M60 - Duck Season? (Director's Cut) - Game Thread

[seth24c]

I don't think MF's absence is scum indicative.

Neither do I - I think his actual play is.

Beside MF's D1 vote for summit, he seems to be the only one to agree with me that seth was protecting summit D1, so I think he is likely town.

How does that make him town? I think it makes him more likely to be scum and he is my second highest preference for today’s flip after maniac.

[bozotheclown]

Neither do I - I think his actual play is.

Beside MF's D1 vote for summit, he seems to be the only one to agree with me that seth was protecting summit D1, so I think he is likely town.

How does that make him town? I think it makes him more likely to be scum and he is my second highest preference for today’s flip after maniac.

I would not expect you to agree with MF.

[ghug]

I'm bored ##VOTE Moscow

[bozotheclown]

What about that period where he seemed to forget he thought Seth was scum, before a post of yours reminded him?

Did he ever town read seth during that time?

No, but he went from being 'dead certain' seth was scum to ignoring him entirely.

He did address this when he responded to you in his 1 post today.

[seth24c]

Beside MF's D1 vote for summit, he seems to be the only one to agree with me that seth was protecting summit D1, so I think he is likely town.

How does that make him town? I think it makes him more likely to be scum and he is my second highest preference for today’s flip after maniac.

I would not expect you to agree with MF.

If you are town you are going to be so disappointed when you succeed in getting me flipped.

[bozotheclown]

I have to leave, I should be back before EOD.

[kgray]

I'm not into a Seth wagon. I could vote Moscow, but I'd probably stay on one of Flum and flash if Flum involved himself.

Maniac's behavior is scummy, but I think others are right to say that summit was less likely to claim up against a teammate, which limits him to traitor or 3P.

Hey, we disagree on something!

I'm not voting for Flum today. I'd be alright with Moscow too, and I don't mind seeing flash flip even though I'm not totally convinced he's scum and not just stubborn town.

I'll join bozo on ##vote seth for now.

This seems like an opportunistic play. I don’t believe that you find bozo’s case against me compelling enough to just sheep it.

It's not just bozo's case. You were one of the most suspicious people to me based on D1 voting, and you being a counter wagon to two town wagons on D2 means that knowing your alignment would tell us a lot.

I admit that I thought you were being pretty towny on D4 in terms of tone, but I'm not sure I trust those reads at this point given I was so wrong about Vecna. It also seems like you haven't been very active today, like you were satisfied that a lot of the pressure on you had faded.

Honestly I'd probably prefer Maniac, but it's a bit riskier because I think he's the traitor, and I can't get over this suspicion I have about Donny, but he apparently isn't an option today.

[kgray]

I'm bored ##VOTE Moscow

Flum's gonna be crushed you left him

[Fluminator]

Hey, we disagree on something!

I'm not voting for Flum today. I'd be alright with Moscow too, and I don't mind seeing flash flip even though I'm not totally convinced he's scum and not just stubborn town.

I'll join bozo on ##vote seth for now.

This seems like an opportunistic play. I don’t believe that you find bozo’s case against me compelling enough to just sheep it.

It's not just bozo's case. You were one of the most suspicious people to me based on D1 voting, and you being a counter wagon to two town wagons on D2 means that knowing your alignment would tell us a lot.

I admit that I thought you were being pretty towny on D4 in terms of tone, but I'm not sure I trust those reads at this point given I was so wrong about Vecna. It also seems like you haven't been very active today, like you were satisfied that a lot of the pressure on you had faded.

Honestly I'd probably prefer Maniac, but it's a bit riskier because I think he's the traitor, and I can't get over this suspicion I have about Donny, but he apparently isn't an option today.

Didn't you say you didn't think summit would fakeclaim if maniac was scum or am I misremembering?

[Fluminator]

I'm bored ##VOTE Moscow

Flum's gonna be crushed you left him

I called him a hoe for a reason

[kgray]

This seems like an opportunistic play. I don’t believe that you find bozo’s case against me compelling enough to just sheep it.

It's not just bozo's case. You were one of the most suspicious people to me based on D1 voting, and you being a counter wagon to two town wagons on D2 means that knowing your alignment would tell us a lot.

I admit that I thought you were being pretty towny on D4 in terms of tone, but I'm not sure I trust those reads at this point given I was so wrong about Vecna. It also seems like you haven't been very active today, like you were satisfied that a lot of the pressure on you had faded.

Honestly I'd probably prefer Maniac, but it's a bit riskier because I think he's the traitor, and I can't get over this suspicion I have about Donny, but he apparently isn't an option today.

Didn't you say you didn't think summit would fakeclaim if maniac was scum or am I misremembering?

Yeah, that's why I think he's probably the traitor.

[ghug]

I'm bored ##VOTE Moscow

Flum's gonna be crushed you left him

I called him a hoe for a reason

Well you're a rake

[ghug]

@Seth, you scumread Flum, tight? I'll move back if you do.

[seth24c]

Hey, we disagree on something!

I'm not voting for Flum today. I'd be alright with Moscow too, and I don't mind seeing flash flip even though I'm not totally convinced he's scum and not just stubborn town.

I'll join bozo on ##vote seth for now.

This seems like an opportunistic play. I don’t believe that you find bozo’s case against me compelling enough to just sheep it.

It's not just bozo's case. You were one of the most suspicious people to me based on D1 voting, and you being a counter wagon to two town wagons on D2 means that knowing your alignment would tell us a lot.

I admit that I thought you were being pretty towny on D4 in terms of tone, but I'm not sure I trust those reads at this point given I was so wrong about Vecna. It also seems like you haven't been very active today, like you were satisfied that a lot of the pressure on you had faded.

Honestly I'd probably prefer Maniac, but it's a bit riskier because I think he's the traitor, and I can't get over this suspicion I have about Donny, but he apparently isn't an option today.

So now you are just not going to trust your reads at all because you were wrong on vecna? Seems like a great way to not take responsibility for the votes you place, feels scum motivated. I haven’t been very active because it was the weekend and then a busy day at work, have to head to another extra shift in 10 minutes. Like I said, even this post feels opportunistic. We’ve had town v town wagons (with the possible exception of yesterday, idk about flash) since day 1 because everyone is content to keep looking at day 1 vca even though maniac has been extremely scummy this entire game and so the scum team is able to stay completely hidden.

[seth24c]

@Seth, you scumread Flum, tight? I'll move back if you do.

I prefer Moscow fleet. I have a theory where flum could be scum but I and null on him outside of that specific theory. I do think moscow is scum and will likely vote him before I have to sign off of maniac isn’t happening.

[bo_sox48]

##GM NOTE

Please do not +1 other players' posts.

[ghug]

Seth/Flum scumteam confirmed.

[bo_sox48]

VOTE COUNT 5.7

flash2015 (4) - Fluminator, Nanook, Donny Dude, Durga
Fluminator (2) - flash2015, worcej
MoscowFleet (2) - Hellenic Riot, ghug
seth24c (2) - bozotheclown, kgray
ghug (1) - Maniac
Maniac (1) - seth24c

MoscowFleet must vote.

FLASH2015 is set to be sandblasted.

Day 5 has ~40 minutes remaining.

[Donny Dude]

Seth/Flum scumteam confirmed.

What is your read on seth?

[ghug]

##GM NOTE

Please do not +1 other players' posts.

Stray thumb, sorry.


For the record, it was Bozo's post last page about MF's absence not being scum indicative.