MAFIA 66: The Battle for Olympus - Game Thread [hidden]

[Bonatogether]

Yes

WTF?

Fits with their conjecture that posting carelessly is a townslip while posting carefully is NAI.

That was my thing but ever since he's been intentionally posting carelessly.

[Kakarroto]

Heya, sorry I wasn't here for a bit, work was a [equivalent female dog; used in slang] after I overslept yesterday and rushed there, had to 'show good intentions' *grmbl*

my last page is on 236, I'm not sure I can catch up until EoD, what did I miss? I hope I wasn't shot?

[Hamilton Brian]

Can you give me the Cliff Notes here? What makes you scumread Jamie overall?

I wish I could give you a hard, well-defined reason. What you read from me is exactly where my brain keeps going...back and forth. Hardly anything logical; it's all based on gut-reads where I don't like something that I read, but then I do like something I read.

Also, we know that Hamilton is on Jamie even though he has made cases for both town-Jamie and scum-Jamie and admits that he is uncertain. He was also uncertain about celaph.

Sorry if I am tunneling, but there is a good case for Ham to be scum here.

Did you all see how much effort HB put into town-reading yavu? But the same level of effort is not expended to scum-read Jamie or celaph, who he has voted for.

Very, very scummy of HB.

There are some things about HB that are bringing me around to maybe townreading him; it's a very difficult sort. But I would not at all be surprised if Hamilton is scum.

You're going to be surprised if you expect me to flip scum. When this game is over it might be worth it for us to sit down over a beer and I can explain a) how I started playing mafia, b) the road forward, and c) where I am now. It might surprise you. Or maybe not.

I really haven't figured out how to obv!town.

[Chaqa]

Heya, sorry I wasn't here for a bit, work was a [equivalent female dog; used in slang] after I overslept yesterday and rushed there, had to 'show good intentions' *grmbl*

my last page is on 236, I'm not sure I can catch up until EoD, what did I miss? I hope I wasn't shot?

Nothing too crazy. People softening on Jamie a bit, somewhat.

Kinda feeling like today is the day to get Hamilton.

[Bonatogether]

If I discard thsoe I deem to be town for one reason another and I discard certain pairs as they don't make sense as scumpartners I am amazingly only left with one possible scumteam.

I am happy to announce the scumteam are:

Jamie
Macca
rdr
yav

Anyone apart from darg and I could be ww.

Prove me wrong.

kgray celaph and darg aren't on here

proven

[Hamilton Brian]

Let me ask you this, then, since I'm towning on you...if it might be the wrong play to axe Jamie today who'd be a better replacement? Still Maniac or one of Macca/RDR/Yav? Hold off on answering that. I'd like to see if I can look at VCA to see who might generate more info. If I can't come up with it you'll know when I raise the white flag.

You shouldn't vote people based on who generates more info, you should vote the people you scumread. Why would it be the wrong play to axe Jamie today? Do you think he's town?

I honestly don't know if you're offering these suggestions and asking questions to help me improve my game or if you are trying to get me to doubt myself.

[Hamilton Brian]

Let me ask you this, then, since I'm towning on you...if it might be the wrong play to axe Jamie today who'd be a better replacement? Still Maniac or one of Macca/RDR/Yav? Hold off on answering that. I'd like to see if I can look at VCA to see who might generate more info. If I can't come up with it you'll know when I raise the white flag.

You shouldn't vote people based on who generates more info, you should vote the people you scumread. Why would it be the wrong play to axe Jamie today? Do you think he's town?

And when did you offer that same advice to Chaqa this game?

[Chaqa]

If I discard thsoe I deem to be town for one reason another and I discard certain pairs as they don't make sense as scumpartners I am amazingly only left with one possible scumteam.

I am happy to announce the scumteam are:

Jamie
Macca
rdr
yav

Anyone apart from darg and I could be ww.

Prove me wrong.

kgray celaph and darg aren't on here

proven

Why do you still insist Darg is scum?

[Chaqa]

Let me ask you this, then, since I'm towning on you...if it might be the wrong play to axe Jamie today who'd be a better replacement? Still Maniac or one of Macca/RDR/Yav? Hold off on answering that. I'd like to see if I can look at VCA to see who might generate more info. If I can't come up with it you'll know when I raise the white flag.

