MAFIA 66: The Battle for Olympus - Game Thread [hidden]

[Chaqa]

My head hurts. Im going back to bed lol

[Jamiet99uk]

Given Janitor in play I think either Jamie or rdr must be Janitor. We don't have to vote for either though, werewolf can consume.

Or you.

And I don't believe werewolf will take this risk.

Or me from othersPOV agreed.

Werewolf is welcome to consume Janitorme if they like.

##vote Jamie

I am not the Janitor. I was only fake-claiming that during the night because lying is fun and has no consequences at all.

[Jamiet99uk]

We lost brain, which I'm a bit sad about. He's always fun to play with.

Working my way through, but it's ANZAC day here is Australia, so I've had quite a busy morning.

STOP MAKING EXCUSES
You have done nothing all game but make excuses.
Participate properly today or be killed.

[foodcoats]

It could be that BB has worked out who the doctor or Journalist is and that's not Celaph, So when BB has seen celaph visit someone he has concluded he must be scum.

If this is true, I will take back what I said about Maniac wagon

I can see how the Watcher might deduce the Doctor, but how could he decide who the Journalist is, Maniac?

[Jamiet99uk]

##VOTE MACCA

I think we've had quite enough of this anchoring and delaying from Macca.

[Jamiet99uk]

It could be that BB has worked out who the doctor or Journalist is and that's not Celaph, So when BB has seen celaph visit someone he has concluded he must be scum.

If this is true, I will take back what I said about Maniac wagon

I can see how the Watcher might deduce the Doctor, but how could he decide who the Journalist is, Maniac?

The Journalist's action is a visit.

[Chaqa]

##VOTE MACCA

I think we've had quite enough of this anchoring and delaying from Macca.

Spicy. ##Vote Macca

Back to sleep for real now

[Jamiet99uk]

Makes me laugh when people post as they catch up.

It's known as the "Flavius method" and it's actually quite useful, despite the extra posts it generates, because you react to information as you would have at the time of its reveal.

[Jamiet99uk]

Ok I'm caught up.

I'm half tempted to do a deep dive for Brainbomb's watcher crumbs, and half terrified that doing that will cause me to want to gnaw off my own hands in frustration at reading all of Brain's nonsense writing.

[damo666]

Or you.

And I don't believe werewolf will take this risk.

Or me from othersPOV agreed.

Werewolf is welcome to consume Janitorme if they like.

##vote Jamie

I am not the Janitor. I was only fake-claiming that during the night because lying is fun and has no consequences at all.

My vote had nothing to do with your 'claim'.

Anyway, what do you make of my theory that you, me and rdr are good Janitor candidates? And if I am to believe you it's rdr. Quite happy to vote rdr.

[foodcoats]

Shower Thought:

Werewolf can't be nightkilled, right? So we're assuming Vecna was killed by the mafia. Is there a world where werewolf decides to help scum? Good guess at Vecna's role (maybe he crumbed something?) and someone with a wealth of experience playing with Vecna to pick it up?

So then mafia know who the werewolf is; they can't kill it, but could they guide it to effective daykills?

Just wondering...

I want to continue spending time rereading worcej and the numerous interactions but it is TOO nice outside. It'll be an intermittent task.

##vote HB No need to elaborate

I think I saw later that you explained this as “town would not think about how WW can help scum.” I don’t agree, but I do think this fits into a pattern of HB making posts that do not advance the game for town but rather are a fakenews attempt to make it LOOK like he is solving.

[damo666]

Ok I'm caught up.

I'm half tempted to do a deep dive for Brainbomb's watcher crumbs, and half terrified that doing that will cause me to want to gnaw off my own hands in frustration at reading all of Brain's nonsense writing.

Don't bother. I've done it and as I keep saying repeatedly over and over again more than once and for the umpteenth time brain got no useful info as watcher.

I think he was probably pissed off that he learnt nothing.

[rdrivera2005]

I don't think the Janitor will be doing the kill with a Ninja around. And Vecna wasn't Janitored so this makes no sense.
And if he saw me doing a kill why he didn't even vote for me D2?

It's look a lot like you tryng to find reasons to justify your scum read on me and not an organic analysis of Brain's flip. Like that game you were scum with ND...

