MAFIA 66: The Battle for Olympus - Game Thread [hidden]

[TheMadMonarch]

On what basis please? Why do you think they are scum?

Jamie janitor i assume? What aboot rdr and damo?

I don't think HB is scum.

Yav? I'm a gut reads person, but I'll try to give a bit of a reason.

He just kinda hasn't done anything? I know that's rich coming from me, but I frankly might scumread myself if this wasn't a thing I did all the time.

He has less then 10 posts and 1300 words more than me, and I was basically missing for 5 days.

Neither of these are super strong tho, keep that in mind.



Did you read what I wrote in my big piece? Assuming Jamie is telling the truth, I believe the wolf to likely be either damo or rdr.

I did read your post about WW. I think it’s interesting that you say rdr scumreads Jamie much less than damo, because it’s actually rdr who was adamant about Jamie Janitor last night. Damo actually spent a lot of time considering Chaqa as Janitor. Where did you get the idea that damo janitor-reads Jamie more than rdr janitor-reads Jamie?

I did a quick search. Damo has said it more, and for longer. That was the extent of it. rdr said it like 2 or 3 times.

[foodcoats]

Again we should not be hunting WW now because Jamie literally knows who it is and can claim it later.

What we need to do is DK scum so that we can continue to process previous days’ activity and catch more scum.

I believe we effectively have already caught the WW because I completely believe Jaime.

Hmm.

I guess if Jamie claims the WW we can elim them from the POE.

But again I still think scum will derail the conversation with it.

Look at how much discussion this is already wasting...

[foodcoats]

Alright, Jamie you’re vastly more experienced than I. If you think it’s right to claim, go ahead.

[dargorygel]

I do not see the reason to wait to reveal. Kill em I say. Sure, it will produce an argument... But it is already doing that. Maybe I do not get the math. But reveal and let us vote.

[dargorygel]

Again we should not be hunting WW now because Jamie literally knows who it is and can claim it later.

What we need to do is DK scum so that we can continue to process previous days’ activity and catch more scum.

I believe we effectively have already caught the WW because I completely believe Jaime.

Hmm.

I guess if Jamie claims the WW we can elim them from the POE.

But again I still think scum will derail the conversation with it.

Look at how much discussion this is already wasting...

Yes... But the flip will clear things up

[foodcoats]

I don't think HB is scum.

Yav? I'm a gut reads person, but I'll try to give a bit of a reason.

He just kinda hasn't done anything? I know that's rich coming from me, but I frankly might scumread myself if this wasn't a thing I did all the time.

He has less then 10 posts and 1300 words more than me, and I was basically missing for 5 days.

Neither of these are super strong tho, keep that in mind.



Did you read what I wrote in my big piece? Assuming Jamie is telling the truth, I believe the wolf to likely be either damo or rdr.

I did read your post about WW. I think it’s interesting that you say rdr scumreads Jamie much less than damo, because it’s actually rdr who was adamant about Jamie Janitor last night. Damo actually spent a lot of time considering Chaqa as Janitor. Where did you get the idea that damo janitor-reads Jamie more than rdr janitor-reads Jamie?

I did a quick search. Damo has said it more, and for longer. That was the extent of it. rdr said it like 2 or 3 times.

Okay, but is there no one else who scumreads Jamie who could be WW?

[foodcoats]

Again we should not be hunting WW now because Jamie literally knows who it is and can claim it later.

What we need to do is DK scum so that we can continue to process previous days’ activity and catch more scum.

I believe we effectively have already caught the WW because I completely believe Jaime.

Hmm.

I guess if Jamie claims the WW we can elim them from the POE.

But again I still think scum will derail the conversation with it.

Look at how much discussion this is already wasting...

Yes... But the flip will clear things up

Yeah agreed, I realize that now

[foodcoats]

What about this:
Scum learned who the ww is on N1 so thry krpt RBing the wolf while dargo claimed the RB? I don't feel like doubting dargorygel until cclaimed though.
Maybe dargo isn't roleblocked tonight and it was ww who got roleblocked? Dargo??

Yavu, on balance, do you think darg is scum or town?

[foodcoats]

This Chaqa!Janitor stuff all popping up as soon as the night started is pretty great.

Good planning on organizing this nonsense, scumbos.

