M60 - Duck Season? (Director's Cut) - Game Thread

[seth24c]

He didn't do much to get townread D1, he flipped PR, and I imagine they knew the doctor and jailer were accounted for, so I imagine they killed him because they had reason to suspect he was a PR.

I’m not following sorry.

Which part?

How did they have the jailer accounted for? Are you saying they knew the jailer was jailing chaqa?

[Durga]

What part of Tom using the gun made him clearly town?

Scum wouldn’t be announcing that they have a gun and giving town the vca chance of them choosing to shoot the top wagon. Too much attention so that made him pretty clearly town.

Why wouldn't they? Scum holstering the gun while the person who gave it to them was alive is basically yelling to the Item Giver that they're scum

Demonrhk hid gun once like that and that's how I caught him

[seth24c]

What part of Tom using the gun made him clearly town?

Scum wouldn’t be announcing that they have a gun and giving town the vca chance of them choosing to shoot the top wagon. Too much attention so that made him pretty clearly town.

Why wouldn't they? Scum holstering the gun while the person who gave it to them was alive is basically yelling to the Item Giver that they're scum

Well for one thing I have no idea when Tom got the item so how would I know if he was holstering it lol

[Hellenic Riot]

Scum wouldn’t be announcing that they have a gun and giving town the vca chance of them choosing to shoot the top wagon. Too much attention so that made him pretty clearly town.

Why wouldn't they? Scum holstering the gun while the person who gave it to them was alive is basically yelling to the Item Giver that they're scum

Well for one thing I have no idea when Tom got the item so how would I know if he was holstering it lol

No, but the person who gave it to him would know...

[kgray]

The point is that you're so good at replicating a town game as scum that no one can find a reason to scum read you. I know that's not a good reason, but I'm not gonna not entertain that this could be a thing.

Yeah I'm not asking you to not entertain it. I'm a little skeptical of people implying I could be scum just because I was good at it in other games, but some amount of paranoia is probably town indicative.

Who's your top townread and your top scumread?

Frankly, I don't have a top for either. I felt like HR, Seth, and Donny were all pretty townie. I don't like how HR has been tunnelling, but I think I'm just being paranoid, I don't know. I'm not gonna vote for those three today at least.

I think you're a straight null for me at this point. But a wagon on you would be kinda fun, I'd like to see that actually. Have you ever even been voted ever?

I thought bozo was townie but less so now because he won't stfu about Seth and its dumb. Scum is probably between bozo, nook, ghug, flum, Maniac, emc and maaaaybe you. But frankly I haven't done much thinking on how it'd all work together. And I'm going back and forth on flum and maniac. I don't think they're both scum together at least.

Anyway those are my current thoughts.

Why do you think Donny has been towny?

I think the only person to have voted me in this game is Moscow. My first game I was a tied wagon in mylo (with damo, who was also town) and then I was the kylo miskill. After that I think it's just been a random vote here and there, never a real wagon.

Do you not think bozo getting caught up on something like seth's D1 is town!bozo? I can't figure out if it's normal for him to be this stubborn about it because he's usually adamant about his scumreads, or if he's being sort of lazy/cautious by not picking a new target.

[Jamiet99uk]

GM update:

Vote is tied as per last count.

EMC and Durga must vote.

1 hour and 18 minutes left.

[seth24c]

One hour and we’ve got 4 people with two votes on them.

[seth24c]

Oh sorry 3 people. And 3 single wagons.

[Durga]

Yeah I'm not asking you to not entertain it. I'm a little skeptical of people implying I could be scum just because I was good at it in other games, but some amount of paranoia is probably town indicative.

Who's your top townread and your top scumread?

Frankly, I don't have a top for either. I felt like HR, Seth, and Donny were all pretty townie. I don't like how HR has been tunnelling, but I think I'm just being paranoid, I don't know. I'm not gonna vote for those three today at least.

I think you're a straight null for me at this point. But a wagon on you would be kinda fun, I'd like to see that actually. Have you ever even been voted ever?

I thought bozo was townie but less so now because he won't stfu about Seth and its dumb. Scum is probably between bozo, nook, ghug, flum, Maniac, emc and maaaaybe you. But frankly I haven't done much thinking on how it'd all work together. And I'm going back and forth on flum and maniac. I don't think they're both scum together at least.

Anyway those are my current thoughts.

Why do you think Donny has been towny?

I think the only person to have voted me in this game is Moscow. My first game I was a tied wagon in mylo (with damo, who was also town) and then I was the kylo miskill. After that I think it's just been a random vote here and there, never a real wagon.

Do you not think bozo getting caught up on something like seth's D1 is town!bozo? I can't figure out if it's normal for him to be this stubborn about it because he's usually adamant about his scumreads, or if he's being sort of lazy/cautious by not picking a new target.

Donny feels like he's actually questioning people and also pretty laid back about being voted. Nothing to indicate that he might be scum imo.

Ah okay, yeah, well, I'm not gonna vote you anyway. Not today. But I'd like to see how you'd react under pressure.

Also, maybe a good point on Bozo actually. I can't remember what he usually does either. I can definitely see him being so convinced at his one truth that he can't get past it as town.

[Fluminator]

Wow only an hour. Driving to Sask rn but chevking in.
I'm back to ##vote Bozo but I'm really confused by Donny.

[Durga]

##vote flum why did you get me to sign up for survivor? Was this a scum ploy so I ignore you all game?

[kgray]

One hour and we’ve got 4 people with two votes on them.

Sadly I am unable to consolidate my vote, as Maniac has now read the thread several times (and even posted some) without answering the explicit question that I've asked him over and over.

Also I think he should be our kill, so there's that.

[Durga]

@flum don't text and drive, but also, why did you go from voting Donny to voting with Donny.

[Fluminator]

Survivor best game

[seth24c]

One hour and we’ve got 4 people with two votes on them.

Sadly I am unable to consolidate my vote, as Maniac has now read the thread several times (and even posted some) without answering the explicit question that I've asked him over and over.

Also I think he should be our kill, so there's that.

I agree, I strongly believe he is our best chance to hit scum.

[ghug]

I’m not following sorry.

Which part?

How did they have the jailer accounted for? Are you saying they knew the jailer was jailing chaqa?

Go look at the bot for Night 1.

It came out pretty quickly D2 because it was obvious to everyone who'd actually read the setup, so it's pretty much impossible scum didn't know.

[Fluminator]

I don't know Durga. Donny confuses me but bozo is my biggest scumread in isolation. I'm not sold on a Maniac or Moscow kill right now.

[bozotheclown]

Does anyone think there's a chance kgray saw she rolled scum with summit again and decided he was a lost cause and just bussed hard? Or is this me being paranoid? Literally no one even suggested she might have been scum last time and now I'm getting worried because if there's an incredible deep threat it's her

I considered this because kgray bussed damo in M1011 in a way that would be similar, and I have seen very few cases of scum willing to bus that way D1.

[Donny Dude]

Also Donny, why haven't you opened up for your fireside therapy with Dr Riot? Even the most globally celebrated of mafia players utilise a therapist - This is your opportunity to further your standing and share your feelings on the Fluminator Conundrum

How do I opt in? Are there forms?
To answer.
I guess not.

[Durga]

I love having 5 wagons with 2 ppl each. Fucking solid work team...