I do not think you would "think Jamie knows more about the BP " as scum, but I think you might misrepresent it as scum.bo_sox48 wrote: ↑Wed Aug 26, 2020 11:16 pmAnd then bozo leaves. Cool.
Riddle me this, bozo - why do you think that I as scum would think Jamie knows more about the BP than I do? If I am scum, I don't think Jamie knows more about the BP than I do because he is either my teammate and knows the same as me or town and knows less than me, OR he is actually the BP himself and does not know if the mafia team hit him, but I would, and therefore we now know also knows less than me.
The only thing that makes sense to me in the context of Jamie knowing more about the BP than I do and me trying to pry information out of him is if I am town and I scumread Jamie. That seems plausible, and in fact I am town and I do scumread Jamie. But you're voting for me, and usually votes are reserved for people that we haven't logically deduced are town.
What I found suspicious is that Jamie just said there was no mafia kill, but you asked him if we know there was no attempt at a kill, when Jamie did not say anything about there being no attempt, and the idea that the mafia would not attempt a kill did not seem like a reasonable possibility.bo_sox48 wrote: ↑Wed Aug 26, 2020 10:21 pmDo we know there was no attempt at a kill?Jamiet99uk wrote: ↑Wed Aug 26, 2020 10:11 pmOh! Good point. I was so annoyed at being wrong on Damo I didn't notice there was no Mafia kill! Well at least that's a silver lining.Hellenic Riot wrote: ↑Wed Aug 26, 2020 10:08 pmSo when I said late changed might make scum waste their vote on the daykill, I was being especially prescient
Do you believe Jamie did not notice there was no mafia kill until HR mentioned it? Do you believe HR thought that the mafia targeting damo was the most likely reason for no mafia kill?
When I read the D1 resolution message, my immediate reaction was that the mafia must have tried to kill the BP. Then, HR implied that the scum likely targeted damo and wasted their kill because of a "late change". Then, Jamie said he did not notice there was no mafia kill. Then, you seemed to indicate you thought that it was possible no kill was attempted. I found all of this suspicious, because all of it could be scum trying to look like they did not know they targeted the BP.
Looking at this again, HR looks even more suspicious, because I find it hard to believe he thought the mafia could have ended D1 with their kill on damo.
##VOTE HR