MAFIA 66: The Battle for Olympus - Game Thread [hidden]

[TheMadMonarch]

So I'm not the COP, but we can now be sure Dargo is. I was hoping he'd recant and maybe I'd draw the scum RB.

Nevermind.

I'm The TRB

Jamie was n1
RDR n2
Chaqa n3

This EOD was hilarious to read. An absolutely nuts show.

In conclusion. Not great.

We're down to one PR, dargo. I'll consent on this one for now, but know it is not with complaint. One more mistake and he's drawing votes again.

This is not great as he's going to be non-stop RB'd. If the scum locate the WW, they might RB them instead. So if darg is not RB'd, we know they've found it. If anyone other than darg claims RB, we pop 'em immediately.

[damo666]

If I discard thsoe I deem to be town for one reason another and I discard certain pairs as they don't make sense as scumpartners I am amazingly only left with one possible scumteam.

I am happy to announce the scumteam are:

Jamie
Macca
rdr
yav

Anyone apart from darg and I could be ww.

Prove me wrong.

Your theory has me as scum.
I am not scum.
:. Your theory is wrong.
QED

Very rigorous

[TheMadMonarch]

If I discard thsoe I deem to be town for one reason another and I discard certain pairs as they don't make sense as scumpartners I am amazingly only left with one possible scumteam.

I am happy to announce the scumteam are:

Jamie
Macca
rdr
yav

Anyone apart from darg and I could be ww.

Prove me wrong.

Your theory has me as scum.
I am not scum.
:. Your theory is wrong.
QED

Very rigorous

Thank you.

[damo666]

Speaking of items if anyone has the healing crystal you know what to do tonight.

I assume it is save dargo. But why? Why would the scum kill him? They can just non-stop RB?

No. Not dargo.

[damo666]

The item.

Vecna must have made and passed on an item. I very much doubt he made a vest N1.

Looking at each item in turn:

Gun

Surely scum or ww would have used by now. Brain wouldn't be able to holster so if a gun either
died with ghug (boo) or
still with a townie (yay) [shoot Macca]

Bins

If with town would have been watching darg so we can discount that
If with scum makes lack of Janitor even stranger, points to Janitor Chaqa
Died with ghug or brain

tbh I doubt Vecna made bins

Healing crystal

If with town your time has come
If with scum boo
If died with brain or ghug , sad

What about vest? Would Vecna just not use it?

Inventor cannot give to self.

[TheMadMonarch]

The item.

Vecna must have made and passed on an item. I very much doubt he made a vest N1.

Looking at each item in turn:

Gun

Surely scum or ww would have used by now. Brain wouldn't be able to holster so if a gun either
died with ghug (boo) or
still with a townie (yay) [shoot Macca]

Bins

If with town would have been watching darg so we can discount that
If with scum makes lack of Janitor even stranger, points to Janitor Chaqa
Died with ghug or brain

tbh I doubt Vecna made bins

Healing crystal

If with town your time has come
If with scum boo
If died with brain or ghug , sad

What about vest? Would Vecna just not use it?

Inventor cannot give to self.

I meant: would Vecna not give out a vest?

[TheMadMonarch]

Speaking of items if anyone has the healing crystal you know what to do tonight.

I assume it is save dargo. But why? Why would the scum kill him? They can just non-stop RB?

No. Not dargo.

Ok. That's good.

Good thing I don't have an item though. All this "you know who to use it on" really goes over my head.

[Chaqa]

Love the tinfoil that I must be janitor or WW because I got roleblocked. Truly inspired 10/10 theory

[damo666]

What about vest? Would Vecna just not use it?

Inventor cannot give to self.

I meant: would Vecna not give out a vest?

I assumed he wouldn't make a vest. Would be an inefficient use of the role given his profile and likelihood of early NK

[damo666]

So I'm not the COP, but we can now be sure Dargo is. I was hoping he'd recant and maybe I'd draw the scum RB.

Nevermind.

I'm The TRB

Jamie was n1
RDR n2
Chaqa n3

This EOD was hilarious to read. An absolutely nuts show.

In conclusion. Not great.

We're down to one PR, dargo. I'll consent on this one for now, but know it is not with complaint. One more mistake and he's drawing votes again.

