MAFIA 51 - LONDON BY GASLIGHT [HIDDEN]

[Jamiet99uk]

FULL PLAYER AND ROLE LIST

Tom Bombadil (WAS Vapourwave) = Sherlock Holmes, Detective
Kitsune = Dr Watson, Doctor
DemonRHK = Isabella Bird, Traveller
ND = Dr Jekyll, Day Doctor (and RagingIke = Mister Hyde)
ItsHosuke = Ada Lovelace, Gambler
EMC^42 = Charley Bates, Urchin

Damo666 = George Lusk, the Vanilla Londoner (male)
Xorxes = Joseph Aarons, the Vanilla Londoner (male)
Yavuzovic (WAS ComputerGenius) = Annie Chapman, the Vanilla Londoner (female)
Chaqa = Catherine Eddowes, the Vanilla Londoner (female)
BunnyGo = Charles Reeves, the Vanilla Londoner (male)
Temasek22 = Mary Jane Kelly, the Vanilla Londoner (female)
Frostwind = Elizabeth Stride, the Vanilla Londoner (female)
Purplecow = Thomas Bond, the Vanilla Londoner (male)
Flavius = Montague Druitt, the Vanilla Londoner (male)
CmdrLikely = Francis Tumbelty, the Vanilla Londoner (male)

BobMcBob = James Moriarty, Evil Genius
Rdrivera2005 = Colonel Moran, Strongman
BionicMole = Irene Adler, Goon

Bozotheclown = William Burke, Grave Robber
Vecna = William Hare, Roleblocker
KalelChase = Nelly McDougal, Goon

Dargorygel = Jack The Ripper
RagingIke = Mr Hyde

[FlaviusAetius]

@Jamje
I was a female

[Jamiet99uk]

@Jamje
I was a female

Hm, did we change you at the last minute? Ah well.

[FlaviusAetius]

Where’s the God and Mafia QT?

[Jamiet99uk]

For me this was a fun, if demanding game to GM. We didn't do a perfect job but I think the setup was actually quite balanced.

Vecna, Bozo, and Kalel played very well, in my opinion. Bozo recovered well from a genuine slip on D1.

Town made quite a few mistakes.

[Jamiet99uk]

The God QT:

https://www.quicktopic.com/52/H/Nyg5HHyKU84v

Mafia QT 1:

https://www.quicktopic.com/52/H/8uwGYK8gt8Ha2

Mafia QT 2:

https://www.quicktopic.com/52/H/UEDGx2GsnBc

[Vecna]

Thanks for hosting GM's. It was a fun game.

WP team.

We need to make sure this stuff with formatting of role PM's never occurs again though. That stuff suddenly creating 2 town VT's really impacted the game. It also probably directed us in switching to the -right- NK because Xorxes probably wouldve absolutely wrecked us the very next day.

[Vecna]

suddenly creating 2 town innocent childs*

[Jamiet99uk]

Thanks for hosting GM's. It was a fun game.

WP team.

We need to make sure this stuff with formatting of role PM's never occurs again though. That stuff suddenly creating 2 town VT's really impacted the game. It also probably directed us in switching to the -right- NK because Xorxes probably wouldve absolutely wrecked us the very next day.

It was our fault as GMs for missing the VT PM from the opening page.

I'm not sure any rule change is needed (or that it would help) - it was simply human error.

[KalelChase]

Well, my third time playing and second win (and I've never died). I've got one as town and one as scum (with team intact). To everyone tracking my meta... yes I am actually this clueless, it's not an act.

Thanks to Vecna and Bozo... good teammates.

Demon - sorry about your dad. You were very valuable from my town mind-set.

Purple - I'm on the same page three games in and I'm not sure I like it or will ever be good at it. I'm still a pawn (but not a newbie).

ND - learn a ton from you this game. Thank you!

Jamie & Worc - excellent flavor & immersion on this one. Theme adds so much fun.

Spreadsheet 4.0 for next game.

For anyone looking for the scumslip that freaked me out since I made it... it's here during my Bionic synopsis on Night 2;

Bionic synopsis as requested...

* * * *
That's all I got, but seems to be genuinely hunting.