You shouldn't vote people based on who generates more info, you should vote the people you scumread. Why would it be the wrong play to axe Jamie today? Do you think he's town?

And when did you offer that same advice to Chaqa this game?

I'm not advocating for an info flip. I've actually come around that Maniac and Jamie are probably both not scum.

[Hamilton Brian]

Let me ask you this, then, since I'm towning on you...if it might be the wrong play to axe Jamie today who'd be a better replacement? Still Maniac or one of Macca/RDR/Yav? Hold off on answering that. I'd like to see if I can look at VCA to see who might generate more info. If I can't come up with it you'll know when I raise the white flag.

You shouldn't vote people based on who generates more info, you should vote the people you scumread. Why would it be the wrong play to axe Jamie today? Do you think he's town?

The other really problematic thing about HB's post here is he is now hedging against Jamie, who he is currently voting!!! and is also now saying, "Oh, maybe we do DK yav?" who he just made three big posts defending as town!!!

I think that is really going to be my NAI. Being the Libra that I am, it's a challenge to commit to anything since I see the value in everything. I wouldn't say I am hedging against Jamie; I'm looking for more info. And if someone has a reason for voting someone else, why are you so ossified that it's not worth listening?

[Chaqa]

I think my preferences today are Macca or Hamilton.

Yavu would be great too.

I'll stay on Macca for the moment, but I'm not thrilled that my co-voters are Damo and Yavu (I think there's a scum in between them). I do like the voters on Hamiton, though.

[Chaqa]

You shouldn't vote people based on who generates more info, you should vote the people you scumread. Why would it be the wrong play to axe Jamie today? Do you think he's town?

The other really problematic thing about HB's post here is he is now hedging against Jamie, who he is currently voting!!! and is also now saying, "Oh, maybe we do DK yav?" who he just made three big posts defending as town!!!

I think that is really going to be my NAI. Being the Libra that I am, it's a challenge to commit to anything since I see the value in everything. I wouldn't say I am hedging against Jamie; I'm looking for more info. And if someone has a reason for voting someone else, why are you so ossified that it's not worth listening?

Eww Astrology.

%%Vote Hamilton

[Kakarroto]

I'm not feeling it for flipping Hamilton today ... I'd give him another night, I guess. But maybe I'm wrong and we should. My doubts are as strong as my suspicions.

I see celaph wagon had died ... again. Must've been some good speech. And I also see if I vote Macca, that's probably Macca gone. Hmm ...

[Bonatogether]

If I discard thsoe I deem to be town for one reason another and I discard certain pairs as they don't make sense as scumpartners I am amazingly only left with one possible scumteam.

I am happy to announce the scumteam are:

Jamie
Macca
rdr
yav

Anyone apart from darg and I could be ww.

Prove me wrong.

kgray celaph and darg aren't on here

proven

Why do you still insist Darg is scum?

darg isn't cop

[celaph]

kgray celaph and darg aren't on here

proven

Why do you still insist Darg is scum?

darg isn't cop

Are you cop or ww? Because your confidence over a detail so trivial is stupefying.

[Hamilton Brian]

Well then...I feel like I am on to something, but if the town will speak, the town will speak.

[kgray]

Let me ask you this, then, since I'm towning on you...if it might be the wrong play to axe Jamie today who'd be a better replacement? Still Maniac or one of Macca/RDR/Yav? Hold off on answering that. I'd like to see if I can look at VCA to see who might generate more info. If I can't come up with it you'll know when I raise the white flag.

You shouldn't vote people based on who generates more info, you should vote the people you scumread. Why would it be the wrong play to axe Jamie today? Do you think he's town?

I honestly don't know if you're offering these suggestions and asking questions to help me improve my game or if you are trying to get me to doubt myself.

Neither, I’m trying to figure out who you actually scumread.

[Chaqa]

Well then...I feel like I am on to something, but if the town will speak, the town will speak.

What are you onto?

[Chaqa]

@Jamie

I see you lurking. I think we've reached a rough consensus you're town. Could really use your input on what to do here.

[Hamilton Brian]

I'm on to my gallows pole. :) Not quite. But I also raised my white flag. Forgot to mention that as I was reading walking back from the market.

If I do get killed, I hope to fuck I was right about us being in Scenario 1.