This is not great as he's going to be non-stop RB'd. If the scum locate the WW, they might RB them instead. So if darg is not RB'd, we know they've found it. If anyone other than darg claims RB, we pop 'em immediately.

Scum Macca setting up a miskill

[damo666]

Love the tinfoil that I must be janitor or WW because I got roleblocked. Truly inspired 10/10 theory

Explain to me why
a) Fargo not consumed
b) no Janitor

[damo666]

Your theory has me as scum.
I am not scum.
:. Your theory is wrong.
QED

Very rigorous

Thank you.

Give me your 4 mafia team and I'll explain why you're wrong. This is an open invitation to anyone.

[TheMadMonarch]

Inventor cannot give to self.

I meant: would Vecna not give out a vest?

I assumed he wouldn't make a vest. Would be an inefficient use of the role given his profile and likelihood of early NK

Ok, good to know. I asked because I assumed you'd know more about Vecna's play.

[TheMadMonarch]

So I'm not the COP, but we can now be sure Dargo is. I was hoping he'd recant and maybe I'd draw the scum RB.

Nevermind.

I'm The TRB

Jamie was n1
RDR n2
Chaqa n3

This EOD was hilarious to read. An absolutely nuts show.

In conclusion. Not great.

We're down to one PR, dargo. I'll consent on this one for now, but know it is not with complaint. One more mistake and he's drawing votes again.

This is not great as he's going to be non-stop RB'd. If the scum locate the WW, they might RB them instead. So if darg is not RB'd, we know they've found it. If anyone other than darg claims RB, we pop 'em immediately.

Scum Macca setting up a miskill

Wish I were smart enough to do that.

[Chaqa]

Love the tinfoil that I must be janitor or WW because I got roleblocked. Truly inspired 10/10 theory

Explain to me why
a) Fargo not consumed
b) no Janitor

1) I assume WW doesn’t want to help Mafia at this point
2) Likely they planned to use it later (and didn’t expect ghug to flip PR or Maniac to suicide himself as PR) or the Janitor got RB’d Night 1?

[damo666]

Love the tinfoil that I must be janitor or WW because I got roleblocked. Truly inspired 10/10 theory

Explain to me why
a) Fargo not consumed
b) no Janitor

1) I assume WW doesn’t want to help Mafia at this point
2) Likely they planned to use it later (and didn’t expect ghug to flip PR or Maniac to suicide himself as PR) or the Janitor got RB’d Night 1?

1 Yep. Good point.
2 Why would RB J N1 prevent subsequent use?

[Jamiet99uk]

Game solution

Mafia Jamie yav rdr Macca
Werewolf Chaqa

There you have the answer but town will still manage to lose.

Now 8 4 1
EON 4 6 4 1
EOD5 6 4 0
EON6 5 4 0
EOD6 4 4 0 mafia win because you won't listen and you mk HB

Wrong.
I am town.

[Jamiet99uk]

Meaning, are there any players who have not had a sniff of being made a viable wagon? Why? Because they've obvtowned so hard?

I call bullshit. These people are operating right underneath us.

Yeah, I'll admit I fell into the trap of the Setup 1. It was a nice fantasy. But now? Let's put some 2s and 2s together.

Not that they have obvtowned but none of Jamie, rdr or Yav have been serious wagons.

Excuse me, wrong again, I was a 5-vote wagon at one point yesterday.

[Jamiet99uk]

@Chaqa: Who do you think is the Janitor then?

[foodcoats]

Explain to me why
a) Fargo not consumed
b) no Janitor

1) I assume WW doesn’t want to help Mafia at this point
2) Likely they planned to use it later (and didn’t expect ghug to flip PR or Maniac to suicide himself as PR) or the Janitor got RB’d Night 1?

1 Yep. Good point.
2 Why would RB J N1 prevent subsequent use?

The only way this makes sense is if Jamie was Janitor, got RBd N1, and then after the RB claims they worried Jamie might be watched. (I do not think Jamie is scum, btw.)

It might also just be because they were sending the ninja, so also sending the Janitor would create more possible people to be watched and they decided it was suboptimal to use the janitor at all.

Or perhaps they didn’t want to use janitor because they thought it would help WW to get the reveals and they were hoping to get WW help.