M60 - Duck Season? (Director's Cut) - Game Thread

[Tom Bombadil]

In meetings for a while. Will be back on in a little less than 4 hours to shoot someone. Carry on

[seth24c]

##vote nook

Now that you have more than two votes on you, how about figuring out the game?

Idk dude this game is weird.

I think damo/you/ghug probably town. Flash probably town imo. Seth probably Mafia. Gray probably town.


I dunno how anyone looks at the way summit treated me and goes “YES THEYRE PARTNERS” tbh

So throughout this whole game your only two scumreads have been me and maniac after I pushed maniac’s wagon so hard day 1 and was the one who made the point that initially caused you to be suspicious of maniac?

[Nanook]

https://webdiplomacy.net/contrib/phpBB3 ... 80#p177737

This isn’t directly related but another reason that damo isn’t team mafia with summit, I would bet substantially that this is an attempted soft to someone he thinks might be lost mafia

[Nanook]

##vote nook

Now that you have more than two votes on you, how about figuring out the game?

Idk dude this game is weird.

I think damo/you/ghug probably town. Flash probably town imo. Seth probably Mafia. Gray probably town.


I dunno how anyone looks at the way summit treated me and goes “YES THEYRE PARTNERS” tbh

So throughout this whole game your only two scumreads have been me and maniac after I pushed maniac’s wagon so hard day 1 and was the one who made the point that initially caused you to be suspicious of maniac?

I also thought Bunny was scum!

[seth24c]

##Vote Maniac

I uh totally forgot there was a lost wolf in this game, lost wolves tend to signal to their partners, Seth is spot on kudos to him

[kgray]

##vote nook

Now that you have more than two votes on you, how about figuring out the game?

Idk dude this game is weird.

I think damo/you/ghug probably town. Flash probably town imo. Seth probably Mafia. Gray probably town.


I dunno how anyone looks at the way summit treated me and goes “YES THEYRE PARTNERS” tbh

So throughout this whole game your only two scumreads have been me and maniac after I pushed maniac’s wagon so hard day 1 and was the one who made the point that initially caused you to be suspicious of maniac?

Okay I think seth is town.

[seth24c]

Idk dude this game is weird.

I think damo/you/ghug probably town. Flash probably town imo. Seth probably Mafia. Gray probably town.


I dunno how anyone looks at the way summit treated me and goes “YES THEYRE PARTNERS” tbh

So throughout this whole game your only two scumreads have been me and maniac after I pushed maniac’s wagon so hard day 1 and was the one who made the point that initially caused you to be suspicious of maniac?

I also thought Bunny was scum!

Well everyone did day 3 but you still didn’t push him day 2 and you voted for me for a short period day 3 as well.

[Fluminator]

Moscow I s2g if you disappear without posting again

[Nanook]

https://webdiplomacy.net/contrib/phpBB3 ... 80#p177741

Then he catches a bit of flak for the question, and this is his next post responding to me

https://webdiplomacy.net/contrib/phpBB3 ... 00#p178083


How the hell is that ever a partner interaction

[Nanook]

##Vote Maniac

I uh totally forgot there was a lost wolf in this game, lost wolves tend to signal to their partners, Seth is spot on kudos to him

What’s your point? I thought you were town at the time, now I don’t.

[kgray]

Idk dude this game is weird.

I think damo/you/ghug probably town. Flash probably town imo. Seth probably Mafia. Gray probably town.


I dunno how anyone looks at the way summit treated me and goes “YES THEYRE PARTNERS” tbh

Remind me how he treated you?

Meh at first then “this guy is town af” when he thought he could pocket me

Personally I don't think summit calling you town af is that great of an argument for town!nanook considering how awkward that post of summit's was.

[Nanook]

Oh no I have two votes on me. Whatsoever will I do.

Another thing that I really don't like. It's pretty late for shitposting and this just feels like scum trying to emphasize that they're not afraid of being a wagon.

I don’t stop making jokes and trying to keep things light just cause D1 ended lol

[Nanook]

I mean that just isn’t a partner interaction, you don’t go from “I’m gonna throw some sus on nanook” to “nanook is town af” after a meme response from nanook, that’s insane

[Vecna]

Remind me how he treated you?

Meh at first then “this guy is town af” when he thought he could pocket me

Personally I don't think summit calling you town af is that great of an argument for town!nanook considering how awkward that post of summit's was.

also, traitor/3p

[MoscowFleet]

Okay, finally fully caught up and here to actively play. Like, actually.

Rereading EOD and trying to analyze a bit, I find it hard to believe damo isn't being widely scumread. He made zero mention of finding Maniac scummy in any way on day 1 and had Maniac as the 6th most town on his reads list pg 47, yet he voted for him in a very suspicious spot. Let's take a look.

On pg 60:

I'm getting towny vibes from Chaqa.

I'm not scum so all aboard summit please.

So okay. At this point he's pretty gung-ho about just killing summit, but this doesn't mean much as it's to save his own bacon with the vote count at 7 summit-5 damo and nobody else really viable at this moment. Now pg 62 at 6-6:

Two hours to go and it's 6-6 with summit not voting me. This is bad.

I'm not totally convinced summit is scum. I really hope another wagon develops.

If I do get dk'd look at my voters carefully. I suspect worcej and ghug are just misguided. Of the others TrPrado's vote looks very opportunistic to me, seth and MF are meh, Vecna I'm becoming suspicious about. He is not normally this quiet.

Now we see him waffling a bit on summit. Also odd where he says to look at his voters, but only really singles out 2 of them as scummy, one of them a dead townie. Also as damo mentions here, summit never voted for damo even with damo being the second wagon, which is pretty sus on its own.

Now the interesting thing here is that over the next few pages, Nanook was becoming very viable with 4 voters. So at one point it's 6 summit-4 nanook-3 damo, with damo losing steam and Nanook gaining. Yet summit never voted Nanook, and neither did damo. Instead the counterwagon that summit and damo both jumped to was Maniac - summit we know is scum, and damo listed summit as one his strongest scumreads and Maniac as a townread, so it's extremely suspicious. I've also noticed that damo usually almost responds to questions directed at him, even if it's benign one-word answers. The one question that he rather ominously ignored was bunny asking damo why he voted for Maniac.

So yeah. I could go on, but basically damo's Maniac vote, along with the fact that summit didn't want to vote for damo but jumped at Maniac, makes me feel pretty good about damo being scum and Maniac being town, or maybe 3p I guess. So let's get Tom to shoot him. ##Vote damo.

And if we assume damo is scum for a sec, then Nanook also comes out of it looking pretty sus as someone who both scum could've switched to but opted not to.

[flash2015]

Nanook, Flash and Maniac all feel like excellent gunshots right about now

I don't mind if you take me out.

[kgray]

Meh at first then “this guy is town af” when he thought he could pocket me

Personally I don't think summit calling you town af is that great of an argument for town!nanook considering how awkward that post of summit's was.

also, traitor/3p

You seem to be justifying a lot of scumreads based on the fact that they could be the traitor/3p. That doesn't seem like the best way to scumhunt to me.

[MoscowFleet]

Moscow I s2g if you disappear without posting again

I'm here for you<3

[MoscowFleet]

Also, Flash would need balls of steel to park on his teammate all day and do nothing at all as he gets lined up for the lynch, even with multiple viable counterwagons popping up. I don't think it's him.

[Fluminator]

Nanook, Flash and Maniac all feel like excellent gunshots right about now

I don't mind if you take me out.

why do you play these games