MAFIA 66: The Battle for Olympus - Game Thread [hidden]

[celaph]

Also foodcoats isn't scum, or if he is I'm going to give up playing.

Can you say more about this?

[Hamilton Brian]

how is it possible you liked what we put down when you clearly have absolutely no idea what our debate was actually about?

I was reading the Clif notes. As time has gone on, and another re-read, you concern me.

[brainbomb]

I don't have solid arguements for the following people but I got some impressions by reading the old pages:
Town leaning reads:
ghug
kgray
jamiet99uk
celaph
Scum leaning reads:
Bonatogether

Also Hamilton Brian 's posts sound like a novice mafia. I think I will vote for him. ##vote Hamilton Brian

what does a novice mafia do that an expert mafia or amatuer mafia do

[brainbomb]

how is it possible you liked what we put down when you clearly have absolutely no idea what our debate was actually about?

I was reading the Clif notes. As time has gone on, and another re-read, you concern me.

oh good another null to scumlean player miraculously deciding im scum. good stuff. guess this is gonna be a fast game

[foodcoats]

##VOTE kgray

You don't get townpoints for this anymore.

bit boring of a response that sort of feels like its coming from a place of "I guess I -have- to do this".

Vecna, were you suggesting there was anything alignment indicative here?

[Bonatogether]

does anyone know them?

They're on the mafia discord

[brainbomb]

by the way if you happen to witness anyone dying tonight and you see someone performing a kill do not claim as the kills can potentially be driven

[brainbomb]

Driver:
You are the DRIVER. Each day you must vote for a suspect. Each night, you may visit TWO other players player by PM'ing the GM’s with the order ##DRIVE <NAME> AND <NAME>. Any actions performed on player one will be transferred onto player two, and vice versa. They will not be notified of your visit. At night you can talk to the other Mafia in the Mafia QT at <LINK>. You win when the Werewolf and all of the Town have been eliminated, or nothing can stop this from happening.

[Hamilton Brian]

I don't have solid arguements for the following people but I got some impressions by reading the old pages:
Town leaning reads:
ghug
kgray
jamiet99uk
celaph
Scum leaning reads:
Bonatogether

Also Hamilton Brian 's posts sound like a novice mafia. I think I will vote for him. ##vote Hamilton Brian

Spoken like scum looking for an easy fish to fry.

Why the lean on Bona?
Old pages...that mean you were digging into meta? What games have informed your "gut?"

[Bonatogether]

This assumes that a scum player (macca) was self aware during a stream of consciousness post that they were being their ordinary self and went and self edited. Im not even sure how this refutes my point that they added faked enthuisiasm at the end to look towny. again this post was from M64 and not this game.

Scum players are always (or should always be) self-aware of what their posts look like.

I agree and being careless is a towny behaviour. When I was scum, I used to reread all my messages before posting so I wouldn't scumslip. Posting careful is NAI but posting careless is town-ish.

I don't like this post because it's unnecessary and unprompted elaboration on someone else's kinda old comment. Bad vibes, really

[yavuzovic]

I sort of thought in my darkest most sinister consideration that yav was attempting to execute a script that would crash the bot on purpose to take it out of use. But I also thought that would be super unsporting, and very outside of his level of evil. yav simply wouldnt try to crash the bot imo.

but the joke still didnt make much sense to me. maybe it wasnt for me. I dunno who the joke was for.

Jamie reacting to this seems a little forced since it has already been discussed a decent amount

I wish I was able to code good enough to crash the bot though.
crash(bot)

Anyway, I don't think your accusation on Jamie is applicable because I do it a lot too: He just reacts upon seeing the message before finishing to catch up.

[yavuzovic]

Scum players are always (or should always be) self-aware of what their posts look like.

I agree and being careless is a towny behaviour. When I was scum, I used to reread all my messages before posting so I wouldn't scumslip. Posting careful is NAI but posting careless is town-ish.

