M60 - Duck Season? (Director's Cut) - Game Thread

[Chaqa]

I do think it's especially sus that RIVERA would say excuse-Chaqa is scum-Chaqa, when he has played several games with me that would go against that.

Durga hasn't been around as much since I came back, so more benefit of the doubt there.

That said, I do give a lot of excuses regardless of alignment.

I didn't vote you, did I? But I really think you give more detailed excuses when you were scum. I remember last game when your date had a problem so you can be at EOD (and got daykilled) and another one that involves a soccer game and both times you were scum.

And Among us really sucks, my daughter plays it....

And I very nearly quit playing mafia because I legitimately did come back when my date had a car issue and was running late. We had a very lovely time that evening.

And the soccer game is probably true as well, though I don't remember the instance. I never make up my "excuses"

[kgray]

I don't really follow the summit case, or the end votes. Is this just Day 1 memes still?

What don’t you understand about it. It’s like the simplest case of all time? You can agree or disagree with it, but I find it hard to believe if you genuinely looked you would be confused by it...

I meant that it didn't make sense to me, in that it doesn't hold water.

I'm voting summit because when we were scumbuddies in M1015 he was incredibly hesitant to post in the main thread and was overall really uncomfortable. In the first version of this game he was town and was the opposite - freely posting and coming off as natural and not awkward. Here he seems back to being careful and hiding, so I think it's scum indicative.

[Chaqa]

Chaqa, What is your take on revealing the 9 lives role now?

Well, if the 3P is the Freelancer, it's a bad idea unless we have a Doctor or someone who could catch the Freelancer somehow. If the 3P is Marvin, I think it's a good idea.

So...

Probably wait a bit. As I said, it doesn't have to done right now, but I still think it's a good play at some point once we have more information.

What does this post mean? You think it's a bad idea for the RR to reveal if there's not a 3p that kills by guessing people's roles? But if there is that role, then RR should claim? I don't follow this at all.

And both 3p roles are named Marvin.

Not sure how you took the exact opposite meaning of my post. It isn't that confusing.

Though I didn't realize both 3P were named Marvin.

[Chaqa]

What don’t you understand about it. It’s like the simplest case of all time? You can agree or disagree with it, but I find it hard to believe if you genuinely looked you would be confused by it...

I meant that it didn't make sense to me, in that it doesn't hold water.

I'm voting summit because when we were scumbuddies in M1015 he was incredibly hesitant to post in the main thread and was overall really uncomfortable. In the first version of this game he was town and was the opposite - freely posting and coming off as natural and not awkward. Here he seems back to being careful and hiding, so I think it's scum indicative.

Hmm. Let me go back and review that game and the M59 thread as well.

[kgray]

Well, if the 3P is the Freelancer, it's a bad idea unless we have a Doctor or someone who could catch the Freelancer somehow. If the 3P is Marvin, I think it's a good idea.

So...

Probably wait a bit. As I said, it doesn't have to done right now, but I still think it's a good play at some point once we have more information.

What does this post mean? You think it's a bad idea for the RR to reveal if there's not a 3p that kills by guessing people's roles? But if there is that role, then RR should claim? I don't follow this at all.

And both 3p roles are named Marvin.

Not sure how you took the exact opposite meaning of my post. It isn't that confusing.

Though I didn't realize both 3P were named Marvin.

No, it was pretty confusing.

There are 2 possible 3p roles: Freelancer and Riddler. The Riddler is the one who kills by guessing roles. You said it's a bad idea for RR to claim if we have the Freelancer in play unless we have a Doc or someone who can catch them. Then you said you think it's a good idea for RR to claim if Marvin is in play, and presumably you meant Marvin = Riddler.

[Chaqa]

Oh, I just suck at reading.

I thought the one who does the guessing is the Freelancer, and that the other one was Marvin the Martian. I got all confused.

[BunnyGo]

Oh, I just suck at reading.

I thought the one who does the guessing is the Freelancer, and that the other one was Marvin the Martian. I got all confused.

That’s cool. Let’s move on. You don’t care about getting any analysis. You just want the town clear today as opposed to eventually.

[summit_fever]

Put it off until tomorrow Bunny

Are you feeling tired and emotional?

