MAFIA 66: The Battle for Olympus - Game Thread [hidden]

[Hamilton Brian]

I don't remember

I might call bull on that. I know it's easy to lose track but I think reasons are fairly clear. I know if I answered with "I don't remember," I'd be laughed out of here. Or at least grilled unendingly.

[Hamilton Brian]

Also, regarding the janitor thing: I don't think it makes sense for scum to Janitor brain, because his Watcher soft was so obvious. I know that if brain was Janitor'd and then someone claimed Watcher, I'd be really suspicious of that claim. So while Rivera obviously *could* be the Janitor, I think it's more likely that scum tried to Janitor Vecna and got blocked, so I think Jamie or Damo is more likely.

I want to hold on to this for the time being since you're admitting the suspicions you have about either Jamie, Damo, or both.

Was brain's Watcher soft obvious? Was there a particular writing that made it obvious?

I get what you're saying...that since the softclaim was obvious, someone else stepping in to claim it would be sus.

However, is this not a line of thinking based on the facts we now have? It's possible that there wasn't a soft claim.

How is it that scum would feel safe declaring them being roleblocked?

[Hamilton Brian]

"And I've liked some of the points he's made. I also think his vote for Demon looks good, since he joined me on that wagon when it was picking up steam and made it viable."

Did that vote look good? Almost 3 hours to go, then no movement off of it. Never showed back up, or at least didn't post around crunch time. One reads the remaining Celaph posts that day and they're simply responses to kgray and Chaqa and the only mention of the Demon wagon is Celaph querying if kgray was bussing.

Might make someone take notice and jump to a conclusion.

[Hamilton Brian]

Yes, Flum's original erroneous position has been pointed out as being erroneous, which you should understand by now.

Stop assuming there's any competence here.

[Hamilton Brian]

What do you mean playing off each other?

Arguing with one another to appear at odds? Theatre to make people assume they're not on the same side?

[Hamilton Brian]

Janitors don't work on DKs? And it would just not reveal the role, not say it was VT.

Right; thanks.

[Chaqa]

I’ve been thinking about the game state and I’m pretty sure Maniac is the Werewolf. Just a hunch.

[Chaqa]

I think Yavu is also a possible WW. If not I think either could be mafia

[Hamilton Brian]

I’ve been thinking about the game state and I’m pretty sure Maniac is the Werewolf. Just a hunch.

Care to share the hunch?

[Chaqa]

I’ve been thinking about the game state and I’m pretty sure Maniac is the Werewolf. Just a hunch.

Care to share the hunch?

I just did.

It’s mostly based off him seeming different from normal and his VT hard claim/retraction. He also seems pretty indifferent to the DKs.

[ghug]

I’ve been thinking about the game state and I’m pretty sure Maniac is the Werewolf. Just a hunch.

Care to share the hunch?

I just did.

It’s mostly based off him seeming different from normal and his VT hard claim/retraction. He also seems pretty indifferent to the DKs.

The VT hardclaim seems like someone who wasn't thinking about the werewolf at all to me.

[rdrivera2005]

I'm softening on celaph but not fully.

Rdr/kgray/chaqa is where I'm currently at.
I still have concerns with one of Jamiet/damo

Maniac i think is town.
Getting general town vibes from a bunch of other players

This reads are almost unbelievable for an experienced player like you.

[Bonatogether]

I don't remember

I might call bull on that. I know it's easy to lose track but I think reasons are fairly clear. I know if I answered with "I don't remember," I'd be laughed out of here. Or at least grilled unendingly.

Either do it or don't, no wishy washy "oh I might call you on this"

[ghug]

I'm softening on celaph but not fully.

Rdr/kgray/chaqa is where I'm currently at.
I still have concerns with one of Jamiet/damo

Maniac i think is town.
Getting general town vibes from a bunch of other players

This reads are almost unbelievable for an experienced player like you.

Which parts don't you like?

[Bonatogether]

"And I've liked some of the points he's made. I also think his vote for Demon looks good, since he joined me on that wagon when it was picking up steam and made it viable."

Did that vote look good? Almost 3 hours to go, then no movement off of it. Never showed back up, or at least didn't post around crunch time. One reads the remaining Celaph posts that day and they're simply responses to kgray and Chaqa and the only mention of the Demon wagon is Celaph querying if kgray was bussing.

Might make someone take notice and jump to a conclusion.

It's almost like celaph and kgray are scum together.

[Bonatogether]

What do you mean playing off each other?

Arguing with one another to appear at odds? Theatre to make people assume they're not on the same side?

For a while kgray was defending celaph so I don't think that's the best way to describe it.

[rdrivera2005]

I'm softening on celaph but not fully.

Rdr/kgray/chaqa is where I'm currently at.
I still have concerns with one of Jamiet/damo

Maniac i think is town.
Getting general town vibes from a bunch of other players

This reads are almost unbelievable for an experienced player like you.

Which parts don't you like?

Having both Chaqa and Kgray as scum considering both voted (and pushed) Demon.

Having Maniac as his strong town read.

And the general lack of substance. "Having concerns about Jamie/Damo. Which concerns?

I have to check if it wasn't an HB post.

[Fluminator]

I'm softening on celaph but not fully.

Rdr/kgray/chaqa is where I'm currently at.
I still have concerns with one of Jamiet/damo

Maniac i think is town.
Getting general town vibes from a bunch of other players

This reads are almost unbelievable for an experienced player like you.

If it makes you feel better, that response makes me quite confident I'm wrong on at least one.

[foodcoats]

You know what, ##vote bona and I'm not moving this until you explain why you thought worcej's D1 vote was towny. You won't get off my back for my townread of celaph but I don't think your townread of worcej was genuine. None of the reasons you gave held up to questioning, and you're avoiding this question so much that I cannot think of any reason for you to not answer it except that you know it was a BS reason in the first place. I think you were jumping on brain's read and looking for reasons to switch to celaph's wagon. And I think my assuming you wouldn't have the nerve to stay off your counter wagon at EOD is dangerously underestimating you.

Hold on... wasn’t the “I’m not Xing until you Y” what got you to miskill worcej?

##VOTE kgray

[ghug]

You know what, ##vote bona and I'm not moving this until you explain why you thought worcej's D1 vote was towny. You won't get off my back for my townread of celaph but I don't think your townread of worcej was genuine. None of the reasons you gave held up to questioning, and you're avoiding this question so much that I cannot think of any reason for you to not answer it except that you know it was a BS reason in the first place. I think you were jumping on brain's read and looking for reasons to switch to celaph's wagon. And I think my assuming you wouldn't have the nerve to stay off your counter wagon at EOD is dangerously underestimating you.

Hold on... wasn’t the “I’m not Xing until you Y” what got you to miskill worcej?

##VOTE kgray

Why does doing it again make her scum?