MAFIA 66: The Battle for Olympus - Game Thread [hidden]

[Bonatogether]

I did the math and there’s not any reason for scum!Jamie to lie about who the WW is, as far as I can tell. If Jamie named a town member and got a mis-kill, tomorrow it would still be 5-4-1 and the Wolf + town would have a 6-4 lead to flip him and keep us out of MYLO/KYLO or whatever the new acronyms are

I'm not lying.

Wow thanks

[Jamiet99uk]

@Bona

Stop stalling. You don't want to answer my question. Why is that?

[Hamilton Brian]

I'm going to try to do this briefly and then add explanations throughout the day.

Foodcoats is right. I am the werewolf. I've had 2 unsuccessful chomps. Hence my frustration yesterday.

Jamie as Janitor was the 2nd one. Jamie was also my second choice and I did not go with my original person.

Kgray was my first attempt but not as a VT guess.

I was considering what my options were when the game started. I didn't see a win condition for me by helping mafia (and maybe there is but I didn't see the numbers). So my decision was to help town. It still is. Town wins when mafia and werewolf are gone. I think when you look at the condition for winning, I am a useful role for nighttime for you.

The benefit I've had for town hasn't been great and my reads have been all over the place. However, knowing now that the Scum/Town/Werewolf/Town, it might reveal the reasons for voting movement.

And if this is not the best time to have revealed, then I am sure some smartalec will be more than willing to educate me on it.

[Chaqa]

I did the math and there’s not any reason for scum!Jamie to lie about who the WW is, as far as I can tell. If Jamie named a town member and got a mis-kill, tomorrow it would still be 5-4-1 and the Wolf + town would have a 6-4 lead to flip him and keep us out of MYLO/KYLO or whatever the new acronyms are

I'm not lying.

Was posting this before I saw your reveal.

[Bonatogether]

You and bona have spent more words telling everyone not to read into your absences than you have helped town.

This is patently untrue in my case.

[Jamiet99uk]

I'm going to try to do this briefly and then add explanations throughout the day.

Foodcoats is right. I am the werewolf. I've had 2 unsuccessful chomps. Hence my frustration yesterday.

Jamie as Janitor was the 2nd one. Jamie was also my second choice and I did not go with my original person.

Kgray was my first attempt but not as a VT guess.

I was considering what my options were when the game started. I didn't see a win condition for me by helping mafia (and maybe there is but I didn't see the numbers). So my decision was to help town. It still is. Town wins when mafia and werewolf are gone. I think when you look at the condition for winning, I am a useful role for nighttime for you.

The benefit I've had for town hasn't been great and my reads have been all over the place. However, knowing now that the Scum/Town/Werewolf/Town, it might reveal the reasons for voting movement.

And if this is not the best time to have revealed, then I am sure some smartalec will be more than willing to educate me on it.

Thank you for this info. Hard luck guessing wrong on me.

Did you guess Kgray was a Town role or a Mafia role?

[Chaqa]

I'm going to try to do this briefly and then add explanations throughout the day.

Foodcoats is right. I am the werewolf. I've had 2 unsuccessful chomps. Hence my frustration yesterday.

Jamie as Janitor was the 2nd one. Jamie was also my second choice and I did not go with my original person.

Kgray was my first attempt but not as a VT guess.

I was considering what my options were when the game started. I didn't see a win condition for me by helping mafia (and maybe there is but I didn't see the numbers). So my decision was to help town. It still is. Town wins when mafia and werewolf are gone. I think when you look at the condition for winning, I am a useful role for nighttime for you.

The benefit I've had for town hasn't been great and my reads have been all over the place. However, knowing now that the Scum/Town/Werewolf/Town, it might reveal the reasons for voting movement.

And if this is not the best time to have revealed, then I am sure some smartalec will be more than willing to educate me on it.

What did you guess on kgray?

[Jamiet99uk]

You and bona have spent more words telling everyone not to read into your absences than you have helped town.

This is patently untrue in my case.

You're literally stalling on answering, by commenting on all these posts.

[Hamilton Brian]

I guessed godfather on kgray

[Chaqa]

Hamilton can’t be nightkilled, but I assume now that the Wolf is outed, mafia would just begin roleblocking him and kill Dargo.

Keeping him around as another guaranteed non-mafia person has some value.

What do we think?

[Chaqa]

Math wise he’s essentially a town member, but with some potential to be a wild card.

[Hamilton Brian]

Math wise he’s essentially a town member, but with some potential to be a wild card.

I'd say essentially town knowing I'd be on the block for biting anyone town.

[Hamilton Brian]

And I'd be pretty sus of people wanting to kill me when there's value to me being kept around. Plus, what information does my death reveal?

[dargorygel]

Foodcoats us right? Why not Jamie us right?

[Jamiet99uk]

Foodcoats us right? Why not Jamie us right?

"Us" ?

[Hamilton Brian]

All your base are belong to us?

[damo666]

We cannot afford to not kill HB

If we miskill it will 6 4 1

Scum kills town and HB chomps town it's 4 4 1 and we've lost.

If we kill HB it will be 5-4 tomorrow.

If scum RB HB and kill darg it will be 5 4 1 and we'll be unable to kill HB

[Jamiet99uk]

Hamilton can’t be nightkilled, but I assume now that the Wolf is outed, mafia would just begin roleblocking him and kill Dargo.

Keeping him around as another guaranteed non-mafia person has some value.

What do we think?

This ensures Mafia kill a townclear.

Why is that a good thing?

[Jamiet99uk]

##Vote Hamilton

[foodcoats]

Well played HB, it’s a tough role to draw.

You have provided some very valuable info to town.

Voting for you now sucks but town is forced to do it - you could choose to go on a rampage and duel down the mafia. This is so obvious that yavu and Chaq now look awful.

##VOTE Hamilton