M61 - The Mastermind's Revenge - Game Thread - HIDDEN

[damo666]

Ok if we do your plan and Macca is found to be telling the truth and is not NKd what do we do D6?

We have no real extra info and have lost a player.

[TheMadMonarch]

Vecna, under your plan, what's to stop me from voting someone else (presuming I was scum, and online at EOD)?

[damo666]

Yeah, trying to put Macca second too dangerous.

I think we just ignore Macca and vote as we see best.

We are in a fairly hopeless situation. I say we just go for it and trust we hit scum.

[Vecna]

Vecna, under your plan, what's to stop me from voting someone else (presuming I was scum, and online at EOD)?

Matters not. 5 votes on NO KILL and its guaranteed to happen.

Scum can swap to macca, but if he's governing himself it wont do shit

[damo666]

Vecna, under your plan, what's to stop me from voting someone else (presuming I was scum, and online at EOD)?

Wouldn't make any difference. No kill still wins and we still see if your vote goes to zero or not and discover if you are telling the truth. You vote on someone else would be irrelevant but look scummy so if you are scum please go ahead lol.

[Vecna]

Vecna, under your plan, what's to stop me from voting someone else (presuming I was scum, and online at EOD)?

Scum will NK someone (reduced scumpool)
Bunny will get one more chance to prove how towny he is by tracking the NK
I will get one more chance to use my shit to try and catch liars
Doctors get more chances to be useful

Its fully possible scum do not want to risk it and just no kill in return, meaning we have free information regardless of how it works out.

The information we get on macca alone should help us a lot in narrowing down the possible combinations.

[damo666]

Ok if we do your plan and Macca is found to be telling the truth and is not NKd what do we do D6?

We have no real extra info and have lost a player.

Waiting .....

[TheMadMonarch]

Vecna, under your plan, what's to stop me from voting someone else (presuming I was scum, and online at EOD)?

Matters not. 5 votes on NO KILL and its guaranteed to happen.

Scum can swap to macca, but if they're governing themself it wont do shit

Ok, it's still seems a strange plan, but if it will get you to believe me, I'm happy to go along.

(I'm not moving off chaqa tho)

[Vecna]

You will need to vote no kill, and then you can vote chaqa tomorrow if thats what u really want

[TheMadMonarch]

In which case, why not just leave 1 (presumably Flum's) vote on me to test that I'm telling the truth?

[TheMadMonarch]

You will need to vote no kill, and then you can vote chaqa tomorrow if thats what u really want

But I can't let him slip by AGAIN!

[Vecna]

Ok if we do your plan and Macca is found to be telling the truth and is not NKd what do we do D6?

We have no real extra info and have lost a player.

Waiting .....

im surprised after you just ran all your numbers in that big post that this does not appear obvious to you

[damo666]

Vecna, under your plan, what's to stop me from voting someone else (presuming I was scum, and online at EOD)?

Scum will NK someone (reduced scumpool)
Bunny will get one more chance to prove how towny he is by tracking the NK
I will get one more chance to use my shit to try and catch liars
Doctors get more chances to be useful

Its fully possible scum do not want to risk it and just no kill in return, meaning we have free information regardless of how it works out.

The information we get on macca alone should help us a lot in narrowing down the possible combinations.

How would town Bunny know who the NK is?
If Macca is a truth teller what extra info do we have.
If scum No Kill they get 3 credit and therefore a possible crucial extra RB.

[Vecna]

after all, if macca is towncleared, it should suddenly all but confirm both bunny and Kgray as scum to you, no?

[rdrivera2005]

Vecna, under your plan, what's to stop me from voting someone else (presuming I was scum, and online at EOD)?

Scum will NK someone (reduced scumpool)
Bunny will get one more chance to prove how towny he is by tracking the NK
I will get one more chance to use my shit to try and catch liars
Doctors get more chances to be useful

Its fully possible scum do not want to risk it and just no kill in return, meaning we have free information regardless of how it works out.

The information we get on macca alone should help us a lot in narrowing down the possible combinations.

And tomorrow we will be in kilo and having to count on Flum vote that we don't even are sure is following the thread. I think our chances are really low, but don't see how your plan improves them.

[damo666]

How about Flum votes Macca solo thus we get info . Active players free vote.

[Vecna]

man i hate how people are all so chickenshit and hiding their online status these days

[rdrivera2005]

after all, if macca is towncleared, it should suddenly all but confirm both bunny and Kgray as scum to you, no?

And how you townclear Macca. I don't see why they telling the truth equals a townclear.
Scum don't need saving themselves they just need a single miskill so even if they are telling the truth this don't townclear them.

[damo666]

after all, if macca is towncleared, it should suddenly all but confirm both bunny and Kgray as scum to you, no?

Macca cannot be towncleared.

[Vecna]

Vecna, under your plan, what's to stop me from voting someone else (presuming I was scum, and online at EOD)?

Scum will NK someone (reduced scumpool)
Bunny will get one more chance to prove how towny he is by tracking the NK
I will get one more chance to use my shit to try and catch liars
Doctors get more chances to be useful

Its fully possible scum do not want to risk it and just no kill in return, meaning we have free information regardless of how it works out.

The information we get on macca alone should help us a lot in narrowing down the possible combinations.

And tomorrow we will be in kilo and having to count on Flum vote that we don't even are sure is following the thread. I think our chances are really low, but don't see how your plan improves them.

this is the case regardless for the next 4 days