No. Why?

I believe it was projection on my part.

[kgray]

Oh, I just suck at reading.

I thought the one who does the guessing is the Freelancer, and that the other one was Marvin the Martian. I got all confused.

That’s cool. Let’s move on. You don’t care about getting any analysis. You just want the town clear today as opposed to eventually.

Yeah I think this is a terrible suggestion too. The suggestion itself is kinda scummy. Do you think scum!Chaqa is likely to push it?

Also do you still not understand the summit wagon?

[kgray]

Are you feeling tired and emotional?

No. Why?

I believe it was projection on my part.

Oh hi summit. Are you feeling tired and emotional?

[Chaqa]

Oh, I just suck at reading.

I thought the one who does the guessing is the Freelancer, and that the other one was Marvin the Martian. I got all confused.

That’s cool. Let’s move on. You don’t care about getting any analysis. You just want the town clear today as opposed to eventually.

No? Did no one read my post?

Okay, I gave the setup a good readthrough, and am I crazy or doesn't it make sense for the Road Runner to claim? Maybe not right now, but eventually/early?

^^^^

[summit_fever]

I’m around for a bit.

What’s up doc

Have you read the thread?

There’s a thread?????

[this is where I’d normally post my “reading is for idiots who can’t understand pictures” meme but apparently I can’t post images here, which is a big ???]

Is there a reason you weren't concerned about this in your first game here?

[Chaqa]

I must not use the English language or explain my thoughts the same way as everyone else, because these sorts of confusions are WAY TOO COMMON in my life.

[Nanook]

Have you read the thread?

There’s a thread?????

[this is where I’d normally post my “reading is for idiots who can’t understand pictures” meme but apparently I can’t post images here, which is a big ???]

Is there a reason you weren't concerned about this in your first game here?

Yeh I was town so I was more focused whereas now I’m scum so I just wanna have a good time

[Durga]

Have you read the thread?

There’s a thread?????

[this is where I’d normally post my “reading is for idiots who can’t understand pictures” meme but apparently I can’t post images here, which is a big ???]

Is there a reason you weren't concerned about this in your first game here?

Why is this a question?

[MoscowFleet]

I'm back. Still a pretty boring game. You guys spent 10 pages arguing whether a PR should claim, yeesh.

Ghug is right that Vecna isn't doing Vecna things, but he'll show up soon and tell us he was busy so no point in pushing him now.

[MoscowFleet]

What exactly happened there?

Bo gave the wrong VT PM to people so a couple players were able to townclear themselves by pointing out the flaw.

scum were DOA anyways. 3 dead by EOD2 and 1 more highly suspect. Only Flum to go.

Hey, we were making a comeback.

[MoscowFleet]

I'm getting bad vibes from nanook, his behaviour is so exaggerated in the whole posting-pics convo.

Tom's recent posts strike me as pretty towny.

[bo_sox48]

VOTE COUNT 1.3

summit_fever (4) - Fluminator*, flash2015, MoscowFleet, kgray
Donny Dude (3) - BunnyGo*, damo666, Tom Bombadil
Maniac (3) - bozotheclown, rdrivera2005, seth24c
Chaqa (2) - Nanook, Durga
Fluminator (1) - Maniac
ghug (1) - TrPrado
Vecna (1) - ghug
Hellenic Riot (1) - Donny Dude

* - END: 1/11 (summit_fever), 1/11 (Donny Dude)

Chaqa, summit_fever, Vecna, worcej, and Hellenic Riot must vote.

SUMMIT_FEVER is scheduled to be taken off the air.

You have 26 hours and 35 minutes left in Day 1.

[summit_fever]

I am a bit sus of Tom's entrance.
He's pretending his scum game is terrible so if he is a modicum of useful everyone will townread him.

Bunnygo's heart doesn't seem quite as with it as last game yet but it could be d1 fatigue considering we just had one.

BunnyGo meta change could also be bc he was so excited to be pr with a guilty scan last game. I noticed he was different last game than the other game I played with him when he was town.

He didn't have a guilty scan until D2 though. That doesn't explain anything about his D1.

I figured Bunny was frustrated with being murdered day 1 in M58.