MAFIA 66: The Battle for Olympus - Game Thread [hidden]

[foodcoats]

What's your evidence that this is a scumtell?

I saw you do it in M69420.

Give evidence or your assertion is useless

I will give my evidence when you give evidence on your reads list.

[foodcoats]

I saw you do it in M69420.

Give evidence or your assertion is useless

I will give my evidence when you give evidence on your reads list.

Bona you are obviously scum. If you are town you are literally terrible at this game. You're not even trying to solve. You think the scum team is me, kgray, Chaqa, rdr and Celaph.

[foodcoats]

Also Bona,

The bigger problem for me is that I trusted you because of what I perceived to be our mutual distrust of darg. Without that, I go back to the way I was reading you before, which wasn't great, plus all the things food has dredged up.

Why would you townread me off of a shared read in the first place? That seems like a crappy reason.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=foG8zLMWJ_Y

[foodcoats]

I am not the Janitor. I was only fake-claiming that during the night because lying is fun and has no consequences at all.

My vote had nothing to do with your 'claim'.

Anyway, what do you make of my theory that you, me and rdr are good Janitor candidates? And if I am to believe you it's rdr. Quite happy to vote rdr.

I think your theory is bullshit. If I was Janitor I would have used my power at N1. And I expect you or Jamie to use it at N2. Not using it probably means that Mafia is too cautious or that Janitor is a deep threat that don't want to risk to be seen/reported/etc.

Although this is contradictory... shortly following rdr saying that the Janitor wouldn't be used while the Ninja is around, rdr says that HE, if Janitor, would fire on N1.

Hmm...

@rdr, how do you feel about these mechanics at this point? What do you think happened with the Janitor?

[Bonatogether]

Give evidence or your assertion is useless

I will give my evidence when you give evidence on your reads list.

Bona you are obviously scum. If you are town you are literally terrible at this game. You're not even trying to solve. You think the scum team is me, kgray, Chaqa, rdr and Celaph.

I said my general POE was that group.

[Bonatogether]

I saw you do it in M69420.

Give evidence or your assertion is useless

I will give my evidence when you give evidence on your reads list.

that's beside the point

[foodcoats]

Give evidence or your assertion is useless

I will give my evidence when you give evidence on your reads list.

that's beside the point

Okay, neglect that point.

Bona let’s solve together.

What do you think of damo’s roleblock claim given vecna’s reads and the lack of an item claim?

[foodcoats]

K bye

[Jamiet99uk]

Hi Foodcoats

[Chaqa]

I really don't get why you're pushing on Bona so hard.

[damo666]

celaph put Demon 4-3 in the lead, an unlikely scum move

Bona put Demon 5-4 in the lead against 3 non-Mafia with 17 minutes to go, a highly unlkely scum move

Chaqa put Demon 5-3 in the lead, although an unlikely scum move Chaqa does love a bus and his protests about day 1 bussing look suspicious

Food was the first to vote Demon but was his 5th different votee of the day so does look indecisive town.

kgray more or less puts the nail in Demon's coffin with her vote putting him 6-4 in the lead against non-Mafia with 2 minutes to go. An extremely doubtful bus.

Bussing likelihood

Chaqa >> celaph > food >> Bona >>> Kgray

So we either have

No bussers => scum team is Jamie Macca rdr yav [G4]
1 busser => Chaqa + 3 of G4 or just maybe celaph + 3 of G4
2 bussers => Chaqa celaph + I would guess Macca and Yav.

This all points to tomorrow's kill target being either Macca or Yav.

I find it interesting how we can examine the same data and reach the opposite conclusion. I thought Kgray is the most likely busser by far, followed by celaph.

I suspect we are both unwittingly influenced by our own propensity for bussing

[foodcoats]

While I agree that he's been coasting a little, I do not believe Celaph is the best kill for today. There are much more scummier people around.

I'll happily vote for a maniac wagon if it pops off.



(Or y'all could see the light and join me here on Dargo...)

I can't join Dargo and would explain why (again). We have a Cop for sure (because scum have a Stalker). So, if Dargo is fake claiming the real Cop will counter claim at some point. So, unless we have a janitored night kill we shouldn't be voting Dargo.
Ghug, a town PR also explained this and I don't understand why people still can't understand.
Also, if there is other cop he should probably claim and list his scans at next EON.

Granted I’m giving these points for like... confirmation bias? To some degree, but the fact that yavu bona and macca ALL fight against darg’s cop claim, and then Kak’s fakeclaim successfully drew the NK... while bona’s brilliant effort at softing for like the entire game didn’t draw anything...

I can’t help but wonder if bona actually convinced his scummates that darg was faking and they allowed themselves to be fooled by Kak.

[foodcoats]

I really don't get why you're pushing on Bona so hard.

Because of how terribly he explained his stance on dargo.

[foodcoats]

I really don't get why you're pushing on Bona so hard.

Because of how terribly he explained his stance on dargo.

I honestly kept coming back to his D1 vote day after day and saying “naw, even with the tunnel, he can’t be scum!”

But his explanation of his darg view was so flawed he obviously is not town.

[foodcoats]

Damo confirmed town

This reaction makes me feel scum RBed Vecna and Yav is tryng to clear his partner Damo.

Kgray picked up on this too i believe... if we flip yavu and he is scum, worth remembering.

Something on my mind is if they RB’d N1 then why didn’t they janitor? Urk.

[foodcoats]

##VOTE Macca

Why Macca? One thing we knew is that at least two scum were around closer to EOD to change kill.

##vote Jamiet

Looks like you and bona were last to post before Kak got NK’d

[foodcoats]

Alright well kgray as RDR’s ambassador will have to give me some insight here but rdr really looks town

He sorts
He is passionate
He evolves naturally
He makes mechanical as well as qualitative analysis
He comes up with theories
He makes mistakes and moves on
Etc

[foodcoats]

I also think rdr was pushed as the alternative to celaph in the D2 midday but i have to reread celaph too

[Chaqa]

celaph put Demon 4-3 in the lead, an unlikely scum move

Bona put Demon 5-4 in the lead against 3 non-Mafia with 17 minutes to go, a highly unlkely scum move

Chaqa put Demon 5-3 in the lead, although an unlikely scum move Chaqa does love a bus and his protests about day 1 bussing look suspicious

Food was the first to vote Demon but was his 5th different votee of the day so does look indecisive town.

kgray more or less puts the nail in Demon's coffin with her vote putting him 6-4 in the lead against non-Mafia with 2 minutes to go. An extremely doubtful bus.

Bussing likelihood

Chaqa >> celaph > food >> Bona >>> Kgray

So we either have

No bussers => scum team is Jamie Macca rdr yav [G4]
1 busser => Chaqa + 3 of G4 or just maybe celaph + 3 of G4
2 bussers => Chaqa celaph + I would guess Macca and Yav.

This all points to tomorrow's kill target being either Macca or Yav.

I find it interesting how we can examine the same data and reach the opposite conclusion. I thought Kgray is the most likely busser by far, followed by celaph.

I suspect we are both unwittingly influenced by our own propensity for bussing

I don't like bussing...

[foodcoats]

Hi Foodcoats

Who’s there

Who’s there I say