort gunner.

describe my play so far
compare it to my scum meta
talk about how im scum for playing too agitated
talk about how im overreacting to early pressures
talk about how i typically behave when im a runaway wagon as scum
talk about how there are no prs so all are expendable
talk about how I might have lied in pregame
talk about how you feel about me lying in pregame
talk about how turning mafia into a math problem never works
talk about why turning this mafia game into a math problem will work

I don't think I need to do any of this, but if it helps, I am getting the vague impression that you're mafia who is mad about being "caught" on probabilistic mechanics votes rather than on actual suspicious behavior, like you got RNG'd out of the game before you got a chance to fool us.

[Jamiet99uk]

Yes.

[Jamiet99uk]

Goodnight everyone. See you in 8 hours.

[brainbomb]

wouldnt that just allow a false narrative to fester and gain even more traction? How can I dispel a false narrative by walking away and letting it get even worse?

Do you think you're making traction with the way you're handling the situation now? Inertia is a real problem in these situations, but you especially know that this group can be fickle when the rubber hits the road at EOD. I would bet that if you're hunting for most of the day that some people besides just me will be interested in taking out a different, lower-effort gunner.

describe my play so far
compare it to my scum meta
talk about how im scum for playing too agitated
talk about how im overreacting to early pressures
talk about how i typically behave when im a runaway wagon as scum
talk about how there are no prs so all are expendable
talk about how I might have lied in pregame
talk about how you feel about me lying in pregame
talk about how turning mafia into a math problem never works
talk about why turning this mafia game into a math problem will work

I don't think I need to do any of this, but if it helps, I am getting the vague impression that you're mafia who is mad about being "caught" on probabilistic mechanics votes rather than on actual suspicious behavior, like you got RNG'd out of the game before you got a chance to fool us.

Wouldnt I be even more mad about being miscaught on false probabilistic mechanics which are combined with calls to end, for me to shut up, and me to take it quietly?

[brainbomb]

doesnt make a whole lot of sense why you think my wagon will die when the reasoning behind my wagon will never stop existing on fraudulent out of game influence

[brainbomb]

the only reason im being voted other than ghug is that I said id take a gun in pregame.

[brainbomb]

the problem here is its also a gotcha narrative. If I claimed a rose right away youd also be bandwagoning me claiming I lied and that id take a rose as scum to try to avoid the mechanics.

[brainbomb]

lets operate on the logic that I am scum who got mechanically outted. By asking me questions you would look towny. youd get tells. as scum I tend to out my partners and bus, and usually throw a fit causing many people to look great for getting under my skin.

[ghug]

lets operate on the logic that I am scum who got mechanically outted. By asking me questions you would look towny. youd get tells. as scum I tend to out my partners and bus, and usually throw a fit causing many people to look great for getting under my skin.

We've clearly got you talking plenty.

[brainbomb]

assuming Jamie is town, which is possible; it would appear he finds my vote for snowy suspect and is operating under a notion that im bussing snowy. hard to know because he left the game satisfied with me as a runaway wagon only 2 hours in

[ghug]

Hi Johnny Big Horse. How are you?

[brainbomb]

lets operate on the logic that I am scum who got mechanically outted. By asking me questions you would look towny. youd get tells. as scum I tend to out my partners and bus, and usually throw a fit causing many people to look great for getting under my skin.

We've clearly got you talking plenty.

which is funny since supposedly people wanted me to stop talking

[brainbomb]

bona being quiet so far is interesting

[TheMadMonarch]

They could have, but they're not a factor in the info we have, which is that 9-11 Town-aligned players - out of a total of 11 - chose rose. Taking out pregame claimed gunners is a pretty good starting spot with that info. That's where we're at right now.

I think the choice of gun or rose is based predominantly on individual risk tolerances and predicted interactions with other players, and not per se alignment indicative, but that info is quite damning.

The info you think you have is completely useless because it is being based off of pregame chatter which isn't even part of this actual game thread. if you were to make a case and explain it to another player, you would have to link them to the pregame thread and say, look here is where brainbomb claimed something he would do regardless of alignment.

What is interesting is you didn't ask yourself if I would change my mind, if I would actually do the right thing, or if this was all meant to just get brain to claim his item immediately at game start. Either way, this was poorly considered on your part and if you really plan to exile me day one for something I didn't actually say IN THIS THREAD, then we probably should look into whether there should even be a pregame phase at all.

And for the record I will not say if I lied in pregame about my intentions. I will also not say what item I chose. This is a wonderful setup where guess what.

I
Dont
Have
Anything
Relevant
or
Interesting
To Claim

FOR ONCE

I'm the cop.

Aren't we all?

[brainbomb]

cant really distinguish between opportunistic and just moronic on my voters.

[Johnny Big Horse]

It seems to me, that either Brainbomb or Jaime, one of them, has got to be mafia, OR... maybe they just hate each other. One of these three. I guess we will find out later.

[ghug]

cant really distinguish between opportunistic and just moronic on my voters.

You listed bunch of good reasons to scumread you, so clearly you get where we're coming from.

[brainbomb]

should anyone be claiming item and night use? seems like we dont want scum to know exactly who is killable on which nights

[TheMadMonarch]

I'm certainly seeing the BB case, however:

##VOTE Jamie

Man's as scummy as a scummy thing on a scummy day wearing scummy clothes. I'd shoot him if I had a gun (I do not).