Of course, as it's been pointed out, and probably one of the things that really messing with my weights... everyone can be scum hunting right now, so most everyone is going to be some percentage perceived as town. I thought two teams of town would be scarier because two kills, but it's really scarier because it's harder to tell them apart from us.

[xorxes]

Thanks for hosting GM's. It was a fun game.

WP team.

We need to make sure this stuff with formatting of role PM's never occurs again though. That stuff suddenly creating 2 town VT's really impacted the game. It also probably directed us in switching to the -right- NK because Xorxes probably wouldve absolutely wrecked us the very next day.

Bionic was already killing me anyway, and I think dargo's choice of Chaqa also had nothing to do with it.

But yeah, not posting the VT role PMs with the rest had an impact. Maybe bozo would not have outed himself if he had seen the VT role PMs.

Nobody but me paid any attention to it though.

[xorxes]

Well, my third time playing and second win (and I've never died). I've got one as town and one as scum (with team intact). To everyone tracking my meta... yes I am actually this clueless, it's not an act.

Well, this game it was at least in part an act. You will need to improve or we will lynch clueless Kalel every time now...

Spreadsheet 4.0 for next game.

You will be lynched and hammered as soon as you mention a spreadsheet again, so think about it carefully.

[worcej]

Also I'm not sure whether I had fun or not. I don't think this game is my kind of thing.

Sorry to hear that purple, Mafia isn't for everyone.

[Vecna]

Also, reading what actually happened all those nights with so little kills.....

pretty hilarious

[KalelChase]

Well, my third time playing and second win (and I've never died). I've got one as town and one as scum (with team intact). To everyone tracking my meta... yes I am actually this clueless, it's not an act.

Well, this game it was at least in part an act. You will need to improve or we will lynch clueless Kalel every time now...

Spreadsheet 4.0 for next game.

You will be lynched and hammered as soon as you mention a spreadsheet again, so think about it carefully.

Advice logged in the spreadsheet, sir!

Jamiet - the GM's note about the VT names is so cool.

My two favorite parts of the other Mafia teams thread;
Early discussing other players...
Bionic: "My ideas for killing were ND, Bunny and Flav. Flav because he talks alot and oddly is right about alot of things. Bunny because he has a thing for scumreading both of us. And ND because he is flat out a dick."

Much later...
Bionic: "Hello? cricket cricket"
Jamiet: "Sorry, BionicMole. You are the last of your team alive. You can still order your kill here."

[worcej]

Thanks for hosting GM's. It was a fun game.

WP team.

We need to make sure this stuff with formatting of role PM's never occurs again though. That stuff suddenly creating 2 town VT's really impacted the game. It also probably directed us in switching to the -right- NK because Xorxes probably wouldve absolutely wrecked us the very next day.

Yeah, it slipped through the cracks because of myself. I take full responsibility for the situation appearing.

However, bozo played masterfully to get out of it. Hats off to him.

[dargorygel]

Also, reading what actually happened all those nights with so little kills.....

pretty hilarious

The best part of dying was reading the night activities

[worcej]

Also, reading what actually happened all those nights with so little kills.....

pretty hilarious

It definitely was comical as a GM - we expected a lot more deaths than occurred...

[xorxes]

Most accurate "from the Mafia QT" ever:

From Mafia1 QT:

BionicMole: lol, how on earth did I survive that? Kill xorxes

From Mafia2 QT:

dargo: Can we kill xorxes already, please?
Vecna: It will look suspicious if he's killed before me.
bozo: He knows I'm not a VT, I will be forced to cc the Urchin if he is still alive.
Vecna: All right then. Kill xorxes

From Jack QT:

Flav: I think I will kill someone random just to confuse everyone. Let's see, eenie, meenie, miney, moe, kill xorxes

[dargorygel]

Most accurate "from the Mafia QT" ever:

From Mafia1 QT:

BionicMole: lol, how on earth did I survive that? Kill xorxes

From Mafia2 QT:

dargo: Can we kill xorxes already, please?
Vecna: It will look suspicious if he's killed before me.
bozo: He knows I'm not a VT, I will be forced to cc the Urchin if he is still alive.
Vecna: All right then. Kill xorxes

From Jack QT:

Flav: I think I will kill someone random just to confuse everyone. Let's see, eenie, meenie, miney, moe, kill xorxes

Other than me... and I just had no one to talk to.