Mafia 57 Matrix

[Jamiet99uk]

I like spreadsheets.

This seems like new information. I don't recall this coming up before, including when Squigs or I or others have talked about them. What information do you enter into your spreadsheet, Jamiet?

I just like them in general. I use them a lot at work and am apparently better than most of my colleagues at formatting them and using what I consider to be quite simple formulas.

I don't think I've made a Mafia tracking spreadsheet since we got the Bot.

[Tom Bombadil]

therul is probs town.

With scum daychat available I don’t think a scumbo who is newish(?) would accidentally vote the GM.

I think "teammates told him to be dumb" is equally plausible.

I do not.

[goldfinger0303]

I think you have it wrong, goldfinger0303. The Virus only wins after a daykill if that is their THIRD wincon achievement. If, by chance or otherwise, the daykill is the Virus D1, or Virus gets night killed by the agents without being redpilled, that is it for the Virus! Kaput! Adieu!

I understand that perfectly well and explained it in prior posts Bismark, but thank you for the attempted correction. It might be useful for others.

Tom, you're absolutely right, ghug should never be elevated to a level equal to yours. My bad :p

[Tom Bombadil]

therul is probs town.

With scum daychat available I don’t think a scumbo who is newish(?) would accidentally vote the GM.

I think "teammates told him to be dumb" is equally plausible.

I do not.

If teammates told him to be dumb, I don’t think he would have corrected himself so quickly. He would have let someone else correct him to play it off more visibly. This seems like an honest mistake. A mistake scum could make too, but if I were a new player with scum daychat I’d be running almost all of my thoughts and posts through that daychat before posting here.So I’m inclined to think he is town.

[ghug]

I think "teammates told him to be dumb" is equally plausible.

I do not.

If teammates told him to be dumb, I don’t think he would have corrected himself so quickly. He would have let someone else correct him to play it off more visibly. This seems like an honest mistake. A mistake scum could make too, but if I were a new player with scum daychat I’d be running almost all of my thoughts and posts through that daychat before posting here.So I’m inclined to think he is town.

I definitely see where you're coming from, I just think the alternative is plausible enough that it's not going to move my needle on him a lot.

Is this his first game?

[bozotheclown]

Who are you?

I have found that pretending to forget players is scum indicative.

##VOTE ghug

Do you think that Ghug actually forgot who Flash is?

What was your nickname for Ghug in high school, Bozo? Genuine question?

No, I do not think ghug forgot flash, but it was not completely clear to me if this was a joke or if he was pretending to not remember flash.

[bozotheclown]

So we're discussing whether the best strategy for Town is to ally with the Virus, help them to win, whilst also using the Virus to take shots at scum?

Sounds interesting.

It seems a no lose from tpov but 3p would be at constant risk of anti virus. Why would they e pose themselves thus? Maybe if they thought it was their only chance of recruitment. So let's hope we have a 3p lacking in confidence.

Considering the number of players, the 3P would have to be lucky to get randomly recruited at all, much less in time to complete his other tasks. I think making a deal to get recruited gives the 3P his best chance at winning.

[bozotheclown]

Hi all. I still stand by my ##vote emc. He should not be allowed to repeatedly ruin the games without penalty. It's not fun.

Welcome back ghug, I've heard a lot about you. I'm just catching up now, but you've already made me laugh twice in the few posts I've read.

I have found that voting for emc D1 is scum indicative.

##VOTE BunnyGo

That's only because I've drawn scum since emc got modkilled.

I did not mean it was scum indicative for you specifically, but it is scum indicative in general. I am not sure what you are referring to, I could not find a case where you voted for emc D1 as scum.

[Fluminator]

##GM Announcement

Vecna has requested replacement due to out of game reasons. We wish him the best.
A replacement will be coming in asap.

[TheFlyingBoat]

Well this is a lot better than last time where I fell behind 20 pages after not checking the thread until lunch. Time to catch up and find out who to flip. And by that I mean ##vote bozo. I did it last time to start Day 1 and we eventually got the right guy, so I'm confident it'll we work again.

[Jamiet99uk]

Best wishes to Vecna, I hope he is ok.

Gosh, I hope Chaqa hasn't done anything to his dog.

[DemonRHK]

ghug and goldie seems like a pointless dickwaving contest.

I don't really like damo's argument re:3p mechs. It almost comes off as scum loudly trying to dissuade a powerful combo from going off by the time town lynches the 3p the daychat won't matter as much, as (hopefully) we'd be down to one, maybe two scumbos

All this emc and newbie hate does seem like easy shots. Reminder that like fucking EVERYONE has a QT at this point that is active.

##Vote Damo

Ain't on much yet, but it's what my gut says for now.

[Jamiet99uk]

I guess the fact that nearly everyone is in a QT partly explains the slow pace so far.

But it does not explain our absentees.

[Hamilton Brian]

I do appreciate the continued analysis of the rules. I haven't had the time to deep dive into them. Given that we're a day away from turn's end, I'm okay with that.

So, there's some tension heating up between ghug, goldie, and TB. Good questions raised and I haven't seen goldie address ghug's question.

@goldie; besides me, who else are you scumreading? Why?
@ghug, you've voted for Macca. Is that a serious vote you'll maintain until something otherwise causes you to change it?

Poor emc; seems to be a constant over this game and the last.

[ghug]

I guess the fact that nearly everyone is in a QT partly explains the slow pace so far.

But it does not explain our absentees.

Nearly everyone? I'm the most important role, and I'm not.

[ghug]

I do appreciate the continued analysis of the rules. I haven't had the time to deep dive into them. Given that we're a day away from turn's end, I'm okay with that.

So, there's some tension heating up between ghug, goldie, and TB. Good questions raised and I haven't seen goldie address ghug's question.

@goldie; besides me, who else are you scumreading? Why?
@ghug, you've voted for Macca. Is that a serious vote you'll maintain until something otherwise causes you to change it?

Poor emc; seems to be a constant over this game and the last.

I've done what now?

[therul]

##unvote
sorry. dumb stuff. :)

What's your life story?

You quoted it.

[DemonRHK]

I guess the fact that nearly everyone is in a QT partly explains the slow pace so far.

But it does not explain our absentees.

Nearly everyone? I'm the most important role, and I'm not.

Dammit ghug we've been through this. I'M the most important role.

[ghug]

##CALLGM can I request not Chaqa please?

[Hamilton Brian]

I've done what now?

Shit, read the tracker wrong! Apologies. Now I need to read Macca to see why they voted for you, and to trace the whole exchange back between you and goldie to see what stood out for you to vote for them.