If i were Janitor it would have been used Night 1. Get better than that.

If you were janitor that's exactly what you would say.
But ##vote Macca because I promised that to damo Also Macca flip will be good: If scum, I will lock my endvote on rivera and even if they're town, we can reconsider the votes in Day 3.

Sorry yavu, I must have missed this...

Why do you think Macca and rdr are scum together?

[foodcoats]

If you were janitor that's exactly what you would say.
But ##vote Macca because I promised that to damo Also Macca flip will be good: If scum, I will lock my endvote on rivera and even if they're town, we can reconsider the votes in Day 3.

You know we are in milo, don't you? So if they are town we lose.

I can't see a world where Yav is town.

I guess we should wait for one night then?
@Werewolf, please try for mafia next night, town should agree not to expose WWs name. If we agree, ww can freely try to consume a mafia without the fear of being exposed.

Are you saying here yavu you think we should wait to flip Macca?

Who do you want to vote for instead?

[kgray]

I’m going to be gone for basically all of today (irl) because I’m playing in a vFTF dip tourney. First round was last night and I’m currently in second, wish me luck!

I think I believe Jamie..? And I think it’d be best for him to reveal the werewolf, but really I haven’t thought it through.

I’m going to try to keep checking in, but I’ll be back tonight at least. ##vote Hamilton for now.

[foodcoats]

Anyway, he said he blocked Jamie, rdr and Chaqa

SO

I was scumblocked so am not Mafia (could be ww but I'm not)

scum RBd darg Ns 2 & 3 which makes perfect sense with his doc claim

My scumteam of Jamie Macca rdr Yav remains possible

What makes you put me in the same team with my top scumreads?

Sorry yavu just clipping this in.

So your scum team is macca jamie rdr...

Who do you think is the 4th?

[foodcoats]

Oh I just had a thought about who it might be.

Now I’m very interested to hear.

[TheMadMonarch]

I did read your post about WW. I think it’s interesting that you say rdr scumreads Jamie much less than damo, because it’s actually rdr who was adamant about Jamie Janitor last night. Damo actually spent a lot of time considering Chaqa as Janitor. Where did you get the idea that damo janitor-reads Jamie more than rdr janitor-reads Jamie?

I did a quick search. Damo has said it more, and for longer. That was the extent of it. rdr said it like 2 or 3 times.

Okay, but is there no one else who scumreads Jamie who could be WW?

I searched posts with "Jamie" and "janitor", because I assumed it was someone with a janitor specific read rather than just scum. I reason because it seems to risky otherwise, and to me frankly, it too risky with.

If Jamie has been informed, it means the werewolf has already missed twice; why didn't we hear about those? If the werewolf knew they were running at a risk of reveal, why take a risk like Jamie?

So many questions, so few answers.

[Chaqa]

I say reveal.

It’s not me btw

[foodcoats]

I did a quick search. Damo has said it more, and for longer. That was the extent of it. rdr said it like 2 or 3 times.

Okay, but is there no one else who scumreads Jamie who could be WW?

I searched posts with "Jamie" and "janitor", because I assumed it was someone with a janitor specific read rather than just scum. I reason because it seems to risky otherwise, and to me frankly, it too risky with.

If Jamie has been informed, it means the werewolf has already missed twice; why didn't we hear about those? If the werewolf knew they were running at a risk of reveal, why take a risk like Jamie?

So many questions, so few answers.

Alright so anyway, you scum read yav?

Who else atm

[foodcoats]

I say reveal.

It’s not me btw

Let’s take bets, who do you think it is?

Mac says damo or rdr

[Chaqa]

I say reveal.

It’s not me btw

Let’s take bets, who do you think it is?

Mac says damo or rdr

Tbh I think it probably Jamie and he’s trying to big brain us

If not him... maybe yavu or celaph?

[Hamilton Brian]

I know I am probably the last one to suggest this since it's the reverse of my tendencies early in the game. However, let's assume WW is trying to help town. Leave it alone and try for the scumkill today.

[foodcoats]

I know I am probably the last one to suggest this since it's the reverse of my tendencies early in the game. However, let's assume WW is trying to help town. Leave it alone and try for the scumkill today.

I think it’s HB...

The “see you at EOD” post suggested frustration

This confirms?

Sorry HB

Can you tell us what you guessed on Jamie?