MAFIA 64 - The Z Files - Game Thread [HIDDEN]

[Bonatogether]

The earlier ghug wagon doesn't count,

Why?

and I've continuously explained why I believe so many of us ended up on the same wagons,

Could you go over that over again?

and you have yet to consider that you yourself were also on these wagons.

I was on the rivera wagon and none of the other 3

[brainbomb]

so I guess I better come up with my real role to claim now and stuff

[Bonatogether]

It is not accurate to characterize my scumread of HR as omgus.

How would you characterize your vote, then?

Like there was seriously no reason for town!HR to vote me like that.

HR needs to die

I didn't vote for HR because he scumread me, I voted for him because if he were town he would not have missed the things he did, and he would not have placed an end vote on me and left like that. And then he lied about me being mechanically confirmed scum. That's not omgus, that's knowing he's full of shit.

This was before the mechanical scum business. What was your reasoning at the time?

[BunnyGo]

so I guess I better come up with my real role to claim now and stuff

Please don't

[brainbomb]

For research:

http://mafia.peterlund.se/e/web/msgs

[brainbomb]

http://mafia.peterlund.se/e/web/msgs?word=HR&g=64

here we go
day 1 HR mentions

[brainbomb]

Official Voting File 1.2
Ghug (3) DemonRHK, kgray, brainbomb
kgray (3) Bunnygo, ghug
brainbomb (1) Maniac
e.m.c^42 (1) damo666
Hellenic Riot (1) Bonatogether

Not filled out the government agency form:
Bob, bozo, celaph, Donny, Einstein, Ezio, HB, HR, jasnah,Ifishchl, Macca, rdr, Vecna

Right now, the data indicates ghug’s demise.

Not Meeting Posting Requirements:
Bozo, ezio, HR, jasnah, lfischl, Vecna

A day and around 19 hours left in this time measure.

Does Bona's "$$vote hellenic brian" formally count as a vote for HR?

[Bonatogether]

Official Voting File 1.2
Ghug (3) DemonRHK, kgray, brainbomb
kgray (3) Bunnygo, ghug
brainbomb (1) Maniac
e.m.c^42 (1) damo666
Hellenic Riot (1) Bonatogether

Not filled out the government agency form:
Bob, bozo, celaph, Donny, Einstein, Ezio, HB, HR, jasnah,Ifishchl, Macca, rdr, Vecna

Right now, the data indicates ghug’s demise.

Not Meeting Posting Requirements:
Bozo, ezio, HR, jasnah, lfischl, Vecna

A day and around 19 hours left in this time measure.

Does Bona's "$$vote hellenic brian" formally count as a vote for HR?

It was a joke cause I messed them up a lot last game (and this game too)

[brainbomb]

So, I'm going to work my way down the list of players in activity order and give my thoughts before rereading.
Bunny - I townlean bunny. Bunny has seemed okay so far, nothing has really stood out

HR - I can't remember much other than there was an early interaction with ghug or someone that seemed pretty townie at the time.

Maniac - idk what maniac's brand is, I wouldn't expect it to be this. Very low activity, half of the posts were jokes, idk what to think. Slight scumlean and needs to show up more.

Vecna - null. I don't like the inactivity but he has a reason.

Ezio - null. Obviously.

[Hamilton Brian]

so I guess I better come up with my real role to claim now and stuff

Just tell us that you really love or loathe the role. I was excited for you when you said you loved it.

[brainbomb]

Is it just me or is anyone else getting confused of who's who in the people with donator stars? I feel like I just see a star and ignore the name and suddenly I've confused HR and rdr.

[BunnyGo]

http://mafia.peterlund.se/e/web/msgs?word=HR&g=64

here we go
day 1 HR mentions

First thing that jumps out at me is Celaph actually spoke about HR. It must have been some of his only posts.

[kgray]

The earlier ghug wagon doesn't count,

Why?

and I've continuously explained why I believe so many of us ended up on the same wagons,

Could you go over that over again?

and you have yet to consider that you yourself were also on these wagons.

I was on the rivera wagon and none of the other 3

The ghug wagon doesn't count because Demon's was clearly a shitpost vote and brain's was unexplained, so it wasn't a serious wagon. I think mine was the only ghug vote that was a real scumread until Donny joined.

I think that town was floundering somewhat and looking for the right daykill, and so we moved between people we were considering. And we followed each other because obviously you need more than just one person on a wagon to make it count. I don't know how to describe it more than you just get a feel for who's looking for the same thing as you. And when you already townread someone going into an EOD, that becomes a lot easier to do, you get a lot of movement and coordination. That looks scummy to you because you still think scum are trying to team up and control votes to get townies killed, but that's not really what happens.

And that's absolutely not true, you were on Bunny's wagon and celaph's wagon...

[ghug]

so I guess I better come up with my real role to claim now and stuff

Nobody thinks you're scum.

[brainbomb]

Just checking this on the cool down from my run. HR, thank you so much for doing that. It’s what I’ve been looking to do but I wasn’t sure where exactly to start. I was looking at the one hour mark, the 15 minute mark. I’ll give it a Nother read to see what conclusion you were arriving at.

And if this is scum! HR doing this, then my hats off to you, because that is a hell of a lot of fake effort.

[BunnyGo]

http://mafia.peterlund.se/e/web/msgs?word=HR&g=64

here we go
day 1 HR mentions

Next take: Donny is linking ghug and HR as scummates and pressuring HR for lack of activity. Ghug then steps in to defend.

[Hamilton Brian]

[

Can’t tell what the smirk is for.

[BunnyGo]

Is it just me or is anyone else getting confused of who's who in the people with donator stars? I feel like I just see a star and ignore the name and suddenly I've confused HR and rdr.

...
is it really that distracting?
This is from d1...

[BobMcBob]

So, I'm going to work my way down the list of players in activity order and give my thoughts before rereading.
Bunny - I townlean bunny. Bunny has seemed okay so far, nothing has really stood out

HR - I can't remember much other than there was an early interaction with ghug or someone that seemed pretty townie at the time.

Maniac - idk what maniac's brand is, I wouldn't expect it to be this. Very low activity, half of the posts were jokes, idk what to think. Slight scumlean and needs to show up more.

Vecna - null. I don't like the inactivity but he has a reason.

Ezio - null. Obviously.

[kgray]

How would you characterize your vote, then?

I didn't vote for HR because he scumread me, I voted for him because if he were town he would not have missed the things he did, and he would not have placed an end vote on me and left like that. And then he lied about me being mechanically confirmed scum. That's not omgus, that's knowing he's full of shit.

This was before the mechanical scum business. What was your reasoning at the time?

I think he was faking frustration after the almost-tie D1, he was distorting the VCA from D1, he voted for someone he said he thought was playing like his town self after shading that wagon, and his scumread of me showed he wasn't thinking about things that town!HR would think about in a way that I am not willing to further elaborate on at this time.