I mean, you're right about janitor to stay down while ninja is around. But wouldn't I say something more about this if I was trying to find reasons to justify my scumread on you? You're chasing a careless message with 2 lines. My scumread on you is mostly based on your D1 vote, not what brain said. And if that's what you want to hear: I retract any arguments who say rivera is scum because BB observed him move. I really don't think that's the case. Rivera is still scum though. ##vote rdrivera

You scumreading me because my vote D1 is bizarre. You also scumread Worcej?
I feel good with my vote, will probably only change if Damo become a viable wagon.

[damo666]

I'll join the pressure vote

##vote Macca

[rdrivera2005]

Or me from othersPOV agreed.

Werewolf is welcome to consume Janitorme if they like.

##vote Jamie

I am not the Janitor. I was only fake-claiming that during the night because lying is fun and has no consequences at all.

My vote had nothing to do with your 'claim'.

Anyway, what do you make of my theory that you, me and rdr are good Janitor candidates? And if I am to believe you it's rdr. Quite happy to vote rdr.

I think your theory is bullshit. If I was Janitor I would have used my power at N1. And I expect you or Jamie to use it at N2. Not using it probably means that Mafia is too cautious or that Janitor is a deep threat that don't want to risk to be seen/reported/etc.

[damo666]

I am not the Janitor. I was only fake-claiming that during the night because lying is fun and has no consequences at all.

My vote had nothing to do with your 'claim'.

Anyway, what do you make of my theory that you, me and rdr are good Janitor candidates? And if I am to believe you it's rdr. Quite happy to vote rdr.

I think your theory is bullshit. If I was Janitor I would have used my power at N1. And I expect you or Jamie to use it at N2. Not using it probably means that Mafia is too cautious or that Janitor is a deep threat that don't want to risk to be seen/reported/etc.

O. I think you may be right. It makes no sense for you to be Janitor. It's possible Janitor Jamie was blocked N1 and held N2 but I'll shelve that for the time being. Same ofc could be said for me. Gonna forget it.

[Jamiet99uk]

I am not the Janitor. I was only fake-claiming that during the night because lying is fun and has no consequences at all.

My vote had nothing to do with your 'claim'.

Anyway, what do you make of my theory that you, me and rdr are good Janitor candidates? And if I am to believe you it's rdr. Quite happy to vote rdr.

It was Maniac who originally proposed that I was Janitor. Maniac's theory about me wasn't that bad but it weirdly left you out (because Maniac was tunelling me because of his contempt for me and desire to eliminate me from the game irrespective of my alignment, which he has openly admitted because he's apparently a toxic, hateful arsehole in real life).

What's the angle on Rdr being Janitor? I'm not sure I've understood that...

[damo666]

scumteam guess #3

yav Macca Flum Maniac

WW food

[damo666]

I am not the Janitor. I was only fake-claiming that during the night because lying is fun and has no consequences at all.

My vote had nothing to do with your 'claim'.

Anyway, what do you make of my theory that you, me and rdr are good Janitor candidates? And if I am to believe you it's rdr. Quite happy to vote rdr.

It was Maniac who originally proposed that I was Janitor. Maniac's theory about me wasn't that bad but it weirdly left you out (because Maniac was tunelling me because of his contempt for me and desire to eliminate me from the game irrespective of my alignment, which he has openly admitted because he's apparently a toxic, hateful arsehole in real life).

What's the angle on Rdr being Janitor? I'm not sure I've understood that...

abandoned

[Jamiet99uk]

Ok I'm caught up.

I'm half tempted to do a deep dive for Brainbomb's watcher crumbs, and half terrified that doing that will cause me to want to gnaw off my own hands in frustration at reading all of Brain's nonsense writing.

Don't bother. I've done it and as I keep saying repeatedly over and over again more than once and for the umpteenth time brain got no useful info as watcher.

I think he was probably pissed off that he learnt nothing.

Sadly I have done it, and I came to the same conclusion.

I will post my comments on each of the relevant posts, if anyone wants me to?

However, the only conclusions I can draw are:

- It's not certain Brainbomb visited Celaph N1.
- Brainbomb's scumread on Celaph appears unrelated to Watching.
- Brainbomb probably targeted Maniac last night.