I don't like this post because it's unnecessary and unprompted elaboration on someone else's kinda old comment. Bad vibes, really

I don't know why you think it's scummy to react to an old post. Last 2 hours passed me trying to cath up and I started from the point I left, and I reacted to every message I found worthy. You may be right about the necessity, but I guess I would be more careful if I were mafia.

[Bonatogether]

It's an early d1 offhand comment. You can't read anything into it.

this implies you think Vecna is town, and an authority over public opinion.
Do you fear Vecna will sway the game his way?

This post makes brain less scummy in my eyes and makes me suspicious about Bona. Like Bone, I townread Vecna too but he assumed that Vecna is town when writing this. Does Bona know who's mafia and who's not? We have the werewolf though. It's still suspicious and I'm fine with switching my vote to Bona. I just need to catch up so I can see the thread clearer.

I do not townread Vecna as strongly as people seem to think. He's more very soft town, but I would use that phrasing regardless of my perception of the other player.

[yavuzovic]

it was yav making a joke but it was flamboyant

Brainbomb is confirmed small nails. Don't forget: 97% more likely. Also his messages feel scummy.

yav what is small nails? you make this expression a few times. is this a character?

Not really, I met with a friend irl who had very small nails. We talked about them being alien nails and they are "sus". And I carried the joke to here. It's not a meaningful statement.

[Hamilton Brian]

oh good another null to scumlean player miraculously deciding im scum. good stuff. guess this is gonna be a fast game

Is this hubris? You considering I'm leaning scum?

[Bonatogether]

This assumes that a scum player (macca) was self aware during a stream of consciousness post that they were being their ordinary self and went and self edited. Im not even sure how this refutes my point that they added faked enthuisiasm at the end to look towny. again this post was from M64 and not this game.

Scum players are always (or should always be) self-aware of what their posts look like.

this is completely untrue. and if anything this is the reason why scum mess up most often. alot of players hit submit without rereading. and it bites them in the ass as scum. not everyone is careful. this has never been true.

Then they should be aware of what they're typing before they send it. Macca's pretty smart and I figure that they do reread their posts.

[Bonatogether]

I don't have solid arguements for the following people but I got some impressions by reading the old pages:
Town leaning reads:
ghug
kgray
jamiet99uk
celaph
Scum leaning reads:
Bonatogether

Also Hamilton Brian 's posts sound like a novice mafia. I think I will vote for him. ##vote Hamilton Brian

Why is HB being voted here if I'm your only scumlean?

[foodcoats]

Brain's for sure scum.

Ghug, you’ve sort of flippantly called brain, kgray and Chaqa scum. I don’t get the impression you actually think any of them ARE scum... but you haven’t called anyone else scum, other than sheeping Vecna onto Maniac... which also strikes me as unserious.

Is there anyone you seriously think might be scum at this point?

[Bonatogether]

I agree and being careless is a towny behaviour. When I was scum, I used to reread all my messages before posting so I wouldn't scumslip. Posting careful is NAI but posting careless is town-ish.

I don't like this post because it's unnecessary and unprompted elaboration on someone else's kinda old comment. Bad vibes, really

I don't know why you think it's scummy to react to an old post. Last 2 hours passed me trying to cath up and I started from the point I left, and I reacted to every message I found worthy. You may be right about the necessity, but I guess I would be more careful if I were mafia.

You can't use the thing I said about how scum should be careful what they post to pass off an careless comment. Major scumpoints for that.

[yavuzovic]

Thinking out loud.

Small nails = Brad, is this a reference to Brad Pitt? What is Brad Pitt famous for? Thelma and Louise, Oceans 11, Friends (scum buddies) Bradgelina. Oh Bradgelina is a portmanteau as is werewolf so Small Nails is code for werewolf. OK but why use this code. Is it a crumb? It will have some significance before the game ends.

Also foodcoats isn't scum, or if he is I'm going to give up playing.

I'm sorry for being confusing. Now you're a good conspiracy theorist.
No sorry small nails have no secret meaning, neither the codes.