M60 - Duck Season? (Director's Cut) - Game Thread

[BunnyGo]

This is soooo wrong as to be creepy.

No it isn’t. If jailer does NOT protect from the riddler there is zero reason for Chaqa to be alive. If that’s the case then either the riddler is unable to achieve win condition OR if we have the freelancer then it is bad for town to look for 3P. Freelancer is effectively a miskill since their win condition doesn’t contradict ours.

The riddler must identify the exact role, so they would only have had a 1/3 chance of killing Chaqa, which is one reason why it was a good idea for Chaqa to crumb and claim the way he did.

Ah...very clever.

Oh. Scum can’t safely eliminate our good PRs if the riddler is around. It puts them at risk of a bloody night.

[bozotheclown]

I'm not sure.... But I don't like his wishy-washy statement about if anyone on the scumteam knew Chaqa was in jail. There's no way they didn't realize that.

A lot of us claimed to have overlooked it. Are we lying or town slipping then?

It seems weirder to overlook it if you were in the first attempt at the game. It's also a very easily fakeable townslip, to the point that I probably would have claimed ignorance as either alignment if I had known.

If you had known what?

[BunnyGo]

A lot of us claimed to have overlooked it. Are we lying or town slipping then?

It seems weirder to overlook it if you were in the first attempt at the game. It's also a very easily fakeable townslip, to the point that I probably would have claimed ignorance as either alignment if I had known.

If you had known what?

Chaqa was jailed.

[ghug]

Fact 4: If the riddler guesses wrong on anybody at any point they lose their killing powers for the rest of the game

Fact 5: The toddler doesn't have to kill every night.
Fact 6: We don't know Chaqa's exact role.

Re 6. So?

Prado thinks the toddler tried to kill Chaqa last night, which there's no reason for it to have done without better info.

[ghug]

A lot of us claimed to have overlooked it. Are we lying or town slipping then?

It seems weirder to overlook it if you were in the first attempt at the game. It's also a very easily fakeable townslip, to the point that I probably would have claimed ignorance as either alignment if I had known.

If you had known what?

That Chaqa was jailed.

[Chaqa]

@Chaqa please be careful not to reveal Jailer (unless they're in mortal danger of course). We already now know it's not TrPrado. This does not matter if TrPrado is scum but helps scum if he's not.

Don’t worry, the Jailer and I had extensive discussions on when/if to reveal his identity, there’s no need to worry about me screwing it up lol

I assume 'his' is catchall

Damo trying to bait or signal his scummates?

[TrPrado]

Don’t worry, the Jailer and I had extensive discussions on when/if to reveal his identity, there’s no need to worry about me screwing it up lol

I assume 'his' is catchall

Damo trying to bait or signal his scummates?

(I took it as damo making sure you didn't just eliminate 2 more people from being jailer)

[bozotheclown]

It seems weirder to overlook it if you were in the first attempt at the game. It's also a very easily fakeable townslip, to the point that I probably would have claimed ignorance as either alignment if I had known.

If you had known what?

That Chaqa was jailed.

So does that mean you did not realize he was jailed?

[damo666]

Fact 5: The toddler doesn't have to kill every night.
Fact 6: We don't know Chaqa's exact role.

Re 6. So?

Prado thinks the toddler tried to kill Chaqa last night, which there's no reason for it to have done without better info.

I hadn't realised 'exact' was a requirement. Nw

[damo666]

I assume 'his' is catchall

Damo trying to bait or signal his scummates?

(I took it as damo making sure you didn't just eliminate 2 more people from being jailer)

This.

[BunnyGo]

Hey, Vecna. Why you vote Prado?

[Chaqa]

##CallGM: Does the Riddler have to visit their target(s) to kill them?

[Chaqa]

Fact 4: If the riddler guesses wrong on anybody at any point they lose their killing powers for the rest of the game

Fact 5: The toddler doesn't have to kill every night.
Fact 6: We don't know Chaqa's exact role.

Re 6. So?

Fake dumbslip.

Starting to get sus of Damo.

[Chaqa]

This is soooo wrong as to be creepy.

No it isn’t. If jailer does NOT protect from the riddler there is zero reason for Chaqa to be alive. If that’s the case then either the riddler is unable to achieve win condition OR if we have the freelancer then it is bad for town to look for 3P. Freelancer is effectively a miskill since their win condition doesn’t contradict ours.

The riddler must identify the exact role, so they would only have had a 1/3 chance of killing Chaqa, which is one reason why it was a good idea for Chaqa to crumb and claim the way he did.

Bozo saying I made a good play seems pretty sus (this is a joke)

[BunnyGo]

Fact 5: The toddler doesn't have to kill every night.
Fact 6: We don't know Chaqa's exact role.

Re 6. So?

Fake dumbslip.

Starting to get sus of Damo.

The most suspicious vote thing he did was move off summit to tie the vote. Then “innocently” proclaim anyone tying the vote after that was scummy. Gave a chance for next voter to jump on Maniac and then “oops...can’t tie vote again”

[damo666]

Fact 5: The toddler doesn't have to kill every night.
Fact 6: We don't know Chaqa's exact role.

Re 6. So?

Fake dumbslip.

Starting to get sus of Damo.

Not fake. Just dumb.

[Chaqa]

I assume 'his' is catchall

Damo trying to bait or signal his scummates?

(I took it as damo making sure you didn't just eliminate 2 more people from being jailer)

If this was the case he'd want to not say anything.

[Chaqa]

Going to go do a deep dive into Day 1 VCA.

[BunnyGo]

Going to go do a deep dive into Day 1 VCA.

https://vimeo.com/163780065

[damo666]

Damo trying to bait or signal his scummates?

(I took it as damo making sure you didn't just eliminate 2 more people from being jailer)

If this was the case he'd want to not say anything.

I'm trying to impress on you to refrain from making slips that narrow down the jailer pool you great nit. I'd be happy to wager large jailer is not durga nor kgray and now scum know it. Think before posting.